Posted by stinenavy on 2/21/2013 11:21:00 AM (view original):
I don't get the Rodgers pick. If he gets discount double-checked into on-coming traffic he doesn't even make the Hall of Fame with his current record of accomplishment.
You have to just project things that haven't happened to say he's 7th All-Time. Perhaps you should pick RGIII next.
Go back to the first post. It doesn't say we're judging entire careers. Obviously
if we're judging entire careers I can't take Rodgers. If you go by that measure, you can't take Manning over Brady. If you go by that measure, we're already talking about Aikman.
I read this as judging skills
. If we're willing to say that Unitas would easily be able to dominate in today's style of game and not have that judged, then I have to just as easily go backward and say that Rodgers has just as many skills as anyone else at the #7 spot.
It's all about argument, and anyone else I picked at the #7 would have generated an argument of some kind. Brees? Marino? Favre