Something similiar was happening to me at Minnesota last November. I was carrying 3 QB's. The starter was getting the snaps ok but the backup wasn't getting in the games the 3rd string was. Thing is it wasn't every game, my ticket says it was in 4 out of 6 games. I had the 3rd string listed as 3rd in every category possible yet he was jumping ahead of the backup. I also got the I'm an idiot response from CS. But after enough pestering they fixed whatever issue it was.