Player wants to play far from home, wants success, and wants strong defense.

Team A
Prestige - A+, recent championship
Preferences:
Distance - bad (330 miles)
Success - very good
Strong D - neutral
Promises - Start/20
Effort:
AP - 317
Max visits

Team B
Prestige - B+
Preferences:
Distance - very good (1065 miles)
Success - very good
Strong D - neutral
Promises - Start/25
Effort:
AP - 730
Max visits

Team B 56-44

Not enough information. What does "recent championship" mean? Did prestige change between RS1 and RS2? Did the kid sign early?

He signed in the first cycle, so the prestige was accurate the entire time recruiting took place.

Championship was two seasons earlier - this was during the second season after the championship.

I have team a up a lot. Maybe 70-30?

One estimation has team B up moderately, the other has team A up significantly. Any other guesses? I’ll post later this afternoon.

Distance preference is huge. Team B has a quite a few more APs on him. The difference between team A's "very good" with success and team B's "very good" with playing time(5 more minutes) might come close to cancelling out. If the AP's were even, I would give team A the advantage

To be clear, playing time was not a preference.

Posted by shoe3 on 3/11/2018 11:03:00 AM (view original):
To be clear, playing time was not a preference.

I thought it said so in your first post at the top?

Player wants to play far from home, wants success, and wants strong defense.

Posted by thewizard17 on 3/11/2018 11:09:00 AM (view original):
Player wants to play far from home, wants success, and wants strong defense.

There isn't a comma between wants to play and far from home, meaning "player wants to play far from home" is one clause.

Posted by darnoc29099 on 3/11/2018 11:29:00 AM (view original):

Posted by thewizard17 on 3/11/2018 11:09:00 AM (view original):
Player wants to play far from home, wants success, and wants strong defense.

There isn't a comma between wants to play and far from home, meaning "player wants to play far from home" is one clause.

Ah! Got confused there! In that case, I'll go 54-46 Team B

I get team B close call.

I would give a slight edge to team B as well, say, 52-48, but I'm usually way off on these.