Sounds like you might be scouting too many to level 4, too fast. That is how I recruited until I found out how important "preferences" are to the signing process. I scout at D1 level two to 200 (or 400 depending what side of Country). At level two you will see the preferences. I then rate guys by rating system Very Good +2 Good +1 Neutral 0 Bad -1 Very Bad -2. I then look at everybody that is a positive number at this point and look at Offense and Defense, GPA, and WE Rating, and if I still have prospects that match positions I am recruiting, I recruit them to level 3. At this level I look for players tapped out mainly, and then on to level 4 with those that still match what I am looking for. If I do not have prospects enough, I will go to Level 2 that are at Zero and repeat. If I am still not filling enough recruits, I will go to Off/Def skills not like I play, or lower WE. But never will I recruit enmasse to level 4. You need to treat your scouting money like gold, because I have also ended up on the last day with ZERO prospects unsigned in my pool, and tons of recruiting cash. At that point you are worse then screwed. You know players exist, that you can offer, but with zero guys in your pool, you cannot offer anyone unless you have a transfer email pop up. Then it is walk on time. I had to resign my Penn State team a season ago because I knew the computer could recruit ten guys better then I could.