So drafting home run hitters is inefficient, I'm supposing that's because of the abundance of deadball pitchers. Any other trends you are seeing?

Posted by toysboys on 3/11/2024 6:03:00 PM (view original):
So drafting home run hitters is inefficient, I'm supposing that's because of the abundance of deadball pitchers. Any other trends you are seeing?

The word "inefficient" implies there is a salary cap. Since there is no salary cap, HR hitters aren't necessarily inefficient, but they are more likely to underachieve by a larger margin than non-HR hitters.

In terms of other trends, I have a couple of things I am going to try and measure once I complete posting data on all eight leagues. Then I'll post my results.

LEAGUE 4 - HITTING
(Min 285 PA to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by OPS difference)
.

Leag	Name	Year__	Team Name	Sim OPS	Act OPS	DIFF
4	Belle, Albert	1996	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	0.681	1.033	-0.352
4	Thome, Jim	1998	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	0.653	0.997	-0.344
4	Pujols, Albert	2009	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	0.758	1.101	-0.343
4	McGwire, Mark	1998	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	0.879	1.222	-0.343
4	Pujols, Albert	2001	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	0.694	1.013	-0.319
4	Belle, Albert	1994	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	0.836	1.152	-0.316
4	Averill, Earl	1936	Where are the Spiders?	0.758	1.065	-0.307
4	Pujols, Albert	2003	Cards' Pujols x 2	0.812	1.106	-0.294
4	Ramirez, Jose	2020	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	0.711	0.993	-0.282
4	Hornsby, Rogers	1922	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	0.900	1.181	-0.281
4	Rosen, Al	1950	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	0.670	0.948	-0.278
4	Pujols, Albert	2006	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	0.831	1.102	-0.271
4	Pujols, Albert	2008	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	0.846	1.115	-0.269
4	Trosky, Hal	1936	Where are the Spiders?	0.757	1.026	-0.269
4	Hornsby, Rogers	1924	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	0.935	1.203	-0.268
4	Thome, Jim	2001	Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	0.773	1.040	-0.267
4	Pujols, Albert	2004	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	0.828	1.072	-0.244
4	Speaker, Tris	1917	Indians take 5 Naps	0.678	0.918	-0.240
4	Thome, Jim	1996	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	0.825	1.062	-0.237
4	Edmonds, Jim	2001	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	0.737	0.974	-0.237
4	Speaker, Tris	1923	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	0.851	1.079	-0.228
4	Clark, Jack	1987	L4: Cards	0.831	1.056	-0.225
4	Thome, Jim	2002	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	0.905	1.122	-0.217
4	Torre, Joe	1970	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	0.679	0.896	-0.217
4	Arenado, Nolan	2021	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	0.590	0.806	-0.216
4	Averill, Earl	1934	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	0.767	0.983	-0.216
4	Hafey, Chick	1930	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	0.848	1.059	-0.211
4	Speaker, Tris	1924	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	0.734	0.942	-0.208
4	Doby, Larry	1952	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	0.717	0.924	-0.207
4	Ramirez, Manny	1998	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	0.769	0.976	-0.207
4	Ramirez, Manny	1996	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	0.775	0.981	-0.206
4	Lindor, Francisco	2016	Where are the Spiders?	0.593	0.793	-0.200
4	Lankford, Ray	1998	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	0.731	0.931	-0.200
4	Watkins, George	1930	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	0.838	1.036	-0.198
4	Hafey, Chick	1928	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	0.792	0.990	-0.198
4	Pujols, Albert	2010	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	0.813	1.010	-0.197
4	Boudreau, Lou	1948	Puzzle Indians	0.790	0.987	-0.197
4	Martinez, Victor	2007	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	0.682	0.879	-0.197
4	Speaker, Tris	1920	Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	0.851	1.045	-0.194
4	Lindor, Francisco	2018	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	0.679	0.871	-0.192
4	Keltner, Ken	1948	Puzzle Indians	0.730	0.917	-0.187
4	Frisch, Frankie	1930	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	0.742	0.927	-0.185
4	Belle, Albert	1995	Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	0.906	1.091	-0.185
4	Speaker, Tris	1922	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	0.899	1.080	-0.181
4	Musial, Stan	1950	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	0.852	1.033	-0.181
