Green a backup and hold back on giving out one scholarship.
If he is a backup, he will go green for you once the 1-A school completes his class. If he isn't, or if the 1-A school can't fill all it's scholarships, you can still extend the schollie up to the next to last cycle of recruiting to your backup.
I have never seen a DII school beat a 1-A school for a recruit. Don't spend more money on that recruit. You'd just be throwing it away or needlessly spending it if he turns out to be a backup.