Is 100 De and SB, 90 Ath, and 85 REB good enough?

Your questions make no sense lol.

Um, yeah?

Posted by cubcub113 on 8/17/2017 8:34:00 AM (view original):
Is 100 De and SB, 90 Ath, and 85 REB good enough?

No, you should be at 125+ across the board in those categories.

You also need to work the WE cheat code for 4-6 hours.

With the low reb and non-elite ATH it's not a lock. I had 95 ATH and 80 REB at the 4 for a year and felt it against better teams. Luckily other people offered more in depth feedback thru sitemail. What if I play this team in the sweet 16?

https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerProfile/Ratings.aspx?tid=0&pid=3594293

I'll be honest, I was in a rush and the question was crap.

If you're in the S16, it's too late to worry about it. I'm assuming you're not holding back a better PF to surprise someone.

Posted by cubcub113 on 8/17/2017 8:34:00 AM (view original):
Is 100 De and SB, 90 Ath, and 85 REB good enough?

This kid is Urkel. Cut him.

Wait, is a big man with 90 ATH considered non-elite ATH?

No wonder I'm struggling to rebuild Purdue.

Posted by pallas on 8/17/2017 1:44:00 PM (view original):
Wait, is a big man with 90 ATH considered non-elite ATH?

No wonder I'm struggling to rebuild Purdue.

Lol I thought the same thing, like Bruh I got 75 ATH starters that seem to be doing just fine.

Posted by pallas on 8/17/2017 1:44:00 PM (view original):
Wait, is a big man with 90 ATH considered non-elite ATH?

No wonder I'm struggling to rebuild Purdue.

Lol. I am really trying to get a Final Four or Elite 8 while Larkins stays around. It's not 99 but it's pretty darn good. Also, this guy in awful at offense. How many guys can be good at DI with 85 Reb, 40 Speed and no offense whatsoever.

I wouldn't say a guy with 90 ATH/68 LP is awful at offense. Even if you never ask him to score his defense, rebounding, and 60 passing make him a great player. He would easily be the most promising post player on my Oklahoma team (not Elite 8 quality but they are ranked 19th). He was the #7 C for a reason.

You also need to work the WE cheat code for 4-6 hours.

that and unlock Big Head mode

Posted by mrslam34 on 8/17/2017 2:30:00 PM (view original):
I wouldn't say a guy with 90 ATH/68 LP is awful at offense. Even if you never ask him to score his defense, rebounding, and 60 passing make him a great player. He would easily be the most promising post player on my Oklahoma team (not Elite 8 quality but they are ranked 19th). He was the #7 C for a reason.

Thanks

The answer isn't really easy. He's a stud if you're not at high D1. At High D1, guys like this are "commonplace". My guess is that there are 20-30 guys with similar defensive stats.

In a vacuum, the player is a + defender and an average rebounder.

If you have a 100/100 (or close to that) ATH/REB C and/or a SF or some guards that can rebound it should help.

He's very solid in a 3-2 zone if you have others to rebound with.

His speed is important (as is the speed in his paired SF) in the 2-3. If he's slow I would even consider playing him at the 5.

In man, that 100 SB becomes less important and he becomes less elite as a defender. I would trade 15 points in rebounding for 20 points in block in a heartbeat.. He's still a good defender but no longer super elite.

I wouldn't hesitate to take this type of guy on my good D1 zone teams at all. In a perfect world, I would pair him with a monster rebounder at the 5.

For a man team, IF I ONLY WANTED DEF, I would take him. If he can score a little or could pass or something else, I would take him but if he's less than 30 in LP and/or PASS he would be a 2nd/3rd level backup.

He's a great defensive player who is an adequate rebounder. If he can do anything else, I would take him. If not, then it becomes more situation dependent.

Posted by Trentonjoe on 8/18/2017 7:18:00 AM (view original):
The answer isn't really easy. He's a stud if you're not at high D1. At High D1, guys like this are "commonplace". My guess is that there are 20-30 guys with similar defensive stats.

In a vacuum, the player is a + defender and an average rebounder.

If you have a 100/100 (or close to that) ATH/REB C and/or a SF or some guards that can rebound it should help.

He's very solid in a 3-2 zone if you have others to rebound with.

His speed is important (as is the speed in his paired SF) in the 2-3. If he's slow I would even consider playing him at the 5.

In man, that 100 SB becomes less important and he becomes less elite as a defender. I would trade 15 points in rebounding for 20 points in block in a heartbeat.. He's still a good defender but no longer super elite.

I wouldn't hesitate to take this type of guy on my good D1 zone teams at all. In a perfect world, I would pair him with a monster rebounder at the 5.

For a man team, IF I ONLY WANTED DEF, I would take him. If he can score a little or could pass or something else, I would take him but if he's less than 30 in LP and/or PASS he would be a 2nd/3rd level backup.

He's a great defensive player who is an adequate rebounder. If he can do anything else, I would take him. If not, then it becomes more situation dependent.

Original guy is 46 speed 70 BH 60 pa. 70 LP. I got him at B- prestige. I run man.

I should have a 95+ Ath De Reb Sb 90 LP guy at center for hopefully 2 years.

After that, I'll have a 85 Ath, 95 REB, 100 De, 95 Sb guy at center.