4	Justice, David	1998	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	0.658	0.839	-0.181
4	Sizemore, Grady	2007	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	0.673	0.852	-0.179
4	Cooper, Walker	1943	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	0.635	0.812	-0.177
4	Rosen, Al	1953	L4: Indians	0.859	1.035	-0.176
4	Colavito, Rocky	1958	Puzzle Indians	0.849	1.025	-0.176
4	Rosen, Al	1954	Indians take 5 Naps	0.736	0.910	-0.174
4	Carpenter, Matt	2013	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	0.704	0.873	-0.169
4	Heath, Jeff	1938	Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	0.816	0.985	-0.169
4	Rolen, Scott	2004	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	0.839	1.007	-0.168
4	Thome, Jim	1997	Indians take 5 Naps	0.835	1.002	-0.167
4	Bell, Les	1926	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	0.735	0.901	-0.166
4	Bradley, Bill	1902	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	0.726	0.890	-0.164
4	Hornsby, Rogers	1923	Cards' Pujols x 2	0.922	1.086	-0.164
4	Musial, Stan	1948	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	0.990	1.152	-0.162
4	Doby, Larry	1949	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	0.696	0.857	-0.161
4	Trosky, Hal	1940	Puzzle Indians	0.761	0.921	-0.160
4	Hale, Odell	1936	Where are the Spiders?	0.728	0.886	-0.158
4	Hornsby, Rogers	1917	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	0.711	0.869	-0.158
4	Alomar, Roberto	1999	L4: Indians	0.797	0.955	-0.158
4	Bottomley, Jim	1925	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	0.835	0.991	-0.156
4	Musial, Stan	1942	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	0.731	0.887	-0.156
4	Edmonds, Jim	2002	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	0.827	0.981	-0.154
4	Hickman, Charlie	1902	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	0.804	0.958	-0.154
4	Santana, Carlos	2019	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	0.762	0.912	-0.150
4	McHenry, Austin	1921	L4: Cards	0.775	0.924	-0.149
4	Rolen, Scott	2003	Cards' Pujols x 2	0.764	0.910	-0.146
4	Pujols, Albert	2007	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	0.852	0.997	-0.145
4	Lajoie, Nap	1906	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	0.712	0.857	-0.145
4	Lajoie, Nap	1910	Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	0.817	0.959	-0.142
4	Fournier, Jack	1921	L4: Cards	0.775	0.914	-0.139
4	Mize, Johnny	1937	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	0.884	1.022	-0.138
4	Lofton, Kenny	1994	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	0.810	0.948	-0.138
4	Bottomley, Jim	1928	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	0.893	1.030	-0.137
4	Blades, Ray	1925	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	0.822	0.958	-0.136
4	Hemus, Solly	1952	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	0.683	0.817	-0.134
4	Ramirez, Jose	2017	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	0.824	0.957	-0.133
4	Speaker, Tris	1916	Indians take 5 Naps	0.839	0.972	-0.133
4	Heidrick, Emmet	1901	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	0.705	0.836	-0.131
4	Jordan, Brian	1998	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	0.771	0.902	-0.131
4	Musial, Stan	1952	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	0.840	0.970	-0.130
4	Slaughter, Enos	1948	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	0.750	0.879	-0.129
4	Avila, Bobby	1954	Indians take 5 Naps	0.750	0.879	-0.129
4	Rolen, Scott	2006	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	0.759	0.887	-0.128
4	Edmonds, Jim	2004	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	0.933	1.061	-0.128
4	Boudreau, Lou	1946	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	0.628	0.755	-0.127
4	Slaughter, Enos	1942	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	0.779	0.906	-0.127
4	Hernandez, Keith	1979	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	0.805	0.930	-0.125
4	Averill, Earl	1938	Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	0.840	0.964	-0.124
4	Sizemore, Grady	2006	Where are the Spiders?	0.785	0.908	-0.123
4	Torre, Joe	1971	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	0.853	0.976	-0.123
4	Doby, Larry	1953	L4: Indians	0.750	0.872	-0.122
4	Trosky, Hal	1934	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	0.865	0.986	-0.121
4	Ramirez, Jose	2018	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	0.819	0.939	-0.120
4	Musial, Stan	1946	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	0.904	1.021	-0.117
4	Bottomley, Jim	1923	Cards' Pujols x 2	0.850	0.960	-0.110
4	Francona, Tito	1959	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	0.871	0.980	-0.109
4	Rosen, Al	1952	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	0.803	0.911	-0.108
4	Hornsby, Rogers	1925	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	1.138	1.245	-0.107
