Here are the most popular selections... the Avg Win% is through 79 games.
.

Name	Season	Pos	Salary	Count	Avg Win%
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
Billy Herman	1937	2B	6,039,949	22	0.543
Willie McGee	1990	OF	4,587,037	20	0.532
George Davis	1895	3B	5,506,148	18	0.537
Dave Bancroft	1918	SS	4,629,010	17	0.524
Roger Connor	1894	1B	496,376	15	0.491
Ben Chapman	1936	OF	1,076,318	14	0.533
Bill Bernhard	1902	SP	9,370,956	13	0.511
Ed Walsh	1915	SP	973,462	13	0.462
Hub Collins	1888	OF	5,102,994	13	0.521
Tommy Helms	1977	DH	200,000	13	0.518
King Kelly	1887	OF	5,821,295	12	0.522
Phil Douglas	1915	SP	989,730	12	0.514
Bill Joyce	1897	3B	4,677,976	11	0.535
Hooks Wiltse	1915	RP	2,045,427	11	0.502
Kid Elberfeld	1901	SS	4,650,901	11	0.542
Thurman Munson	1975	C	6,169,426	11	0.482
Carl Weilman	1912	SP	1,995,364	10	0.472
George Dumont	1915	SP	1,794,025	10	0.467
Roy Johnson	1937	OF	247,089	10	0.510
Harry Walker	1947	OF	6,255,350	9	0.465
John McGraw	1895	3B	5,569,186	9	0.515
Roberto Alomar	1989	2B	4,917,074	9	0.518
Tommy Milone	2018	SP	200,000	9	0.558
Wally Schang	1915	3B	2,984,375	9	0.547
Aaron Nola	2018	SP	7,394,530	8	0.517
Cliff Lee	2010	SP	3,949,291	8	0.540
Greg Maddux	2006	SP	1,829,396	8	0.546
Herman Long	1896	SS	5,341,807	8	0.514
Martin Glendon	1903	SP	1,042,116	8	0.495
Mellie Wolfgang	1915	RP	1,975,978	8	0.516
Roger Connor	1893	1B	4,991,236	8	0.584
Tony Watson	2013	RP	2,499,182	8	0.524
Bobby Bonilla	1989	3B	5,468,103	7	0.490
Frank Baker	1909	3B	4,887,357	7	0.488
Joe McGinnity	1902	SP	5,486,751	7	0.494
Johan Santana	2005	SP	8,147,678	7	0.561
Pete Alexander	1918	SP	1,322,920	7	0.525

Most popular selections by position (excluding players under $1 million)...
.

