I'm playing with the connection from Billy Hamilton to Billy Hamilton. It's too bad the new one can't hit, but I think I can build a nice team across the centuries here.
Billy Hamilton played with Lave Cross for the 1894 Philadelphia Phillies
Lave Cross played with Walter Johnson for the 1907 Washington Senators
Walter Johnson played with Buddy Myer for the 1925 Washington Senators
Buddy Myer played with Early Wynn for the 1941 Washington Senators
Early Wynn played with Tommy John for the 1963 Cleveland Indians
Tommy John played with Rickey Henderson for the 1986 New York Yankees
Rickey Henderson played with Cesar Izturis for the 2003 Los Angeles Dodgers
Cesar Izturis played with Billy Hamilton for the 2013 Cincinnati Reds