I think I've got a roster now. Check me.
1. P Weldon Wyckoff 1913-18
1913 Philadelphia A's: P Eddie Plank, P Boardwalk Brown, P Weldon (Long Man) Wyckoff, P Herb (Longer Man) Pennock
2. Cardinals @ Reds, 6/7/2013
2B Matt Carpenter, P Trevor Rosenthal, P JJ Hoover, P Randy Choate
3. P Orber Moreno 1999-2004
2004 Mets: SS Kaz Matsui, OF Mike Cameron, OF Victor Diaz, P Orber Moreno
4. Pirates @ Cardinals, 9/2/1963, 2nd game of doubleheader
1B Bill White, 3B Ken Boyer, OF Roberto Clemente, P Ron Taylor
5. 1981 Los Angeles Dodgers fielding - any four players, incl. pitchers
P Fernando Valenzuela, P Jerry Reuss, C Mike Scioscia, C Jerry Grote
6. Red Sox @ Athletics, 4/29/1935
OF Bob Johnson, SS Skeeter Newsome, IF Max Bishop, OF Bing Miller
Wild card: 2009 Mike Carp, 1B, Seattle