Posted by MikeT23 on 1/14/2013 3:53:00 PM (view original):
While the fan's vote is just a popularity contest, the A/S bench is filled out by people who know baseball.

In his 15 year career, he made the A/S game 4 times.    He wasn't even the best 1B in his league for his entire career.

the top 1% is the right size

there are under 300 in the Hall

there are maybe 15000 that played

so we are basically there



what should happen is a team of retired judges should meet once a year and consider one player to remove and one player to replace him with

they would get a crash course in basebology most of them

all you f*cknuts could make your arguments for six months

the judges would ruminate for six months, maybe talk amongst themselves, fire briefs back and forth, call each other names like imbecile and applejohn

and accept or reject the substitution



the writers and the veterans would just have to suck it when their applecart got upset by the cazy crackpot outside world