Owner Rankings, 2018 Topic

We have 72 confirmed owners (with the majority of GCs purchased), so I went ahead and calculated the owner rankings. The complex formula used is based on a combination of past tournament performance (more recent tournaments get more weight), historical WIS stats, and a new wrinkle -- recency (how you have performed on WIS since your last tournament appearance, relative to your overall historical averages). Your ranking here is also your team ID which will be used to assign you to your league (note that league numbers are not yet available -- a sitemail will be sent out when they are).
6/19/2018 4:23 AM
Rank Owner________ 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
1 brianjw 1 2 1 6 2 1
2 discodemo 5 6 4 2 3 4 5
3 rbow923 5 1 2 44 3 12 9 16 9
4 schwarze 5 14 7 5 5 3 11 9 8 5 4 27 12 4
5 ozomatli 45 29 9 3
6 jbohrman 58 5 14 3 4 6 21
7 buddhagamer 3 7 35 14 20 13 10
8 mildnhazy 4 4 30 32 13 7 12 11 1 7 17 12 5 8
9 jfranco77 1 29 9 60 10 22 38 68 7 6
10 jmissirlis 5 11 26
11 dougpalm 20 3 17 15 13 65 7
12 shaybee 2 3 18 45 5 27 12 26
13 bighooze 31 15 18 34 30 27 17 16
14 Fusion27s 48 41 22 12
15 homiealiens 6 7 61
16 justinlee_24 16 36 7 18 32
17 crystalao 29 18 20 29 3 53
18 mllama54 36 53 36 35 47 22 61 25 20
19 markeking 29 10 41 24 20 18 37 61 42 15 57 21 24 49
20 mdc2276
21 dippedncrack 34 29 42
22 calhoop 41 7 33 20 24 15 16 58 25 90 24 35 68 11
23 redcped 46
24 cstrohmier 13 35 22 26 32 58 30 29 42 43
25 newarkwilder 64 15 10 18 19 27 42 23 26 21 39 30 55
26 tigerrott 61 29
27 Donburgh 47 39 30 58 23
28 magicdreamer 52 40 39 18
29 mpitt76 37 26 19 29 8 12 29 33 35 12 21 39 32 51
30 ledfoot 33
31 bothways
32 frank_drebin 51 17
33 wink0094 54
34 ejstockman 59 32 22 54 38 37 22 43 58
35 beauchamp 67 48 59 81 35 41 55 13 62 44 50 15
36 odalisgagne 38 17 39 32 50 50 45 68
37 jjgreen14 59 19 8 19 29 63 47
38 kyleb63 39 43 59 52
39 donaldjtrump
40 NebHusker 37
41 Jdh34 78 56 68 23 61 74 29
42 cubbies84 30 17 31 41 19 57 69
43 Chisock 64 63 60 80 49 79 57 79 80 59 27 39
44 Jtpsops 83 93 46 65 52 78 47 24
45 Humdogs 54 71 92 48
46 DarthDurron 79 73 49 80 59 42
47 sprintracer 75 67
48 The Taint 30 24 30 92 33 79
49 thehuseman 67 38 36 75
50 toddcommish 38 55 80 82 47 74 80 27
51 mick33 55 85 86 35
52 jetscanes 95 44 15 67 16 89 44
53 trd3 78 47 47 66 48 56 61
54 sjh0825 71 37 90
55 zlionsfan 79 40 85 33 56 49 86 73 81 86 92 64 41 59
56 nordawg 46 74 73 80 78
57 thejuice6 88 64 59 36 76 60 61 72 71 71 64
58 gigrant 77 84 80
59 scottharra 82 57
60 hurst47 84
61 thebubbaq 50 94 56 68 89 84 76 67 85 73
62 happyhours 94 56 81 37 58 83 94 94 86 73 67
63 sionnach99
64 mars2010 58
65 loyalcanuck 87
66 Pebo 83
67 npg32433 86 92 87 85
68 garmansouth 82 89 82
69 midknight 74 89
70 deathdealer 96 94 89
71 tridentric 49 58 95 96 66 94 89 89 96 95
72 scthallfan 85 82 60 70 95
73 spoonfed 92 94 94
8/18/2018 3:09 PM (edited)
Hold for aggregate owner stats
6/19/2018 4:24 AM
How do you feel about your pre-tournament Owner Ranking?
Votes: 36
(Last vote received: 8/10/2018 8:00 PM)
6/19/2018 4:49 AM
Not last! Lol
6/19/2018 8:00 AM
Yikes. Went from 46 to 22 this year despite a middle-of-the-pack showing the first time. Now the pressure is really on, because advancing is now an expectation.
6/19/2018 9:44 AM
brianjw ranked 1st? I'm shocked, shocked I tell you.
6/19/2018 10:23 AM
Posted by redcped on 6/19/2018 9:44:00 AM (view original):
Yikes. Went from 46 to 22 this year despite a middle-of-the-pack showing the first time. Now the pressure is really on, because advancing is now an expectation.
You scored fairly well on most of the stats ranking portion (despite not having a ton of teams) and well enough on the recency portion to bump up your tournament rank. Since you only have one other appearance, the tournament rank portion was not weighted very heavily in your final rank. At one point while I was tinkering, it projected you even a few spots higher.
6/19/2018 11:19 AM
FYI - dippedncrack has replaced doctorcc, and he has slotted into the 19th spot.
7/9/2018 12:39 PM (edited)
I also noticed a few cases where the formula was applied incorrectly to individual owners. After fixing the bug, here are the changes (they are small)

buddhagamer up one spot
mildnhazy down one spot
jmissirlis up one spot
shaybee down one spot
markeking up one spot
dippedncrack down one spot
newarkwilder up one spot
redcped down one spot
bothways up two spots
XJchessman down two spots
mick33 up one spot
jetscanes down one spot
nordawg up one spot
thejuice6 down one spot
npg32433 up one spot
midknight down one spot