Name	Season	Pos	Salary	Count	Avg Win%
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
Thurman Munson	1975	C	6,169,426	11	0.482
King Kelly	1888	C	6,429,543	5	0.428
Terry Kennedy	1981	C	4,444,635	4	0.526
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
Roger Connor	1893	1B	4,991,236	8	0.584
Jack Doyle	1897	1B	4,877,356	5	0.524
Dan Brouthers	1890	1B	5,514,629	4	0.551
Jim Delahanty	1911	1B	5,555,227	4	0.421
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
Billy Herman	1937	2B	6,039,949	22	0.543
Roberto Alomar	1989	2B	4,917,074	9	0.518
Bill Sweeney	1911	2B	4,873,516	5	0.501
Hardy Richardson	1885	2B	5,735,887	5	0.499
Tom Daly	1899	2B	4,777,380	5	0.494
Odell Hale	1934	2B	4,894,037	4	0.551
Yank Robinson	1887	2B	4,982,026	4	0.503
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
George Davis	1895	3B	5,506,148	18	0.537
Bill Joyce	1897	3B	4,677,976	11	0.535
John McGraw	1895	3B	5,569,186	9	0.515
Wally Schang	1915	3B	2,984,375	9	0.547
Bobby Bonilla	1989	3B	5,468,103	7	0.490
Frank Baker	1909	3B	4,887,357	7	0.488
Frank Baker	1913	3B	6,697,127	5	0.519
Buck Ewing	1887	3B	3,550,776	4	0.433
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
Dave Bancroft	1918	SS	4,629,010	17	0.524
Kid Elberfeld	1901	SS	4,650,901	11	0.542
Herman Long	1896	SS	5,341,807	8	0.514
Joe Sewell	1923	SS	6,672,162	6	0.494
Sam Wise	1887	SS	6,451,863	6	0.527
Corey Seager	2015	SS	1,319,090	5	0.461
Jimmy *****	1929	SS	4,531,762	5	0.542
Ezra Sutton	1887	SS	3,290,106	4	0.551
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
Willie McGee	1990	OF	4,587,037	20	0.532
Ben Chapman	1936	OF	1,076,318	14	0.533
Hub Collins	1888	OF	5,102,994	13	0.521
King Kelly	1887	OF	5,821,295	12	0.522
Harry Walker	1947	OF	6,255,350	9	0.465
Bill Lange	1896	OF	6,111,116	6	0.521
Ken Williams	1921	OF	6,324,945	6	0.500
Rickey Henderson	1988	OF	5,370,303	6	0.523
Billy Hamilton	1890	OF	6,095,199	5	0.524
Steve Evans	1914	OF	5,835,655	5	0.466
Taylor Douthit	1926	OF	4,726,598	5	0.484
Cy Seymour	1903	OF	5,970,106	4	0.570
George Gore	1886	OF	5,995,609	4	0.506
Max Carey	1919	OF	2,390,913	4	0.567
Tris Speaker	1913	OF	8,512,877	4	0.519
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
Bill Bernhard	1902	SP	9,370,956	13	0.511
Carl Weilman	1912	SP	1,995,364	10	0.472
George Dumont	1915	SP	1,794,025	10	0.467
Aaron Nola	2018	SP	7,394,530	8	0.517
Cliff Lee	2010	SP	3,949,291	8	0.540
Greg Maddux	2006	SP	1,829,396	8	0.546
Martin Glendon	1903	SP	1,042,116	8	0.495
Joe McGinnity	1902	SP	5,486,751	7	0.494
Johan Santana	2005	SP	8,147,678	7	0.561
Pete Alexander	1918	SP	1,322,920	7	0.525
Charlie Smith	1911	SP	1,045,018	6	0.517
Chris Carpenter	2005	SP	7,348,377	6	0.570
Kyle Hendricks	2016	SP	6,524,026	6	0.506
Tim Hudson	2003	SP	7,899,543	6	0.532
Al Mamaux	1914	SP	2,059,239	5	0.489
Corey Kluber	2018	SP	6,635,862	5	0.481
Cy Falkenberg	1915	SP	2,228,116	5	0.448
Frank Arellanes	1908	SP	2,470,699	5	0.496
George McQuillan	1907	SP	2,322,911	5	0.415
Jacob deGrom	2018	SP	9,223,818	5	0.463
Jake Northrop	1918	SP	3,375,906	5	0.375
Jose Fernandez	2014	SP	1,883,684	5	0.557
Nick Maddox	1907	SP	2,620,891	5	0.415
Ray Caldwell	1914	SP	7,291,663	5	0.506
Roy Halladay	2005	SP	4,614,701	5	0.567
---------------------------	------------	--------	------------------	-----------	-----------
Hooks Wiltse	1915	RP	2,045,427	11	0.502
Mellie Wolfgang	1915	RP	1,975,978	8	0.516
Tony Watson	2013	RP	2,499,182	8	0.524
Oscar Tuero	1918	RP	1,938,517	6	0.409

Salary breakdown, sorted by most spent on pitching. The average is $45.93 million (51.0%) on pitching and 44.04 million (49.0%) on hitting.
.

