Round 1 - 90M Analysis Topic

I can't really complain since my 99 Blue Jays are playing very well, but dang I knew the 2008 Braves was a good pick (I was twisting a hitter as my third twist).
9/22/2017 3:42 PM
Sorted by amount of improvement compared to real life win%

Owner Selected Team Winning% Clones SIM Win% Win% Diff
-------------------- ------------------------------------ ------------- ------------- ------------- -------------
dlchow 1993 New York Mets 0.364 3 0.584 0.220
jmissirlis 1965 Houston Astros 0.401 3 0.616 0.215
mpitt76 2004 Arizona Diamondbacks 0.315 3 0.512 0.197
frank_drebin 1984 Milwaukee Brewers 0.416 3 0.584 0.168
sford 1943 New York Giants 0.359 3 0.512 0.153
firesalt 1984 Milwaukee Brewers 0.416 3 0.56 0.144
calhoop 2008 Atlanta Braves 0.444 3 0.584 0.140
wink0094 2008 Atlanta Braves 0.444 3 0.584 0.140
brickster44 2004 Arizona Diamondbacks 0.315 3 0.448 0.133
bighooze 2000 Houston Astros 0.444 3 0.568 0.124
Jdh34 2000 Houston Astros 0.444 3 0.56 0.116
Fusion27s 1943 New York Giants 0.359 3 0.472 0.113
schwarze 1999 Toronto Blue Jays 0.519 2 0.632 0.113
BullMoose 1935 Boston Braves 0.248 3 0.36 0.112
batandball 1993 Oakland Athletics 0.42 3 0.528 0.108
Jtpsops 1966 Houston Astros 0.444 3 0.552 0.108
trd3 2000 Houston Astros 0.444 3 0.552 0.108
DarthDurron 1972 San Francisco Giants 0.445 3 0.552 0.107
cstrohmier 1991 Cincinnati Reds 0.457 2 0.56 0.103
pedrocerrano 1972 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.548 2 0.648 0.100
barracuda3 2012 St. Louis Cardinals 0.543 2 0.64 0.097
daddyzander 2008 New York Mets 0.549 2 0.632 0.083
markeking 1989 Montreal Expos 0.5 2 0.576 0.076
nordawg 1990 Atlanta Braves 0.401 3 0.472 0.071
Humdogs 1982 Montreal Expos 0.531 2 0.6 0.069
jetscanes 1987 Oakland Athletics 0.5 2 0.568 0.068
rickysdad44 1992 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.389 3 0.448 0.059
doctorcc 1964 Cincinnati Reds 0.568 1 0.624 0.056
brianjw 1989 St. Louis Cardinals 0.531 2 0.584 0.053
bigmc 1989 Montreal Expos 0.5 2 0.552 0.052
jfranco77 2008 Atlanta Braves 0.444 3 0.496 0.052
crystalao 1994 Seattle Mariners 0.438 3 0.488 0.050
mick33 1986 Chicago Cubs 0.438 3 0.488 0.050
rbow923 1974 New York Mets 0.438 3 0.488 0.050
toddcommish 1999 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.475 2 0.504 0.029
mildnhazy 2005 Houston Astros 0.549 2 0.576 0.027
sjh0825 1972 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.548 2 0.568 0.020
mllama54 1998 Cleveland Indians 0.549 2 0.568 0.019
fatboydad54 1996 Florida Marlins 0.494 2 0.512 0.018
thebubbaq 1968 Pittsburgh Pirates 0.494 2 0.512 0.018
beauchamp 1989 Montreal Expos 0.5 2 0.504 0.004
thehuseman 2008 Atlanta Braves 0.444 2 0.448 0.004
glowguy 1992 Chicago Cubs 0.481 2 0.48 (0.001)
ozomatli 1989 Montreal Expos 0.5 2 0.496 (0.004)
redwingscup 1970 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.54 2 0.536 (0.004)
jjgreen14 2008 New York Mets 0.549 2 0.544 (0.005)
happyhours 1982 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.543 2 0.536 (0.007)
scottharra 1999 Seattle Mariners 0.488 2 0.48 (0.008)
Chisock 2001 Atlanta Braves 0.543 2 0.528 (0.015)
zlionsfan 1991 Detroit Tigers 0.519 2 0.504 (0.015)
ballantine 1995 Baltimore Orioles 0.493 2 0.472 (0.021)
