Posted by moy23 on 9/24/2015 7:50:00 AM (view original):
Posted by bad_luck on 9/24/2015 12:34:00 AM (view original):
Raising taxes and cutting spending would shrink the economy. It's bad policy.
The deficit is already shrinking, almost entirely because the economy is growing. Current policy puts the deficit at zero in the next few years.
And what happens when the economy stops growing and debt continues to rise?
I didn't say pay off the entire debt but there is a healthy debt # and its not $18 trillion and rising. Pay down the debt now while times are good and revenues are at all time highs. Reform govt spending programs now while things are good and don't wait for the next shoe to drop. The economy will shrink again, by how much no one knows. Better to be prepared than to pretend the economy will always be growing. I've seen this model before where valuations on tech stocks were linear and expected to continually rise.... Remember the .com boom?
But hey - that's my non-expert opinion.
Going back to this...what makes you think the debt now is unhealthy?
You say you're in finance, would you consider it a crisis if someone had an income of $100,000 a year and also a mortgage of $100,000?
The reality is that we pay a very manageable amount of money every year servicing the debt, interest rates are low, and a large part of our economic security is tied to not purposefully shrinking the economy.
You ask what happens if the economy stops growing? We'd be in trouble. So we shouldn't purposefully tank the economy to try to pay back debt we owe (mostly) to ourselves. I say try because your plan would slow tax revenue, increase unemployment, and cause more people to need more government aid. We'd
have to increase the deficit to deal with that and suddenly it's 2008 again.
A better plan is to continue on the path we are on. The economy is growing and the deficit is shrinking. As long as we don't do something stupid (drastically cut spending and increase taxes, elect Trump, change to a flat tax, etc) we'll be fine.
Total debt really doesn't matter. Deficits are what need to be carefully managed. You can run them when you need to, but you don't always need to.