Owner	Pitcher Era	Sal% - Pitcher	Sal% - Batters	Win%
-----------------------	------------	------------------	------------------	------------
gigrant	Modern	64.5%	35.5%	0.370
bigsteve12	Modern	59.2%	40.8%	0.235
mpitt76	Modern	57.3%	42.7%	0.531
skinndogg	Modern	56.8%	43.2%	0.543
just4me	Modern	56.3%	43.7%	0.543
garmansouth	Modern	56.1%	43.9%	0.383
marvin_katko	Deadball	55.2%	44.8%	0.173
calhoop	Modern	55.1%	44.9%	0.494
newarkwilder	Modern	55.1%	44.9%	0.457
d_rock97	Deadball	54.5%	45.5%	0.531
nordawg	Deadball	54.2%	45.8%	0.420
redcped	Modern	54.2%	45.8%	0.469
spoonfed	Modern	54.1%	45.9%	0.309
DarthDurron	Modern	53.7%	46.3%	0.444
06gsp	Modern	53.6%	46.4%	0.531
sford	Modern	53.6%	46.4%	0.531
markeking	Modern	53.5%	46.5%	0.481
bheid408	Modern	53.4%	46.6%	0.519
teamhydro	Modern	53.3%	46.7%	0.593
mensu1954	Deadball	53.0%	47.0%	0.568
milest	Modern	52.9%	47.1%	0.593
ballsweatsux	Modern	52.9%	47.1%	0.605
dorkster	Deadball	52.8%	47.2%	0.593
npg32433	Modern	52.6%	47.4%	0.469
mllama54	Modern	52.6%	47.4%	0.481
wildthings1	Deadball	52.5%	47.5%	0.506
crystalao	Modern	52.2%	47.8%	0.519
Fusion27s	Deadball	52.1%	47.9%	0.568
thehuseman	Deadball	52.0%	48.0%	0.494
contrarian23	Modern	52.0%	48.0%	0.593
mjkrunner	Deadball	51.9%	48.1%	0.593
ejstockman	Modern	51.9%	48.1%	0.432
jschirn	Deadball	51.6%	48.4%	0.395
stroh23	Deadball	51.6%	48.4%	0.370
gorbyruss	Modern	51.4%	48.6%	0.506
besterateam	Deadball	51.3%	48.7%	0.531
beauchamp	Modern	51.3%	48.7%	0.593
PennQuaker	Deadball	51.3%	48.7%	0.457
NebHusker	Deadball	51.2%	48.8%	0.481
deathdealer	Deadball	51.2%	48.8%	0.407
big_dowg	Modern	51.1%	48.9%	0.494
Sonofodin52	Deadball	51.1%	48.9%	0.457
cholatse	Deadball	51.0%	49.0%	0.432
loyalcanuck	Modern	50.9%	49.1%	0.457
cstrohmier	Deadball	50.9%	49.1%	0.580
jfranco77	Modern	50.8%	49.2%	0.642
justinlee_24	Deadball	50.7%	49.3%	0.593
odalisgagne	Modern	50.7%	49.3%	0.556
tracyr	Deadball	50.7%	49.3%	0.444
toddcommish	Modern	50.6%	49.4%	0.432
rbow923	Deadball	50.6%	49.4%	0.395
mildnhazy	Modern	50.5%	49.5%	0.519
wetwillytwo	Deadball	50.5%	49.5%	0.543
daddyzander	Modern	50.4%	49.6%	0.593
thebubbaq	Deadball	50.4%	49.6%	0.469
Jdh34	Deadball	50.3%	49.7%	0.420
sjh0825	Deadball	50.3%	49.7%	0.444
tridentric	Modern	50.3%	49.7%	0.469
discodemo	Deadball	50.2%	49.8%	0.580
marinerrott	Deadball	50.2%	49.8%	0.444
happyhours	Modern	50.1%	49.9%	0.494
dougpalm	Modern	50.1%	49.9%	0.556
magicdreamer	Deadball	50.0%	50.0%	0.481
pfan	Deadball	50.0%	50.0%	0.531
doctorcc	Modern	50.0%	50.0%	0.642
hebdomad	Deadball	50.0%	50.0%	0.580
pkearns	Deadball	49.8%	50.2%	0.617
Humdogs	Deadball	49.8%	50.2%	0.506
duhbigcat	Deadball	49.7%	50.3%	0.407
ozomatli	Modern	49.6%	50.4%	0.506
steelerfan19	Modern	49.5%	50.5%	0.309
wink0094	Modern	49.5%	50.5%	0.630
elvisgump	Modern	49.4%	50.6%	0.519
jetscanes	Modern	49.3%	50.7%	0.531
cubbies84	Modern	49.3%	50.7%	0.605
MitchellBade	Modern	49.2%	50.8%	0.556
barracuda3	Deadball	49.0%	51.0%	0.506
trd3	Modern	48.9%	51.1%	0.531
tigerrott	Modern	48.8%	51.2%	0.531
mickr9	Modern	48.8%	51.2%	0.506
jbohrman	Modern	48.8%	51.2%	0.519
chargingryno	Modern	48.7%	51.3%	0.568
buddhagamer	Deadball	48.7%	51.3%	0.481
ledfoot	Modern	48.5%	51.5%	0.593
schwarze	Modern	48.3%	51.7%	0.568
skunk206	Modern	47.9%	52.1%	0.531
northof49	Deadball	47.8%	52.2%	0.370
brianjw	Modern	47.5%	52.5%	0.654
Chisock	Modern	47.4%	52.6%	0.407
BigScungil	Deadball	47.2%	52.8%	0.407
bottomlee	Deadball	46.9%	53.1%	0.481
Zachsmikle1	Deadball	46.9%	53.1%	0.370
midknight	Modern	46.4%	53.6%	0.556
thunder1008	Modern	46.2%	53.8%	0.531
Jtpsops	Modern	42.6%	57.4%	0.630
footballmm11	Modern	42.0%	58.0%	0.519

