Burnsy, i have no clue why you are even responding to this nitwit. He clearly doesn't want a logical argument. I mean, he even stated that he didn't watch a single second of the video you posted.
I didn't watch the video because I don't have time to watch it when I'm on a computer that actually has the capability of watching it.
No way Brady is top five. To say there are 12 or 13 qb's playing today that are better than him is Swampcrazy.
There is a post somewhere earlier in this thread where I listed the QBs I think are at least equal with Brady if not better overall. Some of them there is no question they are better than him, the others can be questioned but I think while he is good at some things, they are good enough and exceed him in other areas.
Are Young and Montana overrated? System QB's?
Yes, Montana is over rated and a system QB. He's not nearly as over rated as Brady, but he is absolutely over rated by most people.
As for Young, he made plays with his arms and his legs on a regular basis that demonstrated he was more than just a system QB. I'd say Young is better than Montana even though he only has one ring from starting.
The number of SB wins isn't the only measure of a QB - and I'd argue that while it means something, how much the number of SBs a TEAM wins with a QB under center is an over rated measure of how great the QB actually is. Trent Dilfer and Young both have one ring while starting - Young is far superior. Dan Marino has zero rings and only one SB appearance (as a rookie) - he was still a phenomenal QB, better than many guys who have SB rings.
Please. Brady is clearly a top 5 with the potential to be the top QB if his stats continue for a few more years at this level and he wins another SB. He has to win a 4th SB to be considered the best though.
He's not even top five right now in the NFL. Top ten right now, maybe, depending upon what you value in a QB.
All time he's not even worth mentioning in the top 20. There are just too many guys who were far away better than him.
My top five are: Montana, Graham, Elway, Unitas, Brady...In the next group are: Manning, Young, Marino
Ladies and gentlemen, yet another example of how Brady is EXTREMELY OVER RATED.
There is no way he holds a candle to any of those guys, including the ones you put "in the next group". They are all so much better than him it is laughable to even mention him among them as far as I'm concerned.
Think of him like Peyton Manning with running skills.
I'd say Manning is better than Young because of his amazing ability to change plays at the line of scrimmage, but I'd agree Young is close to what you say here. I've always said he is better than Montana but Montana gets the credit for more rings. It's funny to me people compare Montana to Brady and I think to myself "yeah, SB wins make them both over rated."