4	Musial, Stan	1949	L4: Cards	0.956	1.062	-0.106
4	Peralta, Jhonny	2005	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	0.783	0.886	-0.103
4	Lajoie, Nap	1907	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	0.636	0.738	-0.102
4	Pujols, Albert	2005	Cards' Pujols x 2	0.939	1.039	-0.100
4	Smith, Ozzie	1987	L4: Cards	0.676	0.775	-0.099
4	Martinez, Victor	2006	Where are the Spiders?	0.757	0.856	-0.099
4	Burkett, Jesse	1901	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	0.851	0.949	-0.098
4	Frisch, Frankie	1928	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	0.719	0.815	-0.096
4	Ramirez, Jose	2022	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	0.774	0.869	-0.095
4	Thome, Jim	1999	L4: Indians	0.871	0.966	-0.095
4	Lajoie, Nap	1913	Puzzle Indians	0.708	0.802	-0.094
4	McGee, Willie	1985	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	0.793	0.887	-0.094
4	Chapman, Ray	1917	Indians take 5 Naps	0.686	0.779	-0.093
4	Gimenez, Andres	2022	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	0.745	0.837	-0.092
4	Martinez, Victor	2005	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	0.764	0.853	-0.089
4	Wallace, Bobby	1901	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	0.715	0.802	-0.087
4	Flood, Curt	1965	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	0.701	0.787	-0.086
4	Eckstein, David	2005	Cards' Pujols x 2	0.675	0.758	-0.083
4	Ludwick, Ryan	2008	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	0.885	0.966	-0.081
4	Musial, Stan	1953	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	0.969	1.046	-0.077
4	Musial, Stan	1943	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	0.910	0.987	-0.077
4	Jamieson, Charlie	1923	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	0.792	0.869	-0.077
4	McCarver, Tim	1967	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	0.744	0.821	-0.077
4	Sewell, Joe	1925	Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	0.750	0.826	-0.076
4	Lajoie, Nap	1904	Where are the Spiders?	0.893	0.965	-0.072
4	Schoendienst, Red	1953	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	0.836	0.907	-0.071
4	Flood, Curt	1969	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	0.639	0.710	-0.071
4	Hornsby, Rogers	1921	L4: Cards	1.030	1.097	-0.067
4	Vizquel, Omar	1999	L4: Indians	0.768	0.833	-0.065
4	Speaker, Tris	1921	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	0.913	0.977	-0.064
4	Renteria, Edgar	2002	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	0.742	0.803	-0.061
4	O Neill, Steve	1922	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	0.780	0.839	-0.059
4	Jackson, Joe	1912	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	0.980	1.037	-0.057
4	Lajoie, Nap	1912	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	0.820	0.876	-0.056
4	Hornsby, Rogers	1920	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	0.934	0.990	-0.056
4	Medwick, Joe	1937	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	1.004	1.055	-0.051
4	Jackson, Joe	1911	L4: Indians	1.010	1.058	-0.048
4	Arenado, Nolan	2022	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	0.846	0.891	-0.045
4	Sewell, Joe	1924	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	0.773	0.817	-0.044
4	Jackson, Joe	1913	Puzzle Indians	0.970	1.011	-0.041
4	Doby, Larry	1950	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	0.949	0.987	-0.038
4	Kurowski, Whitey	1946	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	0.815	0.853	-0.038
4	Musial, Stan	1944	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	0.953	0.989	-0.036
4	Flood, Curt	1967	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	0.763	0.792	-0.029
4	Frisch, Frankie	1927	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	0.833	0.859	-0.026
4	Simmons, Ted	1971	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	0.746	0.771	-0.025
4	Eckstein, David	2007	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	0.715	0.738	-0.023
4	Matheny, Mike	2003	Cards' Pujols x 2	0.656	0.676	-0.020
4	Peralta, Jhonny	2014	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	0.761	0.779	-0.018
4	Smith, Ozzie	1985	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	0.700	0.716	-0.016
4	Speaker, Tris	1918	L4: Indians	0.831	0.838	-0.007
4	Hornsby, Rogers	1926	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	0.857	0.851	0.006
4	Simmons, Ted	1973	L4: Cards	0.827	0.808	0.019
4	Templeton, Garry	1979	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	0.810	0.789	0.021
4	Boudreau, Lou	1944	Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	0.869	0.843	0.026
4	Simmons, Ted	1979	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	0.912	0.876	0.036
4	Herr, Tom	1985	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	0.927	0.795	0.132

LEAGUE 4 - PITCHING
(Min 92 IP to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by ERA difference)
.