The following table shows the weighted "Cookie Score" for each owner. The cookie score represents how many cookies your team has. For example, if every one of you players was taken 7 times, then your cookie score would be 7.00. If you are the only person to take all 25 of your players, your cookie score is 1.00. It's weighted for salary, so 200K guys don't skew the results. The average cookie score in this theme is 4.38.
.

Era	Owner	Pitcher Era	Cookie Score	Win%
------------	-----------------------	------------	------------------	------------
20	ozomatli	Modern	8.25	0.506
19	hebdomad	Deadball	8.11	0.582
19	justinlee_24	Deadball	7.69	0.608
19	buddhagamer	Deadball	7.66	0.481
19	discodemo	Deadball	7.61	0.570
19	BigScungil	Deadball	6.96	0.405
19	Humdogs	Deadball	6.88	0.519
19	wetwillytwo	Deadball	6.74	0.544
19	mjkrunner	Deadball	6.65	0.595
20	ledfoot	Modern	6.49	0.582
19	d_rock97	Deadball	6.48	0.544
20	chargingryno	Modern	6.47	0.570
19	besterateam	Deadball	6.46	0.519
19	wildthings1	Deadball	6.40	0.506
20	brianjw	Modern	6.35	0.646
20	wink0094	Modern	6.31	0.620
19	rbow923	Deadball	6.29	0.380
19	magicdreamer	Deadball	6.09	0.494
20	skunk206	Modern	5.99	0.532
20	odalisgagne	Modern	5.93	0.544
20	teamhydro	Modern	5.83	0.595
20	beauchamp	Modern	5.62	0.595
20	jfranco77	Modern	5.60	0.633
20	redcped	Modern	5.59	0.468
20	contrarian23	Modern	5.47	0.582
19	cstrohmier	Deadball	5.44	0.595
19	mensu1954	Deadball	5.37	0.582
19	marinerrott	Deadball	5.37	0.430
20	dougpalm	Modern	5.37	0.570
20	daddyzander	Modern	5.28	0.595
19	PennQuaker	Deadball	5.13	0.443
19	NebHusker	Deadball	5.09	0.468
19	thehuseman	Deadball	5.03	0.494
20	crystalao	Modern	4.96	0.506
20	mildnhazy	Modern	4.95	0.519
20	mickr9	Modern	4.93	0.506
20	Jtpsops	Modern	4.82	0.620
20	gorbyruss	Modern	4.79	0.519
19	bottomlee	Deadball	4.79	0.468
20	thunder1008	Modern	4.77	0.532
20	jbohrman	Modern	4.73	0.519
19	jschirn	Deadball	4.71	0.405
20	ejstockman	Modern	4.69	0.430
20	calhoop	Modern	4.63	0.494
20	doctorcc	Modern	4.47	0.633
19	duhbigcat	Deadball	4.46	0.418
20	schwarze	Modern	4.39	0.557
19	Jdh34	Deadball	4.37	0.430
20	cubbies84	Modern	4.33	0.595
19	tracyr	Deadball	4.15	0.456
20	jetscanes	Modern	4.10	0.544
20	markeking	Modern	4.05	0.481
20	MitchellBade	Modern	3.96	0.544
20	loyalcanuck	Modern	3.94	0.456
20	06gsp	Modern	3.84	0.532
20	just4me	Modern	3.80	0.544
20	trd3	Modern	3.77	0.532
20	spoonfed	Modern	3.75	0.316
19	Sonofodin52	Deadball	3.68	0.456
20	ballsweatsux	Modern	3.61	0.608
19	Fusion27s	Deadball	3.59	0.570
19	barracuda3	Deadball	3.48	0.494
19	marvin_katko	Deadball	3.47	0.177
19	pfan	Deadball	3.41	0.544
19	pkearns	Deadball	3.38	0.620
20	mpitt76	Modern	3.32	0.532
20	npg32433	Modern	3.29	0.468
20	newarkwilder	Modern	3.25	0.456
20	Chisock	Modern	3.23	0.418
20	sford	Modern	3.17	0.532
19	cholatse	Deadball	3.16	0.418
20	bheid408	Modern	3.09	0.519
20	milest	Modern	3.05	0.582
19	sjh0825	Deadball	3.04	0.456
19	deathdealer	Deadball	2.85	0.392
20	midknight	Modern	2.80	0.570
20	mllama54	Modern	2.74	0.494
20	garmansouth	Modern	2.64	0.367
20	tigerrott	Modern	2.60	0.544
19	nordawg	Deadball	2.58	0.405
19	stroh23	Deadball	2.52	0.380
19	dorkster	Deadball	2.51	0.595
19	thebubbaq	Deadball	2.46	0.456
20	tridentric	Modern	2.41	0.481
20	skinndogg	Modern	2.39	0.557
20	elvisgump	Modern	2.35	0.519
19	Zachsmikle1	Deadball	2.30	0.380
20	DarthDurron	Modern	2.24	0.443
20	toddcommish	Modern	2.22	0.430
20	big_dowg	Modern	2.15	0.506
19	northof49	Deadball	2.04	0.380
20	gigrant	Modern	2.01	0.354
20	happyhours	Modern	1.81	0.506
20	steelerfan19	Modern	1.76	0.291
20	footballmm11	Modern	1.64	0.506
20	bigsteve12	Modern	1.63	0.241

Here is a breakdown of Modern vs Deadball eras.
.

Pitcher Era	Teams	Sal% - Pitcher	Sal% - Batters	Cookie Score	Win%
------------------	------------	------------------	------------------	------------------	------------
Deadball	39	50.7%	49.3%	4.83	0.478
Modern	57	51.3%	48.7%	4.06	0.515

Sorted by winning%
.

