I doubt anyone is clamoring for a follow-up to this thread, but I thought it might be interesting for a few of you who commented to see. This thread was really helpful to me early on in learning how to judge progression and take a critical eye to projections. Here's what the guy has turned into as he nears his prime...
Player Profile: Richard Miller - Hardball Dynasty Baseball | WhatIfSports
I was pretty down on him after reading some of the comments here and traded him for, basically, a similar, more veteran player a couple of seasons ago. Probably a bad deal because I wasn't contending at that time, but the guy plays a decent role on the very good team I have now. Miller has come farther than I expected. I'm not sure what the ultimate lesson here is except that there are very few absolutes in this game.