No one should be mentioning anyone else's recruits in the CC while recruiting is ongoing. Never know what information might be infered by another coach reading.

Best advice is to shut-the-hell-up while recruiting is ongoing ... then there is no problem.

Comments can be made when recruiting is finished. 

I think its a shame that shut the hell up appears to be the required posture.  Banter is fun - so long as no meaningful info is communication, no collusion is suggested or enabled.

Admin said in reply to colonels situation - see the other thread - that the posting complained about here was a problem because "Posting recruiting information, specifically money spent, is a violation of our FairPlay Guidelines."

pretty darn minimal information in the posting - I concede it is more than zero.

so this means posting things like "good luck in our battle" or "wow, look at those great recruits in Alaska" or "I need to get me some bigs" are all forbidden.  Aarg.

I've always assumed (and read in that thread from 4 years ago that I bumped) that "table talk" of any kind was frowned upon, that's why I never said anything in regards to my own battles until after recruiting was over.  If you need to talk **** to win recruits, that's kinda weak if you ask me...I'm not opposed to it, but if you need to use scare tactics then...

People have the weirdest perspectives.

I'm going to talk more then ever next recruiting period, lol. Just because this is so absurdly silly. I can't wait for people to get upset about how much I'm talking, since there are a decent % of guys who think you shouldn't talk at all. 

You want to talk about others recruits  ... send site mail. Keep it out of the coaches corner where all can read.

I think recruiting talk in the CC or sitemail is akin to your right to freedom of speech. You can pretty much say what you want until you violate someone else's rights. Then you're open to all kinds of litigation. If something you post in the CC leads to another coach losing out on a recruit that's not really fair to the other coach regardless of their recruiting situation.