Appearance fatigue has nothing to do with how often he appeared in real life. It's a fixed number, something like 70% of the total games played. It rarely happens. The rule was made many years ago under a different algorithm. There was a loophole where an SP, typically Greg Maddux, could pitch every game Long Relief and you could get more innings out of him. The appearance fatigue rule was made to close that loophole, eventually the algorithm was changed, closing the loophole anyway yet Appearance fatigue still exists.