Assuming they're both the same age(meaning same scouting), I think your scouting is horribly off. 35 pts VL seems impossible. That said, based on your scouting, I'd take player 2. We'll go past the obvious 100 power, which is infinitely better than 80, and start with spd/BR. Both are high speed but player 2 projects to better baserunning. He'll get caught stealing less. He has 8 pts in range already. He'll have better range when they're done. At 71, he should at least make mid-80s. That means he'll be able to play anywhere but SS(that 49 glove isn't gaining 36 points). His contact is weak but he should have a better eye(based on projections) so his OBP should be similar. Major drawback in health/dur but I think the rest of his ratings make it worth a shot. Put 20m in medical/training and roll with it. All that said, if either of them throw lefty, take the other guy.