Tough call.
I'd go with the position player at #1.  the fact that he's a switch hitter helps his values greatly, as does his speed.  He's a .280/.360/.520 monster who will steal 25+ bases a year and play gold glove defense at 3b.

I usually would say go with the pitcher, but I'd put him 2nd.  For some reason, starters with only 3 pitches tend to underperform.  As do pitchers with velocity under 20.  He will be a good pitcher, but the position player has a chance to be a MVP.