Welcome to the game! You'll get a lot of help here. Just a few things to start:
1. You'll have great recruiting vision, since your team has won 14 games each of the past 3 seasons. That means you will see more of the very best players than the majority of teams will.
2. When you start recruiting, don't look at any players that are more than 360 miles away. The price for recruiting goes way up when you get out farther than that. Players closer than 180 miles are even less costly to recruit.
3. If you use the standard WIS recruiting page to search for recruits, use the specific position ratings to rank your players. For example, when you search for Quarterbacks, in the Overall Rating drop-down box, specify Quarterback, not Total.
4. You will need to have enough players at each position. You have 50 total roster spots. Most people go with a distribution something like this:
QB 2 or 3
RB 4 or 5
WR 5 or 6
TE 2 or 3
OL 8 or 9
DL 7 or 8
LB 6 or 7
DB 7 or 8
K 1
P 1