Era	Owner	Pitcher Era	Sal% - Pitcher	Sal% - Batters	Cookie Score	Win%
------------	-----------------------	------------	------------------	------------------	------------------	------------
20	brianjw	Modern	47.5%	52.5%	6.35	0.646
20	jfranco77	Modern	50.8%	49.2%	5.60	0.633
20	doctorcc	Modern	50.0%	50.0%	4.47	0.633
20	wink0094	Modern	49.5%	50.5%	6.31	0.620
20	Jtpsops	Modern	42.6%	57.4%	4.82	0.620
19	pkearns	Deadball	49.8%	50.2%	3.38	0.620
19	justinlee_24	Deadball	50.7%	49.3%	7.69	0.608
20	ballsweatsux	Modern	52.9%	47.1%	3.61	0.608
19	mjkrunner	Deadball	51.9%	48.1%	6.65	0.595
20	teamhydro	Modern	53.3%	46.7%	5.83	0.595
20	beauchamp	Modern	51.3%	48.7%	5.62	0.595
19	cstrohmier	Deadball	50.9%	49.1%	5.44	0.595
20	daddyzander	Modern	50.4%	49.6%	5.28	0.595
20	cubbies84	Modern	49.3%	50.7%	4.33	0.595
19	dorkster	Deadball	52.8%	47.2%	2.51	0.595
19	hebdomad	Deadball	50.0%	50.0%	8.11	0.582
20	ledfoot	Modern	48.5%	51.5%	6.49	0.582
20	contrarian23	Modern	52.0%	48.0%	5.47	0.582
19	mensu1954	Deadball	53.0%	47.0%	5.37	0.582
20	milest	Modern	52.9%	47.1%	3.05	0.582
19	discodemo	Deadball	50.2%	49.8%	7.61	0.570
20	chargingryno	Modern	48.7%	51.3%	6.47	0.570
20	dougpalm	Modern	50.1%	49.9%	5.37	0.570
19	Fusion27s	Deadball	52.1%	47.9%	3.59	0.570
20	midknight	Modern	46.4%	53.6%	2.80	0.570
20	schwarze	Modern	48.3%	51.7%	4.39	0.557
20	skinndogg	Modern	56.8%	43.2%	2.39	0.557
19	wetwillytwo	Deadball	50.5%	49.5%	6.74	0.544
19	d_rock97	Deadball	54.5%	45.5%	6.48	0.544
20	odalisgagne	Modern	50.7%	49.3%	5.93	0.544
20	jetscanes	Modern	49.3%	50.7%	4.10	0.544
20	MitchellBade	Modern	49.2%	50.8%	3.96	0.544
20	just4me	Modern	56.3%	43.7%	3.80	0.544
19	pfan	Deadball	50.0%	50.0%	3.41	0.544
20	tigerrott	Modern	48.8%	51.2%	2.60	0.544
20	skunk206	Modern	47.9%	52.1%	5.99	0.532
20	thunder1008	Modern	46.2%	53.8%	4.77	0.532
20	06gsp	Modern	53.6%	46.4%	3.84	0.532
20	trd3	Modern	48.9%	51.1%	3.77	0.532
20	mpitt76	Modern	57.3%	42.7%	3.32	0.532
20	sford	Modern	53.6%	46.4%	3.17	0.532
19	Humdogs	Deadball	49.8%	50.2%	6.88	0.519
19	besterateam	Deadball	51.3%	48.7%	6.46	0.519
20	mildnhazy	Modern	50.5%	49.5%	4.95	0.519
20	gorbyruss	Modern	51.4%	48.6%	4.79	0.519
20	jbohrman	Modern	48.8%	51.2%	4.73	0.519
