52M Rosters & Commentary v47 Topic

I know exactly who you mean.  He won't make it through the third round.
11/10/2014 11:11 PM
So McAdoo and DeAndre vs Wilt and the Mailman. I give the edge to logain for sure. But who can he draft in round 4 that won't get completely destroyed by MJ???
11/11/2014 1:35 AM
O.K. time for evals. This is my first time doing it so guy's please don't expect too much.
I'll keep my comments brief and when all picks have been made give a final grade like
Ash and a few others did.
11/11/2014 4:50 AM
1. LOGAIN
Well what can I say Wilt and the Mailman wow!
Logain is too smart an owner to screw that combo
up. I only hope I don't end up in the same division.
O.K. now we finish up with Ray Allen Charlie Ward
Weatherspoon, Hinrich to follow up Ward and Stoudemire
off the bench at the 4 and or 5 spot. Final Grade: A
11/19/2014 7:51 PM (edited)
2. STEELERS
LeBron and Oscar in the backcourt, I think I
like it. I've never used those two but it looks
like you've got it covered back there. Now
let's see who you place up front with Grant.
I like Maxwell and Oakley up front with Grant.
Artest and Art Williams off the bench works for
me as well. Final Grade: B+.
11/19/2014 8:11 PM (edited)
3. McDARSH
Rodman is a very good first round pick.
He gives great rebounding and plays a
clean game with low usage so as not to
get in the way of the higher usage scorers
you didn't place around him. With Buck Williams
and Mutombo, you have a ton of rebounding but
way too low usage up front. Now you have to make
up for it with high usage scoring backcourt players.
I like Harden at SG, Faried is O.K. I know you needed
usage in the backcourt but Arenas and Rose are not
good sim players. Too high usage with too low EFG%.
Final Grade: C-
11/20/2014 3:54 AM (edited)
4. VANCE
I like this team so far. Jordan the anchor in the backcourt
and of course the team, and I like the combo of McAdoo
and Deandre up front. But I don't think it's going to be a
match for Logain's squad. Sorry Vance. O.K. now you mix
in Nick Anderson with M.J., and A.C. at SF love it! Gadzuric
and Tinsley off the bench solid. Final Grade: B+
11/20/2014 4:05 AM (edited)
Thanks, sixer - keep 'em coming!

I agree, mcdarsh is going to have to get a bit lucky in later rounds.  It won't be easy later on to find high usage guards who score, pass, and don't have glaring weaknesses.

And yes, logain is starting out with a great duo, but it's too early to tremble.  It's still a serpentine draft with a salary cap.

I don't really get the pairing of Lebron and Oscar.  This will be interesting.

11/11/2014 9:55 AM
Ginobili is great value in the third round...
11/11/2014 9:55 AM
super great value
11/11/2014 10:37 AM
I kind of looked at MJ and Manu for a minute but McAdoo can go for 40 mpg in this league. Now MJ can't be doubled. I was very surprised to see McAdoo get into the 3rd round.
11/11/2014 10:45 AM
u often draft mcadoo
11/11/2014 2:14 PM
5. MIKEE1
I like Kareem as your first pick, and Manu as the 3rd was a steal,
but I'm not sure about Camby. I like his Rebounding and DEF in
one particular season, but not his low EFG% and low minuets.
Excellent job rounding out the team with Mason, Sanders, and
Christie. Final Grade: B
11/21/2014 4:17 AM (edited)
6.LONGTALLBRAD
Love Dwight Howard and Walton together,
but something tells me you should have gone
for a guard with your third round pick. Still
Kirilenko is solid. Now what will you have
to choose from for your backcourt at pick's
91&102? Terry Porter and Alvin Robertson
great picks. Sabonis and McMillan solid off
the bench. Final Grade: B
11/21/2014 4:20 AM (edited)
7.MAGLOR1
Like Chris Paul as your first pick, can't go
wrong with him. I'm luke warm about Josh
Smith, and I don't like Kemp at all, too many
fouls for my taste. But what do I know. Nate
Thurmond is not a good sim player,too low EFG%.
Buse has one or two decent seasons where he
has good ast% at low usage and very good DEF
but his EFG% is not good either. Chris Mullin
is a solid sim player but I'm afraid he won't be
enough help. Final Grade: D
11/21/2014 4:25 AM (edited)
◂ Prev 1|2|3|4...10 Next ▸
52M Rosters & Commentary v47 Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2024 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.