This one is a little bizarre and I'm not even sure what the results tell us, but here goes. This is for D1 and the kid was a transfer and only preference was "wants to play."
School A:
160 APs, schollie
Prestige in RS1 B, prestige in RS2 C+
School B:
100 APs, schollie
Prestige in RS1 C, Prestige in RS2 B-
All effort was done in RS2. The kid signed on the 2nd cycle of RS2 before either team could put any additional effort towards the kid.