I'm just going to come forward and say who I am, because the time is ripe and, like csudak, I'm almost positive that awags is the mafia member we're looking for.
I believe that I am the INSANE COP.
Out of sheer dumb luck, I investigated awags on the first night, and he came up innocent. However, I thought this was extremely suspicious because of the way awags was acting in the forums. He never accepted Polabonez' claim as doctor, even though nobody step forward to challenge him. He has consistently been sowing seeds of doubt among us townies, which so far we have successfully ignored.
So, tonight, I investigated the other person claiming to be cop (I will not reveal the name for his sake; he can feel free to do so if he wants) and he came up GUILTY. Meanwhile, he investigated awags and the ruling was also GUILTY. This can only mean one thing. Either awags is the REAL COP, and he's been doing an awful job of playing this game (which we all know is extremely unlikely), or the other cop is telling the truth and awags is a mafia member.
I think it's a pretty easy decision at this point. I'm just glad I figured out I was insane early.
Might as well get the ball rolling. I vote to lynch awags.