This will not impact league assignments (or anything else).
7/9/2018 12:34 PM
With two more replacements, the standard deviations updated further. A few ranks moved up or down a spot or two again as a result. This was not a bug as I originally thought but rather just the STDEV rankings changing as a result of replacement owners.
7/14/2018 2:41 PM
One thing I wish I'd remembered to add to the ranking formula this year was Owner Rating Points / Teams Owned

I was skeptical of Owner Rating as a predictive measure, since it can be skewed in many ways (i.e. owners playing more progressives and having down years). However Rating Points / Teams Owned, with a correlation of .68 compared to actual Tournament Rank so far this year, is by itself almost as predictive as the entire existing formula (correlation of .705).

I can only imagine that it will significantly further improve the predictive accuracy of the ranking formula if/once I include it for next year.

Here is each owner with their Points per Team rank:

Rank___ Owner_____________ Teams_____ Owner Rating_____ Points per Team
1 discodemo 376 114,356 304
2 rbow923 793 222,524 281
3 brianjw 225 56,551 251
4 dougpalm 893 214,131 240
5 bothways 31 6,804 219
6 ozomatli 601 130,998 218
6 shaybee 831 180,747 218
8 jmissirlis 97 18,877 195
9 mdc2276 69 13,194 191
10 jbohrman 283 52,752 186
11 tigerrott 296 51,078 173
12 homiealiens 168 28,068 167
13 jfranco77 965 157,920 164
13 mildnhazy 245 40,158 164
15 schwarze 1103 178,494 162
16 buddhagamer 343 49,981 146
17 bighooze 175 24,347 139
17 crystalao 95 13,211 139
17 Humdogs 426 59,382 139
20 dippedncrack 266 36,791 138
21 NebHusker 78 10,495 135
21 donaldjtrump 292 39,541 135
23 markeking 677 89,821 133
24 ledfoot 58 7,373 127
25 cstrohmier 760 91,696 121
26 mick33 127 14,962 118
27 justinlee_24 107 12,510 117
28 Fusion27s 101 11,651 115
29 newarkwilder 867 99,161 114
30 redcped 84 9,204 110
31 jjgreen14 105 11,225 107
32 wink0094 225 21,602 96
33 cubbies84 190 16,568 87
34 odalisgagne 928 76,974 83
35 mpitt76 362 29,074 80
36 magicdreamer 107 8,341 78
37 kyleb63 112 8,615 77
38 ejstockman 515 38,718 75
39 Donburgh 323 19,058 59
40 frank_drebin 756 41,286 55
41 sprintracer 103 5,594 54
41 sionnach99 188 10,187 54
43 sjh0825 737 38,932 53
44 nordawg 641 30,186 47
45 thehuseman 193 7,700 40
46 DarthDurron 1006 39,101 39
47 mllama54 667 24,817 37
48 hurst47 122 3,868 32
49 toddcommish 311 7,401 24
50 The Taint 762 10,789 14
51 gigrant 1010 11,538 11
52 Chisock 1261 5,251 4
53 thejuice6 1430 -214 0
54 calhoop 1160 -3,190 -3
55 trd3 526 -2,464 -5
56 Jdh34 330 -2,171 -7
57 loyalcanuck 339 -3,957 -12
58 Pebo 195 -3,062 -16
59 zlionsfan 385 -6,659 -17
60 mars2010 139 -2,949 -21
61 garmansouth 160 -4,684 -29
62 thebubbaq 609 -19,434 -32
63 deathdealer 208 -8,460 -41
64 Jtpsops 324 -14,348 -44
65 beauchamp 287 -13,621 -47
66 midknight 1179 -62,152 -53
67 happyhours 1293 -76,398 -59
68 jetscanes 112 -7,141 -64
68 scottharra 120 -7,724 -64
70 npg32433 80 -5,575 -70
71 scthallfan 239 -50,055 -209
72 spoonfed 255 -57,418 -225
73 tridentric 614 -143,986 -235


Note that Owner Ratings listed here were at the time I ran the Pre-Rank formula, before the tournament started
9/8/2018 9:45 PM (edited)
My guess is that the strength of this is due to Owner Rating not only being based on results (i.e. W/L), but also by run differential, which is generally a great measure of a team's worth.

However, unlike run differential alone, Owner Rating controls for blowouts by capping the amount of points you can gain or lose per game, regardless of the score.
9/8/2018 9:32 PM
I should probably use Games Played rather than Teams, since some teams for most owners are mid-way through the season at all times.
9/8/2018 9:35 PM
this will be very skewed in favour of owners who play open leagues. For nearly 10 years I only played the WISC - my owner rating is apples vs a lot of other owners's oranges.
9/8/2018 11:19 PM
12 Next ▸
Owner Rankings, 2018 Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2024 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.