20	bheid408	Modern	53.4%	46.6%	3.09	0.519
20	elvisgump	Modern	49.4%	50.6%	2.35	0.519
20	ozomatli	Modern	49.6%	50.4%	8.25	0.506
19	wildthings1	Deadball	52.5%	47.5%	6.40	0.506
20	crystalao	Modern	52.2%	47.8%	4.96	0.506
20	mickr9	Modern	48.8%	51.2%	4.93	0.506
20	big_dowg	Modern	51.1%	48.9%	2.15	0.506
20	happyhours	Modern	50.1%	49.9%	1.81	0.506
20	footballmm11	Modern	42.0%	58.0%	1.64	0.506
19	magicdreamer	Deadball	50.0%	50.0%	6.09	0.494
19	thehuseman	Deadball	52.0%	48.0%	5.03	0.494
20	calhoop	Modern	55.1%	44.9%	4.63	0.494
19	barracuda3	Deadball	49.0%	51.0%	3.48	0.494
20	mllama54	Modern	52.6%	47.4%	2.74	0.494
19	buddhagamer	Deadball	48.7%	51.3%	7.66	0.481
20	markeking	Modern	53.5%	46.5%	4.05	0.481
20	tridentric	Modern	50.3%	49.7%	2.41	0.481
20	redcped	Modern	54.2%	45.8%	5.59	0.468
19	NebHusker	Deadball	51.2%	48.8%	5.09	0.468
19	bottomlee	Deadball	46.9%	53.1%	4.79	0.468
20	npg32433	Modern	52.6%	47.4%	3.29	0.468
19	tracyr	Deadball	50.7%	49.3%	4.15	0.456
20	loyalcanuck	Modern	50.9%	49.1%	3.94	0.456
19	Sonofodin52	Deadball	51.1%	48.9%	3.68	0.456
20	newarkwilder	Modern	55.1%	44.9%	3.25	0.456
19	sjh0825	Deadball	50.3%	49.7%	3.04	0.456
19	thebubbaq	Deadball	50.4%	49.6%	2.46	0.456
19	PennQuaker	Deadball	51.3%	48.7%	5.13	0.443
20	DarthDurron	Modern	53.7%	46.3%	2.24	0.443
19	marinerrott	Deadball	50.2%	49.8%	5.37	0.430
20	ejstockman	Modern	51.9%	48.1%	4.69	0.430
19	Jdh34	Deadball	50.3%	49.7%	4.37	0.430
20	toddcommish	Modern	50.6%	49.4%	2.22	0.430
19	duhbigcat	Deadball	49.7%	50.3%	4.46	0.418
20	Chisock	Modern	47.4%	52.6%	3.23	0.418
19	cholatse	Deadball	51.0%	49.0%	3.16	0.418
19	BigScungil	Deadball	47.2%	52.8%	6.96	0.405
19	jschirn	Deadball	51.6%	48.4%	4.71	0.405
19	nordawg	Deadball	54.2%	45.8%	2.58	0.405
19	deathdealer	Deadball	51.2%	48.8%	2.85	0.392
19	rbow923	Deadball	50.6%	49.4%	6.29	0.380
19	stroh23	Deadball	51.6%	48.4%	2.52	0.380
19	Zachsmikle1	Deadball	46.9%	53.1%	2.30	0.380
19	northof49	Deadball	47.8%	52.2%	2.04	0.380
20	garmansouth	Modern	56.1%	43.9%	2.64	0.367
20	gigrant	Modern	64.5%	35.5%	2.01	0.354
20	spoonfed	Modern	54.1%	45.9%	3.75	0.316
20	steelerfan19	Modern	49.5%	50.5%	1.76	0.291
20	bigsteve12	Modern	59.2%	40.8%	1.63	0.241
19	marvin_katko	Deadball	55.2%	44.8%	3.47	0.177