Player	SN	Team	Sim ERA	Act ERA	ERA Diff
Maglie, Sal	1956	L4: Indians	8.72	2.89	5.83
Hess, Otto	1906	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	6.82	1.83	4.99
Staley, Gerry	1949	L4: Cards	7.67	2.73	4.94
Doak, Bill	1914	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	6.07	1.72	4.35
Tewksbury, Bob	1992	Cards' Pujols x 2	6.48	2.16	4.32
Bauer, Trevor	2018	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	6.31	2.21	4.10
Bieber, Shane	2020	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	5.71	1.63	4.08
Rhoads, Bob	1906	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	5.68	1.80	3.88
Gibson, Bob	1969	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	5.96	2.18	3.78
Garcia, Mike	1949	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	5.65	2.36	3.29
Haines, Jesse	1927	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	6.00	2.72	3.28
Kluber, Corey	2014	Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	5.71	2.44	3.27
Pollet, Howie	1946	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	5.31	2.10	3.21
Bieber, Shane	2022	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	6.05	2.88	3.17
Taylor, Jack	1904	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	5.38	2.22	3.16
Moore, Earl	1903	Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	4.87	1.74	3.13
Bernhard, Bill	1903	Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	5.10	2.12	2.98
Gibson, Bob	1971	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	5.95	3.04	2.91
Perry, Gaylord	1972	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	4.80	1.92	2.88
Wilks, Ted	1944	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	5.44	2.64	2.80
Carpenter, Chris	2009	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	5.03	2.24	2.79
Pollet, Howie	1949	L4: Cards	5.55	2.77	2.78
Gibson, Bob	1966	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	5.13	2.44	2.69
Doak, Bill	1920	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	5.21	2.53	2.68
Brecheen, Harry	1948	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	4.92	2.24	2.68
Nichols, Kid	1904	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	4.68	2.02	2.66
Bagby Sr., Jim	1920	Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	5.41	2.89	2.52
Coveleski, Stan	1918	L4: Indians	4.34	1.82	2.52
Carlton, Steve	1969	Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	4.68	2.17	2.51
Wainwright, Adam	2010	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	4.90	2.42	2.48
Kluber, Corey	2017	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	4.73	2.25	2.48
Martinez, Dennis	1994	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	5.91	3.52	2.39
Lee, Cliff	2008	Puzzle Indians	4.93	2.54	2.39
Coveleski, Stan	1917	Indians take 5 Naps	4.19	1.81	2.38
Mitchell, Willie	1913	Puzzle Indians	4.29	1.91	2.38
Dean, Dizzy	1934	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	4.96	2.66	2.30
Wynn, Early	1956	L4: Indians	5.01	2.72	2.29
Gibson, Bob	1968	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	3.39	1.12	2.27
Joss, Addie	1903	Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	4.45	2.19	2.26
Gibson, Bob	1973	L4: Cards	5.02	2.77	2.25
Bernhard, Bill	1904	Where are the Spiders?	4.36	2.13	2.23
Haddix, Harvey	1953	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	5.28	3.06	2.22
Sabathia, C.C.	2006	Where are the Spiders?	5.43	3.22	2.21
Lemon, Bob	1952	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	4.70	2.50	2.20
Raymond, Bugs	1908	Cards' Pujols x 2	4.22	2.03	2.19
Sallee, Slim	1914	Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	4.26	2.10	2.16
Gibson, Bob	1970	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	5.26	3.12	2.14
Cooper, Mort	1942	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	3.92	1.78	2.14
Cooper, Mort	1944	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	4.58	2.46	2.12
Carpenter, Chris	2006	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	5.18	3.09	2.09
Joss, Addie	1904	Where are the Spiders?	3.66	1.59	2.07
Tiant, Luis	1968	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	3.63	1.60	2.03
Wainwright, Adam	2013	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	4.93	2.94	1.99
Lemon, Bob	1948	Puzzle Indians	4.81	2.82	1.99
Doak, Bill	1924	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	5.06	3.10	1.96
