I am in with St. Louis Brown's/Cardinals
1889 pitching: Twist Silver King (1888), Elton Chamberlain (1888), Toad Ramsey (1885). Add Adonis Terry & Frank Foreman
2004 hitting: Twist Yadier Molina (2012), Albert Pujols (2008), Larry Walker (2001). Add Barry Bonds and Ichiro Suzuki