Which is more important???

When drafting a player, none of them are important.

Posted by skunk206 on 7/26/2017 11:41:00 AM (view original):
When drafting a player, none of them are important.

Disagree.

RC27 is an objective measure of a players offensive value BUT it overstates the value of high walk slap hitters

Agreed with skunk. None of them are used by the game.

RC27 could be useful as an aggregator (similar to ERC# for pitchers) but, in practice, it is not a very good one. For example, anyone who has played high cap leagues can tell you that 1920 Babe Ruth is more valuable than 2004 Barry Bonds, but 2004 Barry Bonds scores 3 runs better in terms of RC27. This may be due to the fact that RC27 doesn't take into account normalization, which is a big factor in this game.

That's because RC27 overvalues walks.

Which is also why 04 Bonds typically under produces compared to early 20's Ruth. The walks pull the bat out of his hand, before he gets to swing

i have always valued RC highly in drafting players....this is wrong ?