I inherited a top-heavy team with tons of committed ML payroll and a MILB system that was clearly neglected. I've got a Type A FA RP. He's solid and will likely get signed if I let him go. However, my draft scouting is only 10 coll/2 HS. My question is whether I'd get more out of re-signing the player (3 yrs/$6M per) than out of the draft picks, when my scouting is poor. I do also have protected 1st round pick (#16). Am I over-thinking it?

10m is a bit of a crapshoot. If he's worth 3/6m, sign him. Don't count on trading him because, if he's a FA, he's likely early/mid-30s. People in this game value the future more than they value the current. But, then again, I traded for a 3/6m RP because I wanted him to help me win.