Here are the three combinations chosen more than once...

Owner_________	League	Winning%	Clones	Players
bighooze	6A	0.690	3	Babe Ruth, Lou Boudreau, Mariano Rivera
contrarian23	6D	0.500	3	Babe Ruth, Lou Boudreau, Mariano Rivera
muckles6	6C	0.538	3	Pedro Martinez, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby
batandball	6C	0.525	3	Pedro Martinez, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby
footballmm11	6A	0.544	3	Babe Ruth, Dennis Eckersley, Lou Boudreau
rls1	6D	0.348	3	Babe Ruth, Dennis Eckersley, Lou Boudreau

Here is a breakdown by number of clones selected...

Owner_________	League	Winning%	Clones	Players
tracyr	6A	0.437	2	Pedro Martinez, Rogers Hornsby

Owner_________	League	Winning%	Clones	Players
bighooze	6A	0.690	3	Babe Ruth, Lou Boudreau, Mariano Rivera
bardin	6A	0.608	3	Pedro Martinez, Roger Bresnahan, Rogers Hornsby
jfranco77	6A	0.595	3	King Kelly, Pedro Martinez, Rogers Hornsby
alleyviper	6C	0.589	3	Honus Wagner, Jimmie Foxx, Pedro Martinez
tjefferson	6A	0.589	3	Jimmie Foxx, Pedro Martinez, Tim Raines
dahsdebater	6B	0.551	3	Pedro Martinez, David Ross, Honus Wagner
shaybee	6D	0.551	3	Babe Ruth, Jimmie Foxx, Mariano Rivera
footballmm11	6A	0.544	3	Babe Ruth, Dennis Eckersley, Lou Boudreau
muckles6	6C	0.538	3	Pedro Martinez, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby
batandball	6C	0.525	3	Pedro Martinez, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby
dougpalm	6A	0.513	3	Pedro Martinez, Earl Smith, Honus Wagner
contrarian23	6D	0.500	3	Babe Ruth, Lou Boudreau, Mariano Rivera
just4me	6C	0.500	3	John Smoltz, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby
Average		0.493	3
odalisgagne	6C	0.468	3	Honus Wagner, Lave Cross, Pedro Martinez
fooolishfool	6B	0.462	3	Pedro Martinez, Rogers Hornsby, Tris Speaker
rmdriskill	6B	0.462	3	Ed Walsh, Jimmie Foxx, Howard Johnson
Dalefan1	6A	0.430	3	Pedro Martinez, Jimmie Foxx, Tony Phillips
tdoak	6B	0.430	3	Babe Ruth, Dennis Eckersley, Lave Cross
chargingryno	6D	0.399	3	Dennis Eckersley, Jimmie Foxx, Nap Lajoie
leeelci	6C	0.399	3	Nap Lajoie, Pedro Martinez, Ted Simmons
rls1	6D	0.348	3	Babe Ruth, Dennis Eckersley, Lou Boudreau
shadoworkcat	6B	0.329	3	John Smoltz, Lou Boudreau, Pete Rose
beirnej1	6B	0.310	3	Babe Ruth, John Smoltz, Pete Rose