Thanks schwarze...going to be interesting sorting through the stats!

Would love to see Fielding% by era.

I only have fielding data for my own league.

Also, I think that alone isn't enough to base any conclusions on. For example, I took modern day pitchers, but I also took a bunch of hitters from the 1800's, so although my fielding percentage is slightly below the league average, it's probably way better than what would be expected given their real life error totals.

For example, Tom Daly, Denny Lyons & George Gore committed 69, 97 and 38 errors, respectively (in real life). Through 80 sim games, they have committed 25, 16 and 7, respectively. But without this information, it would appear my team is "below average" in errors despite using a modern pitching staff.

Also, for what it's worth... the last time I counted, my opponents have committed 10 more errors than I have. (There's not an easy way to tally this, other than going through every single boxscore). This means my selection of all those pre-1900 hitters is inducing more errors for my opponents.

Posted by odalisgagne on 7/5/2020 4:11:00 PM (view original):
Would love to see Fielding% by era.

This is the one thing I was hoping to see for the $90m. Even if it’s not perfect, I think it’d show a pattern

As an owner who is terrible at knowing/finding cookies, I would love it if there was an adjustment for "Cookie Score" in these leagues!

Posted by schwarze on 7/5/2020 5:18:00 PM (view original):
I only have fielding data for my own league.

Also, I think that alone isn't enough to base any conclusions on. For example, I took modern day pitchers, but I also took a bunch of hitters from the 1800's, so although my fielding percentage is slightly below the league average, it's probably way better than what would be expected given their real life error totals.

For example, Tom Daly, Denny Lyons & George Gore committed 69, 97 and 38 errors, respectively (in real life). Through 80 sim games, they have committed 25, 16 and 7, respectively. But without this information, it would appear my team is "below average" in errors despite using a modern pitching staff.

