1907 George Mullin
The extra $2M I would have saved by grabbing the '06 Mullin last round wouldn't have helped me upgrade SS. Sure, I could've added a pretty good Jeff Blauser season (instead of his teammate McMichael), but then I'm short good bullpen innings. Plus, I really like the 1907 Ty Cobb (at least compared to other OF teammates I had available to me at this point in the draft).