Owner_________	League	Winning%	Clones	Players
schwarze	6C	0.652	4	Pedro Martinez, Mike Redmond, Rogers Hornsby, Tim Raines
yankeeso7	6D	0.633	4	Christy Mathewson, Honus Wagner, Mariano Rivera, Sandy Alomar Jr.
ryan_horner	6C	0.627	4	Greg Maddux, Honus Wagner, Jimmie Foxx, Tim Raines
mpitt76	6B	0.608	4	Mordecai Brown, Mariano Rivera, Joe Ferguson, Nap Lajoie
bigmc	6D	0.601	4	Babe Adams, Babe Ruth, Rogers Hornsby, Todd Greene
jjgreen14	6D	0.601	4	Greg Maddux, Lou Boudreau, Mariano Rivera, Pete Rose
tridentric	6C	0.601	4	Bert Campaneris, Dennis Eckersley, Pete Alexander, Pete Rose
profcake	6B	0.595	4	Babe Ruth, Bip Roberts, Mariano Rivera, Ted Simmons
hacker7	6C	0.582	4	Goose Goslin, Joe Mauer, Pedro Martinez, Rogers Hornsby
jbohrman	6B	0.582	4	Addie Joss, Mariano Rivera, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby
tulsaslide	6C	0.582	4	Pedro Martinez, Mariano Rivera, Jimmie Foxx, Tony Phillips
newarkwilder	6D	0.576	4	Babe Adams, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby, Tim Raines
mllama54	6C	0.563	4	Darrell Porter, John Smoltz, Rogers Hornsby, Ty Cobb
sgsmith	6B	0.557	4	Mordecai Brown, Mariano Rivera, Jimmie Foxx, Tim Raines
loma_prieta	6A	0.551	4	Pedro Martinez, Carlton Fisk, Alex Rodriguez, Tim Raines
rbow923	6C	0.551	4	Mordecai Brown, Todd Pratt, Rogers Hornsby, Babe Ruth
mildnhazy	6B	0.544	4	Greg Maddux, Mariano Rivera, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby
Relkcirts	6A	0.544	4	Aaron Miles, Dennis Eckersley, Greg Maddux, Jimmie Foxx
ballantine	6A	0.538	4	Gregg Zaun, Mordecai Brown, Rogers Hornsby, Ty Cobb
ncih	6C	0.538	4	Greg Maddux, Jimmie Foxx, Honus Wagner, Rickey Henderson
wetwillytwo	6D	0.538	4	Greg Maddux, Jimmie Foxx, Luke Appling, Mariano Rivera
ejstockman	6D	0.532	4	Arthur Rhodes, Babe Adams, Craig Biggio, Rickey Henderson
elvisgump	6B	0.525	4	Pedro Martinez, Jimmie Foxx, Toby Harrah, Dave Henderson
gorbyruss	6A	0.519	4	Greg Maddux, King Kelly, Trevor Hoffman, Ty Cobb
calhoop	6D	0.513	4	Babe Adams, Babe Ruth, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby
dippedncrack	6A	0.513	4	Babe Adams, Mariano Rivera, Mike Redmond, Nap Lajoie
SpotSell	6B	0.513	4	Cy Young, Honus Wagner, Mike Piazza, Trevor Hoffman
zephyr1949	6B	0.513	4	Mordecai Brown, Mariano Rivera, Joe Torre, Robin Yount
marlowe	6A	0.506	4	Pedro Martinez, Jimmie Foxx, Joe Cronin, Mel Ott
nhsteven	6A	0.506	4	Babe Ruth, Jimmie Foxx, Rich Gossage, Rogers Hornsby
Average		0.502	4
mensu1954	6B	0.500	4	Greg Maddux, Jimmie Foxx, Mariano Rivera, Placido Polanco
cstrohmier	6B	0.494	4	Honus Wagner, Jim Beauchamp, Jimmie Foxx, Walter Johnson
eman_wi	6D	0.487	4	Honus Wagner, Mike Redmond, Pedro Martinez, Tim Raines
31013	6A	0.475	4	Greg Maddux, Mariano Rivera, Joe Torre, Rickey Henderson
Chisock	6D	0.475	4	Dennis Eckersley, Hank Aaron, Lou Boudreau, Randy Johnson
elonsmitty	6B	0.475	4	Babe Adams, Sandy Alomar Jr., Rogers Hornsby, Babe Ruth
forte4him	6B	0.475	4	Dennis Eckersley, Greg Maddux, Neifi Perez, Pete Rose
Donburgh	6C	0.468	4	Babe Adams, Billy Wagner, Craig Biggio, Honus Wagner
bigsteve12	6A	0.462	4	Honus Wagner, John Smoltz, Mariano Rivera, Mike Lieberthal
zlionsfan	6D	0.462	4	Ed Kirkpatrick, Honus Wagner, Rich Gossage, Roger Clemens
id_203	6D	0.456	4	Babe Adams, Don Pavletich, Rogers Hornsby, Tris Speaker
besterateam	6B	0.449	4	Pedro Martinez, Babe Phelps, Nap Lajoie, Babe Ruth
Jtpsops	6D	0.449	4	Jimmie Foxx, Michael Young, Pedro Martinez, Tim Raines
gigrant	6C	0.437	4	Hughie Jennings, Jack O'Connor, John Smoltz, Pete Rose
holleybard	6B	0.437	4	Pedro Martinez, Mike Lieberthal, Rogers Hornsby, Babe Ruth
markeking	6D	0.430	4	Jimmie Foxx, Pedro Martinez, Rogers Hornsby, Ted Williams
toddcommish	6A	0.424	4	Jimmie Foxx, Joe Nathan, Rogers Hornsby, Walter Johnson
slightner	6B	0.418	4	Honus Wagner, Mariano Rivera, Rogers Hornsby, Walter Johnson
spikeboots	6D	0.418	4	Babe Ruth, Lou Boudreau, Mariano Rivera, Walter Johnson
oskies	6C	0.411	4	Addie Joss, Honus Wagner, Jimmie Foxx, Mike Mordecai
thejuice6	6C	0.411	4	Mordecai Brown, Mariano Rivera, Bill Dickey, Rogers Hornsby
mw100	6D	0.354	4	Babe Adams, Jimmie Foxx, Juan Castro, Nap Lajoie
happyhours	6C	0.348	4	Joe Torre, Pedro Martinez, Robin Yount, Rogers Hornsby
thebubbaq	6A	0.316	4	Randy Johnson, Phil Niekro, Maury Wills, Hank Aaron
Poddy	6A	0.285	4	Dennis Eckersley, Jimmie Foxx, John Smoltz, Pete Rose

