After 7 tries I think I have a team under the cap - it's ugly and I cried leaving 2001 Bonds on the table...but this is it:
WC - 1980 Gary Lucas
1. Reds @ Cubs, 8/16/1940, 2nd game of doubleheader
Lonny Frey, Rabbit Warstler, Zeke Bonura, and Johnny Hutchings
2. Giants @ Diamondbacks, 8/30/2001
Benito Santiago, Shawon Dunston, Ramon Martinez, John Vanderwal
3. Cubs @ Giants, 5/4/1983
Atlee Hammaker, Lee Smith, Gary Lavelle, Johnny LeMaster
4. Tigers @ Orioles, 9/29/1963
Boog Powell, Joe Gaines, Wes Stock, Don Wert
5. Reds @ Pirates, 7/7/1971
Roberto Clemente, Tony Perez, Gary Nolan, Pat Corrales (player-manager for my group)
6. OF Lou Novikoff 1941-46
1943 version of the Mad Russian, Hi Bithom, Claude Passeau, Lon Warneke