My '17 Verlander (RL .149 OAV./172 OAV+) has an OAV of .396 in 12 appearances in the $110M league. He's 0-4 with an 11.32 ERA. Even for a small sample size, that's ludicrous. It's not even like he's a great pitcher. He's a phenomenal pitcher according to his RL stats. Three of his losses came in appearances in which he did not allow a homer. Most recently, he got two quick outs, then walk, single, single, single, two runs, blown save and loss.