Owner_________	League	Winning%	Clones	Players
brianjw	6B	0.684	5	Greg Maddux, Honus Wagner, Jimmie Foxx, Mariano Rivera, Tim Raines
buddhagamer	6A	0.627	5	Babe Ruth, Butch Wynegar, Mariano Rivera, Mordecai Brown, Rogers Hornsby
ybjsports	6D	0.601	5	Ed Walsh, Jimmie Foxx, Mariano Rivera, Neifi Perez, Tim Raines
cubbies84	6C	0.582	5	Greg Maddux, Mariano Rivera, Jack Clements, Howard Johnson, Tim Raines
crystalao	6C	0.551	5	Greg Maddux, Jack Pfiester, Norm Charlton, Craig Biggio, Willie Mays
discodemo	6D	0.551	5	Ed Walsh, Mike Piazza, Rogers Hornsby, Trevor Hoffman, Tris Speaker
beauchamp	6D	0.544	5	Dick Hall, Greg Maddux, Jimmie Foxx, Ozzie Smith, Tim Raines
Average		0.511	5
dlchow	6D	0.506	5	Billy Wagner, Damion Easley, Jimmie Foxx, Kevin Brown, Tim Raines
sford	6A	0.487	5	Pedro Martinez, Mariano Rivera, King Kelly, Rogers Hornsby, Tris Speaker
daronb	6B	0.475	5	Greg Maddux, Pedro Martinez, Gene Tenace, Ozzie Smith, Tim Raines
Jdh34	6D	0.475	5	Addie Joss, Babe Ruth, Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby, Tom Henke
jrnyfan01	6C	0.399	5	Randy Johnson, Sandy Alomar Jr., Nap Lajoie, Alex Rodriguez, Amos Otis
DarthDurron	6C	0.348	5	Barry Bonds, Hal Lanier, Joe Torre, Sandy Koufax, Trevor Hoffman
jbar8888	6C	0.329	5	Addie Joss, Billy Wagner, Phil Gagliano, Rogers Hornsby, Ty Cobb

Owner_________	League	Winning%	Clones	Players
blackmink18	6B	0.614	6	Don Sutton, Frankie Frisch, Jose Vizcaino, Mariano Rivera, Tim Raines, Victor Martinez
trd3	6A	0.494	6	Craig Biggio, George Davis, Mariano Rivera, Pedro Martinez, Ron Guidry, Tim Raines
Average		0.485	6
spoonfed	6A	0.348	6	Cy Young, Harry Krause, Joe Mauer, Joe Nathan, Marty McManus, Tris Speaker

Here is an average winning percentage by clone selected...

