OK, if you have a PG who will be 90 speed, 100 PER/BH/PASS how low are you willing to accept ATH/DEF at high D1. I am talking about FF quality team.

Triangle Man

60/60and with out hesitation

If you want him to play more than 15 minutes then 75/75 otherwise 60/60 is fine for a bench 3 chucker.

Note: I overvalue ATH/DE

I'd like ath + def to be greater than or equal to 155.

60/60 for me as well

55 ATH / 68 DEF. I just think good opponents will pick him apart on defense and limit his minutes if you go any lower on DEF.

I was thinking 60 ath but closer to 75 def.

I thought I had some guards on my FF/E8 teams that were low ath/def but they actually had better def than I thought.

This guy

Or

This guy

https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerHistory/Ratings.aspx?pid=3504773

this guy avg’d 20+ Min 11pts 3.1 assists for my team that went 2nd rd, final loss, elite 8, sweet 16. He woulda started 3ish seasons but had to start freshmen

Depends on the role. And depends on the D

For a Man D, I'd say 60/60 for a small role.
For a press, I'd take him real low D/A to be a bench player for a top D1 program these days. He can get you 10 minutes of good ball with sub 50 ratings in each place unless you're already 12 deep.

Fast break press: D prestige DI. Do you like 60 ath 55 de 100 speed 92 per 90 bh 100 pa 100 stamina?

Posted by cubcub113 on 11/6/2017 12:20:00 PM (view original):
Fast break press: D prestige DI. Do you like 60 ath 55 de 100 speed 92 per 90 bh 100 pa 100 stamina?

He's going to get in a lot of foul trouble with that ATH / DEF, but obviously will also generate a ton of offense, both for himself and teammates. I'd take him, as long as you're comfortable with him being a quality 6th man for his whole career.

Posted by bhansalid00 on 11/7/2017 10:55:00 AM (view original):

Posted by cubcub113 on 11/6/2017 12:20:00 PM (view original):
Fast break press: D prestige DI. Do you like 60 ath 55 de 100 speed 92 per 90 bh 100 pa 100 stamina?

He's going to get in a lot of foul trouble with that ATH / DEF, but obviously will also generate a ton of offense, both for himself and teammates. I'd take him, as long as you're comfortable with him being a quality 6th man for his whole career.

That’s an elite offensive guard, I would absolutely take him in D1. And his speed will net you lots of turnovers with the press, so he’s not a complete defensive liability. Utilization is key, and you have some options, especially with press. It’s tougher to target a weak defender against the press. You can mitigate his defensive deficiency further by using him as a super-sub, the #2 guy on the depth chart at pg-sg-sf, so he’s not coming in at a predictable position, which can also make him harder to defend.