Also, for what it's worth... the last time I counted, my opponents have committed 10 more errors than I have. (There's not an easy way to tally this, other than going through every single boxscore). This means my selection of all those pre-1900 hitters is inducing more errors for my opponents.

I'm in your league and the one thing I'm noticing is all the CS. The league average team has had 236 SBA against them and has a CS% of 33.6. 8 teams have thrown out over 40% of runners against a sizeable number of attempts. Some teams are having guys thrown out at astronomical rates. 10 players have already been thrown out 20+ times on the bases.

Here is average Win % by "Cookie Score"

Cookie Score	#	Avg W%
1-2	4	39%
2-3	18	46%
3-4	22	49%
4-5	19	51%
5-6	15	54%
6-7	13	53%
7-8	3	55%
8-9	2	54%

Excluding the extremes, it looks like 1 point of Cookie Score is worth about 2-3% on your winning %. Of course, it's likely true that owners with higher Cookie Scores are just better owners as well, so it's hard to disentangle how much is from having cookies and how much is just from being better at WIS.

Posted by Jtpsops on 7/6/2020 12:54:00 PM (view original):

Posted by schwarze on 7/5/2020 5:18:00 PM (view original):
I only have fielding data for my own league.

Also, I think that alone isn't enough to base any conclusions on. For example, I took modern day pitchers, but I also took a bunch of hitters from the 1800's, so although my fielding percentage is slightly below the league average, it's probably way better than what would be expected given their real life error totals.

For example, Tom Daly, Denny Lyons & George Gore committed 69, 97 and 38 errors, respectively (in real life). Through 80 sim games, they have committed 25, 16 and 7, respectively. But without this information, it would appear my team is "below average" in errors despite using a modern pitching staff.

Also, for what it's worth... the last time I counted, my opponents have committed 10 more errors than I have. (There's not an easy way to tally this, other than going through every single boxscore). This means my selection of all those pre-1900 hitters is inducing more errors for my opponents.

I'm in your league and the one thing I'm noticing is all the CS. The league average team has had 236 SBA against them and has a CS% of 33.6. 8 teams have thrown out over 40% of runners against a sizeable number of attempts. Some teams are having guys thrown out at astronomical rates. 10 players have already been thrown out 20+ times on the bases.

There seems to be a flaw in how WIS calculates the SB/CS on the team rankings extended fielding page. It looks like the raw numbers are doubled for some reason - you can see this when you compare your catcher(s)'s personal numbers on his regular season page to your team numbers on the team rankings page.

Posted by mildnhazy on 7/6/2020 1:14:00 PM (view original):

Posted by Jtpsops on 7/6/2020 12:54:00 PM (view original):

Posted by schwarze on 7/5/2020 5:18:00 PM (view original):
I only have fielding data for my own league.

Also, I think that alone isn't enough to base any conclusions on. For example, I took modern day pitchers, but I also took a bunch of hitters from the 1800's, so although my fielding percentage is slightly below the league average, it's probably way better than what would be expected given their real life error totals.

For example, Tom Daly, Denny Lyons & George Gore committed 69, 97 and 38 errors, respectively (in real life). Through 80 sim games, they have committed 25, 16 and 7, respectively. But without this information, it would appear my team is "below average" in errors despite using a modern pitching staff.

Also, for what it's worth... the last time I counted, my opponents have committed 10 more errors than I have. (There's not an easy way to tally this, other than going through every single boxscore). This means my selection of all those pre-1900 hitters is inducing more errors for my opponents.

I'm in your league and the one thing I'm noticing is all the CS. The league average team has had 236 SBA against them and has a CS% of 33.6. 8 teams have thrown out over 40% of runners against a sizeable number of attempts. Some teams are having guys thrown out at astronomical rates. 10 players have already been thrown out 20+ times on the bases.

There seems to be a flaw in how WIS calculates the SB/CS on the team rankings extended fielding page. It looks like the raw numbers are doubled for some reason - you can see this when you compare your catcher(s)'s personal numbers on his regular season page to your team numbers on the team rankings page.

Correct, on the team defense page it tallies both the catcher stats and the pitcher involved together, so it double-counts attempts, caught stealings, and stolen bases allowed...