First, 14m is a bit iffy. It's good enough to draft with but there will be times when you go "Dammit. He sucks!!"
1, His range or glove might be keeping him at DH. A 3/10 will auto-list him as DH. I don't care about that, he can catch if the arm/PC are close. Dude is a stud hitter even if ratings are reduced by 10%. Low make-up will hurt his development. I like him but fully understand he might be 80/85/70/80/85 as a hitter. If he gets all 60s in arm/PC, you've got a stud catcher.
2. The 62/95 split is a sign. Most likely, he somewhere in the middle. 75/77 isn't an ace. 19 durability sucks and his pitches don't look good(although if he ended up 72/80/68/72, he'd overperform). Of the ones you've listed, I have him 4th.
3. C-B-A with the pitcher listed ahead of the 2B. The 49 VR is death to me. 62-66% of the pitchers he face will be RH.
You didn't list handedness with the batters but LH is better.
With all that, I'd delete my post if I were you. Your leaguemates can read it. I'll leave my response.