Players leaving teams is a common occurrence but coming back is much less so. Pick a player that left one franchise, played for another and then came back. Pick one season from their first stint and one season from their second. If your player had more than 2 stints with one team, choose 2 stints and one season for each. All players can be twisted to any year of their career and your captain must be on your roster. Blacklisted Captains are listed below, they can be used on your team, just not as a captian. AAA 6/2 below average, no DH, no WW, no trades.

Here's a few examples:

If you choose Greg Maddux, you can pick one Cubs season between 86-92 and another Cubs season between 04-06. So you can pick the 88 and 05 Cubs and twist any players that played for the Cubs those 2 seasons.

If you choose Rickey Henderson, you can pick two out of the four stints he had with the A's (79-84, 89-93, 94-95, 98) or you can choose from either 96 or 97 and 2001 Padres.

Also, please note that your captain must have played on another team, not just signed by another team.

Use a ballpark that was used by your team in one of the seasons you choose


$120 Million Cap

League number is:
MLB121040


Please let me know if there are any questions, I think it's pretty straightforward.

Blacklisted Captains:

Dick Allen
George Altman
Rich Aurilia
Bert Blyleven
Mordecai Brown
Ellis Burks
Joe Bush
Eddie Collins
Roger Clemens
George Davis
Larry Doyle
Kirk Gibson
Joe Girardi
Goose Gossage
Ken Griffey Jr.
Heinie Groh (Season 2 champions, 0soup4u)
Dick Hall
Carmen Hill
Rogers Hornsby
Doc Johnston
George Kelly
Arlie Latham
All Leiter
Kenny Lofton
Greg Maddux
Tino Martinez
Willie McCovey
Ducky Medwick
Doug Mirabelli
Wilcy Moore
Bobby Murcer
Phil Niekro
Tip O'Neill
Chan Ho Park
Jack Quinn
Hanley Ramirez
Jose Reyes
Ivan Rodriguez
Pete Rose
Edd Roush (Season 1 Champions, obnyy)
Wally Schang
Red Schoendienst
George Scott
Al Simmons
Jake Stahl
Mike Stanton
Rusty Staub
Jim Thome
Joe Tinker


Captains entered this season:

Marlon Anderson
Carlos Beltran
Mike Bielecki
Giovanni Carrara
Rocky Colavito
Dennis Eckersley
Alex Ferguson
Chick Gandil
Grover Hartley
Solly Hofman
Reggie Jackson
Ted Kubiak
Willie McGee
Terry Mulholland
Russ Nixon
Bob O’Farrell
Tony Perez
Andy Pettitte
Dick Schofield
Tom Seaver
Mike Stanton
Jack Taylor
Bill White
Maury Wills

Im taking Marlon Anderson 05/09 Mets

Bob O’Farrell Cubs 1916/34

Terry Mulholland - 86/97 Giants

I am back with Dick Schofield

St. Louis Cardinals 1958/68

I will give this another go, this time with Dennis Eckersley, 1978/1998 Boston Red Sox.

I don’t see Solly Hofman taken yet. Like to claim him. Years TBD


edit : 1911 and 1916

Back with Giovanni Carrara - 2002 & 2006 Dodgers.

Ted Kubiak A's - 1969 and 1975

Jack Taylor 1898 & 1907 Cubs/Orphans

Alex Ferguson, 1921 & 1925 Yankees

I'd love to jump in with Tony Perez 1964 & 1986 Reds

Hey Tyler, can you cut your captain at or before the transaction deadline, or do they have to stay on your active roster for the entire season?

Posted by 0soup4u on 1/29/2018 11:54:00 AM (view original):
Hey Tyler, can you cut your captain at or before the transaction deadline, or do they have to stay on your active roster for the entire season?

Soup,
You can send him to AAA but he needs to be on your team. There's no WW or trades

Tom Seaver 1973 & 1983 Mets, please.