Yeah, honestly, I wouldn't care is somebody wanted to use '95 Maddux or '08 Joss because it would cripple their team, but the list is based off the WIS SLB Weekly Snapshot. While updated weekly, the Snapshot reaches back to show the most frequently used payers since Oct. 2008, and I'm not going to try to pick and choose which ones are still used a lot. If you know of a way to see the most used over the last 24 months, please let me know.
That said, I've played some Open League over the last few months, and most of these guys still show up multiple times.