I've only seen a VH beat a H a handful of times, and never when I was involved. It's almost gotten to the point I'd rather be the one who's High.
I don't know who said it and whether it was in this thread or one of the many other ones on this topic, but someone said the battles have gone too far toward the underdogs. I get what they were trying to do with 3.0 and I believe it's worked ("working as intended"). But underdogs winning shouldn't be as common as it appears to be.