I find it hard to argue with 3 Super Bowl rings and 5 appearances, and I hate the guy with a passion.
I don't care how many times your team carries you to titles or a chance at titles - if I'm going to agree you're a great QB, you have to show you have more than slightly above average skills. You also have to show you can do more than ride the coat tails of your team mates and take all the credit just for being the QB.
He was constantly under pressure against the Giants in the Super Bowl, so I assume when he led his team to the go-ahead score with 1:40 to go, he made plays under pressure.
His team mates finally began to carry him. That's what happened. His O-line finally held up on occasion and gave him time to find his amazing receivers.
I'm not naming any great plays other players have made because that's not what we're discussing here.
In fact, I'm done with this for now, and perhaps altogether.
Brady is over rated and always will be. I won't ever change my mind on that unless he starts living up to his hype, and to do that he'd have to be god himself so it ain't gonna happen.