Both fairly SF and fairly similar players

Player A

Ath - 28 (green)
Spd - 42 (blue)
Reb - 54 (blue)
Def - 39 (blue)
Blk - 45 (gray)
LP - 58 (gray)
Per - 51 (green)
BH - 50 (blue)
Pass - 37 (green)
WE - 34
Sta - 60 (blue)
Dur 46 (blue)
FT - B- (gray)

Player B

Ath - 44 (gray)
Spd - 42 (gray)
Reb - 50 (blue)
Def - 56 (blue)
Blk - 37 (green)
LP - 51 (blue)
Per - 10 (green)
BH - 46 (gray)
Pass - 50 (blue)
WE - 41
Sta - 67 (gray)
Dur - 60 (green)
FT - C (gray)

Player A has more upside overall, however Player B could develop his perimeter game quite a bit and be more useful and player A has lower WE.

I would redshirt player A. Higher potential and more effort needed to reach his potential. Also couldn't contribute this season.

Player B could come off the bench somewhere.

Def player A

A.