Would stick with #1 and be on the look out for SS upgrades via trade, IFA, etc.. #3 is a 3B, but a pretty average player. #2 doesn't do much for me. Keep an eye out for a SS with high fielding ratings (lots of + plays which will, in turn, help your pitching) and one redeemable hitting rating. Any offensive production out of a slick fielding SS is a bonus, so look for a guy with 80+ power or > 80-85 in another hitting category.