And the finger pointing already starts... LOL
First off, I've said it before, and it's pointless to say since no one believes it, not that anyone should anyways, but:
I AM NOT MAFIA SCUM. I actually was hoping I would be after seeing mudda and csudak join, because murdering mudda is always fun (see the lynching in game 1), but whatever.
I think what we need to know (because its not in the rules) is if the doctor is allowed to reveal himself or not. Last game he wasn't able to until halfway through the game... The first thing that has to happen is somehow the COP And DOCTOR need to hook up (without ever coming forward of course, so the mafia has no clue). The only chance we have of winning is protecting the cop. The rest of us are all just sheep in the herd protecting the one person that is our ticket for not guessing. The cop should investigate someone, and I think that person should be the middle man between the two... AS long as the mafia doesn't know who the cop is, then it is a guessing game.
of course that is all a mute point if the doctor can't say anything....