In a unique theme league where I had to draft four OFers but don't have a DH role to put one of them in.

If your other two OFers are a C+/A- and a B+/C in the field, who would you play between...

Player A: Right handed, A-/A+ in the field, .285/.327/.477 slash (20 HRs), with good speed.
Player B: Switch hitter, B/C+ in the field, .291/.397/.417 slash, with good speed.

Playing in a HR neutral, 3B negative park.

With just that information available I'd probably go with Player B, but would consider a platoon or even micromanaging matchups if I had the time.

cap? I am leaning towards player B primarily due to the OBP and the fact he's a switch hitter. you can always use player A as his defensive caddy at whatever inning you designate coupled with the PA's available. Agree with skunk... this calls for active management.

That's what I was worried about, ha

Assuming your other two are mashers since their starting is not being questioned....so I would go OBP. You could alsways play your C+/A- guy in CF.

Platoon and pinch hit. Or micro manage playing the matchups against the opposing pitcher stats.

Most likely B. Play A if you need a low OBP RBI guy or if the opposing pitcher is a lefty with a high HR/9.