cubbies84 2000 New York Yankees 0.54 2 0.512 (0.028)
knieman 1979 Kansas City Royals 0.525 2 0.496 (0.029)
ledfoot 2003 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.525 2 0.496 (0.029)
thejuice6 1998 Cleveland Indians 0.549 2 0.512 (0.037)
XJchessman 2005 Houston Astros 0.549 2 0.512 (0.037)
brucel 2006 Boston Red Sox 0.531 2 0.488 (0.043)
jbohrman 2008 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.519 2 0.472 (0.047)
justinlee_24 2004 New York Yankees 0.623 1 0.576 (0.047)
Relkcirts 2002 Florida Marlins 0.488 2 0.44 (0.048)
bardin 1999 Toronto Blue Jays 0.519 2 0.456 (0.063)
buddhagamer 2004 New York Yankees 0.623 1 0.552 (0.071)
Lazerhawks 1977 Cincinnati Reds 0.543 2 0.472 (0.071)
darthmetool 1922 Washington Senators 0.448 3 0.376 (0.072)
NebHusker 1969 Baltimore Orioles 0.673 1 0.6 (0.073)
slightner 1987 Kansas City Royals 0.512 2 0.432 (0.080)
kyleb63 1985 California Angels 0.556 1 0.472 (0.084)
gigrant 1997 Cleveland Indians 0.534 2 0.44 (0.094)
hurst47 2003 Boston Red Sox 0.586 1 0.488 (0.098)
paulives 2009 New York Yankees 0.636 1 0.536 (0.100)
hersheybear 1998 Houston Astros 0.63 1 0.52 (0.110)
rmdriskill 1997 Atlanta Braves 0.623 1 0.512 (0.111)
greenies 2002 Boston Red Sox 0.574 1 0.456 (0.118)
tridentric 1997 Cleveland Indians 0.534 2 0.416 (0.118)
newarkwilder 1981 Houston Astros 0.555 1 0.432 (0.123)
garmansouth 1927 Philadelphia Athletics 0.591 1 0.456 (0.135)
KOTH 1962 St. Louis Cardinals 0.519 2 0.384 (0.135)
tigerrott 1969 Baltimore Orioles 0.673 1 0.536 (0.137)
DoctorKz 2004 St. Louis Cardinals 0.648 1 0.504 (0.144)
hacker7 2001 Atlanta Braves 0.543 2 0.392 (0.151)
charliembg 1995 Cleveland Indians 0.694 1 0.536 (0.158)
ejstockman 1994 Montreal Expos 0.649 1 0.488 (0.161)
moose821 2004 Chicago Cubs 0.549 2 0.384 (0.165)
discodemo 1995 Cleveland Indians 0.694 1 0.528 (0.166)
sohio4ever 1964 Los Angeles Dodgers 0.494 1 0.328 (0.166)
midknight 1977 Cincinnati Reds 0.543 2 0.376 (0.167)
dodgebob 2007 Boston Red Sox 0.593 1 0.424 (0.169)
npg32433 1970 Oakland Athletics 0.549 2 0.376 (0.173)
dougpalm 1969 Baltimore Orioles 0.673 1 0.488 (0.185)
magicdreamer 2001 Seattle Mariners 0.716 1 0.528 (0.188)
spikeboots 2016 Toronto Blue Jays 0.549 2 0.36 (0.189)
redcped 1995 Cleveland Indians 0.694 1 0.496 (0.198)
d_rock97 2016 Chicago Cubs 0.64 1 0.44 (0.200)
fooolishfool 1944 St. Louis Cardinals 0.682 1 0.448 (0.234)
spoonfed 2013 Detroit Tigers 0.574 1 0.256 (0.318)
rufus4ever 1973 Cincinnati Reds 0.611 1 0.216 (0.395)
9/22/2017 3:44 PM
As I learned in last year's 90M and fooolishfool is apparently discovering this time, you just can't trust those '44 Cards at this cap
9/22/2017 3:52 PM
Looks like I should've given the '65 Astros more consideration. I was too scared away by the awful-fielding SS options, but clearly that hasn't been an issue for jmissirlis.

Our offenses have nearly identical production so far:

'65 Astros: .255/.339/.378
'66 Astros: .255/.340/.379

Clearly '65 pitching options are making the difference, though those numbers are relatively close as well.
9/22/2017 4:09 PM
◂ Prev 12
Round 1 - 90M Analysis Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2024 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.