Found a really weird one recently: In the 23 yr old FAs at the beginning of the season, there was a 59 overall SP. Control and P2 aren't great, but otherwise he could easily project as an SP4 or SP5. If everyone sees him he gets drafted in the second round, latest. So one would assume he was drafted last season out of college but went unsigned, right?
Nope. I checked his card, he was never drafted. Doesn't say where he went to college; doesn't have any record of him playing anywhere. Ergo, he was never scouted by any of the league's owners.