Player____________	Teams	AvgWin%
Jimmie Foxx	35	0.511
Rogers Hornsby	31	0.508
Pedro Martinez	28	0.506
Mariano Rivera	27	0.547
Babe Ruth	18	0.501
Tim Raines	16	0.562
Honus Wagner	16	0.520
Greg Maddux	15	0.546
Babe Adams	9	0.499
Dennis Eckersley	9	0.456
Lou Boudreau	8	0.488
Mordecai Brown	7	0.544
Nap Lajoie	7	0.446
Pete Rose	7	0.434
John Smoltz	7	0.412
Tris Speaker	5	0.461
Craig Biggio	4	0.511
Ty Cobb	4	0.487
Trevor Hoffman	4	0.483
Addie Joss	4	0.449
Walter Johnson	4	0.439
Joe Torre	4	0.421
Mike Redmond	3	0.551
Ed Walsh	3	0.538
King Kelly	3	0.534
Rickey Henderson	3	0.515
Sandy Alomar Jr.	3	0.502
Billy Wagner	3	0.434
Randy Johnson	3	0.397
Neifi Perez	2	0.538
Mike Piazza	2	0.532
Howard Johnson	2	0.522
Ozzie Smith	2	0.510
Tony Phillips	2	0.506
Ted Simmons	2	0.497
Rich Gossage	2	0.484
Alex Rodriguez	2	0.475
Joe Mauer	2	0.465
Mike Lieberthal	2	0.450
Lave Cross	2	0.449
Cy Young	2	0.431
Robin Yount	2	0.431
Hank Aaron	2	0.396
Joe Nathan	2	0.386
Christy Mathewson	1	0.633
Butch Wynegar	1	0.627
Don Sutton	1	0.614
Frankie Frisch	1	0.614
Jose Vizcaino	1	0.614
Victor Martinez	1	0.614
Joe Ferguson	1	0.608
Roger Bresnahan	1	0.608
Bert Campaneris	1	0.601
Pete Alexander	1	0.601
Todd Greene	1	0.601
Bip Roberts	1	0.595
Goose Goslin	1	0.582
Jack Clements	1	0.582
Darrell Porter	1	0.563
Carlton Fisk	1	0.551
David Ross	1	0.551
Jack Pfiester	1	0.551
Norm Charlton	1	0.551
Todd Pratt	1	0.551
Willie Mays	1	0.551
Aaron Miles	1	0.544
Dick Hall	1	0.544
Gregg Zaun	1	0.538
Luke Appling	1	0.538
Arthur Rhodes	1	0.532
Dave Henderson	1	0.525
Toby Harrah	1	0.525
Earl Smith	1	0.513
Damion Easley	1	0.506
Joe Cronin	1	0.506
Kevin Brown	1	0.506
Mel Ott	1	0.506
Placido Polanco	1	0.500
George Davis	1	0.494
Jim Beauchamp	1	0.494
Ron Guidry	1	0.494
Gene Tenace	1	0.475
Tom Henke	1	0.475
Ed Kirkpatrick	1	0.462
Roger Clemens	1	0.462
Don Pavletich	1	0.456
Babe Phelps	1	0.449
Michael Young	1	0.449
Hughie Jennings	1	0.437
Jack O'Connor	1	0.437
Ted Williams	1	0.430
Bill Dickey	1	0.411
Mike Mordecai	1	0.411
Amos Otis	1	0.399
Juan Castro	1	0.354
Barry Bonds	1	0.348
Hal Lanier	1	0.348
Harry Krause	1	0.348
Marty McManus	1	0.348
Sandy Koufax	1	0.348
Phil Gagliano	1	0.329
Maury Wills	1	0.316
Phil Niekro	1	0.316

Sometimes, bold moves pay off:

GorbyRuss is 82-76 with 4 clones - Cobb, King Kelly, Hoffman and Maddux

SS King Kelly has 165 errors and 27 minus plays
2B Ty Cobb has 102 errors and 28 minus plays

Tjefferson is 93-65 with Jimmie Foxx playing SS 

(34 Foxx is unrated at SS, is a B/A+ 1B, and has 51 errors but only 6 minus plays)

BigHooze is 109-49 with a 3-man team of Rivera/Boudreau/Ruth

'96 Rivera, despite having a RL IP/G of 1.76, has started 45 games and thrown 38.8 pitches per game... he has a 3.47 ERA for the year.

That really makes me feel like an underachiever...my 3-man Rivera/Boudreau/Ruth team is 79-79 and won't make the playoffs.

In my "team building analysis", I mention that I was trying a Ruth / Boudreau team but couldn't get it to work.  I never considered adding Rivera to the mix (as I was focused on getting 3 Babe Ruth SPs).  The salary was too darn high.

Amazing job by bighooze.

I was shocked by the results in this league - what worked and what didn't....I'm also a little ****** off at my performance given I had the 2nd highest exp winning percentage among the 24 teams in my league (after brianjw) but I'm not even going to sniff the playoffs......

I used the 3 Ruth SPs, and they did about as well as I expected, maybe even a little better.  Rivera was a major disappointment across the board.  And the 2 Boudreaus I spent big $ on really did not deliver anywhere close to the production I would have needed.

Thanks...sure I'll get swept in the first round...(excuse the blatant attempt at fending off the inscrutable sim gods)