Here are their regular season sim stats...
1B: 1885 Cap Anson - Fielding% = .992 (13 errors, 28 + plays)
2B: 1886 Bid McPhee - Fielding% = .986 (12 errors, 25 + plays, 1 - play)
3B: 1887 Jerry Denny - Fielding% = .953 (25 errors, 21 + plays, 1 - play)
SS: 1887 Jack Glasscock - Fielding% = .950 (42 errors, 15 + plays, 1 - play)
CF: 1888 Tommy McCarthy - Fielding% = .970 (11 errors, 20 + plays)
RF/LF: 1887 Harry Stovey - Fielding% = .985 (5 errors, 14 + plays)
LF: 1890 Eddie Burke - Fielding% = .980 (4 errors*, 15 + plays)
* Burke only played 111 games b/c I had a AAA outfielder who was significantly better than Burke offensively.
C: 1971 Thruman Munson threw out 36 of 56 runners (.643).
That's a total of 138 "+" plays and 3 "-" plays and 112 errors.