Posted by bhansalid00 on 12/6/2017 9:55:00 AM (view original):
Posted by rednu on 12/5/2017 3:32:00 PM (view original):
Maine, Presque Isle is easily the worst D3 location IMO. Canada is a wasteland to the north and anything that spawns within the state is often 200+ miles from campus, placing you at a distance disadvantage even against the other schools from your state. Going outside the state is a challenge because you're in the super-saturated New England area that has a gazillion D3 programs. It might be a little better now under 3.0 (though I'm not sure) since theoretically there's a broader pool of talent to target now than under 2.0. I can't imagine the change would be enough to shift it from being anything but the least-friendly place to coach from in D3. Basically, you're always going to be in competition for prime targets and you're rarely, if ever, going to be operating from an advantageous position in going after those targets.
Sul Ross State (mentioned above) also wasn't a bed of roses under 2.0 because, aside from the occasional D1 recruit that shows up in El Paso, hardly anything spawns in western Texas, leaving you 300+ miles for just the in-state kids. It was markedly easier there than M-PI though because you at least had an in-state boost from Texas and New Mexico generated enough good D2 talent that was rarely contested that there were pipelines to be had.
Thanks for the info, rednu! I'm intrigued by how crappy M-PI sounds...
Maine, Presque Isle was the very first HD team I had (in Allen). It was terrible trying to recruit from there but this was also pre-potential, pre-dropdowns/pulldowns, recruits capped by division, etc. It also didn't help that I really didn't know what I was doing either.
I coached Maine in D1 Tark for several seasons and have often thought about going back to Presque Isle in some world and trying it again. I'm pretty sure I'd have a little better luck signing players now than I did way back when, ha ha.