yeah, i agree. it's out of whack. a high-prestige program has a so-so NT season and then a losing season...still A+.
the flipside is that i remember the terrific texas southern teams drsnell had in smith...he could never get above A- no matter how well he did there. in his last 4 seasons he made 4 consecutive sweet 16s...stuck at A- prestige...then 1 losing season (14-15) after he left, drops to B+ and kept dropping since. even with midmajors being able to attain better recruits, prestige is still a pretty heavy handicap for top teams.