Honestly, the "freedom to live the life they want" argument kind of sucks. Animals are deemed property. I don't give a **** how much you love your dog, if you and the wife get divorced, the judge will look at the dog in the same light as he does your coffee table. So, if "the life you want to live" includes ******* your family pet, I can't think of anyone who'll say "What's the harm? It doesn't affect you."