Posted by Got_Worms on 7/17/2014 2:13:00 PM (view original):
I'd also say Troy Tulowitzki but the trade rumors seem to be rampant with him.
Do you think Jimmy Rollins has a better HOF case than Chase Utley?
Utley >> Rollins, but I do think Rollins ends up getting more HOF consideration due to being a SS and the length of his career.
Utley was always going to need a lot to go right with his career to build a HOF resume since he didn't become an everyday starter until he was 26, and it didn't happen for it. If his knees don't cut his peak short, he could have had that kind of trajectory, but at this point his peak was too short and his career is also going to be pretty short by the standards of HOF candidates.