Flaherty, Jack	2019	L4: Cards	4.70	2.75	1.95
Gromek, Steve	1944	Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	4.50	2.56	1.94
Gibson, Bob	1965	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	4.99	3.07	1.92
Bagby Sr., Jim	1917	Indians take 5 Naps	3.82	1.96	1.86
McDowell, Sam	1968	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	3.65	1.81	1.84
Carpenter, Chris	2005	Cards' Pujols x 2	4.67	2.83	1.84
McDowell, Sam	1965	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	4.01	2.18	1.83
Cooper, Mort	1943	Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	4.08	2.30	1.78
Joss, Addie	1907	Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	3.61	1.83	1.78
Garcia, Mike	1952	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	4.12	2.37	1.75
Tudor, John	1985	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	3.67	1.93	1.74
Alexander, Pete	1927	Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	4.25	2.52	1.73
Joss, Addie	1909	Indians take 5 Naps	3.42	1.71	1.71
Joss, Addie	1906	06,24,65,96,02 Indians	3.41	1.72	1.69
Coveleski, Stan	1920	Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	4.16	2.49	1.67
Hughes, Dick	1967	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	4.34	2.67	1.67
Forsch, Bob	1981	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	4.85	3.19	1.66
Wainwright, Adam	2020	Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	4.80	3.15	1.65
Mitchell, Willie	1912	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	4.40	2.80	1.60
Lemon, Bob	1949	CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	4.58	2.99	1.59
Score, Herb	1956	L4: Indians	4.11	2.53	1.58
Gregg, Vean	1911	L4: Indians	3.38	1.80	1.58
Kluber, Corey	2018	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	4.41	2.89	1.52
Joss, Addie	1908	Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	2.63	1.16	1.47
Kluber, Corey	2015	Where are the Spiders?	4.91	3.49	1.42
Kluber, Corey	2016	Where are the Spiders?	4.55	3.14	1.41
Brecheen, Harry	1946	Musial/Pujols/Gibson	3.89	2.49	1.40
Garcia, Mike	1954	Indians take 5 Naps	3.87	2.64	1.23
Wainwright, Adam	2021	Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	4.24	3.05	1.19
Steele, Bob	1917	STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	4.01	2.84	1.17
Feller, Bob	1940	Puzzle Indians	3.77	2.61	1.16
Alexander, Pete	1926	Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	4.18	3.05	1.13
Bernhard, Bill	1902	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	3.22	2.15	1.07
Wainwright, Adam	2014	Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	3.32	2.38	0.94
Plesac, Zach	2020	5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	3.20	2.28	0.92
Lush, Johnny	1908	Cards' Pujols x 2	2.97	2.12	0.85
Feller, Bob	1946	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	2.80	2.18	0.62
Sabathia, C.C.	2008	Puzzle Indians	2.98	2.70	0.28
Joss, Addie	1902	02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	2.71	2.77	-0.06

League 4 - Team Hitting Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	DarthDurron	Cardinals	106	0.910	0.744	-0.166
STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	footballmm11	Cardinals	150	0.964	0.800	-0.164
Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	toysboys	Cardinals	99	0.910	0.761	-0.149
Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	schwarze	Cardinals	112	0.941	0.799	-0.142
Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	glowguy	Cardinals	122	0.893	0.753	-0.140
Cards' Pujols x 2	nocomm999	Cardinals	125	0.927	0.791	-0.136
Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	mllama54	Cardinals	103	0.927	0.801	-0.126
Musial/Pujols/Gibson	je3rd	Cardinals	98	0.889	0.769	-0.121
Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	redcped	Cardinals	97	0.903	0.793	-0.111
L4: Cards	3dayrotation	Cardinals	87	0.906	0.800	-0.105
Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	thejuice6	Cardinals	116	0.903	0.819	-0.084
Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	pedrocerrano	Cardinals	114	0.966	0.886	-0.081
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	BeAllEndAll	Indians	158	0.904	0.699	-0.204
06,24,65,96,02 Indians	kstober	Indians	125	0.950	0.771	-0.178
Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	thejuice6	Indians	121	0.908	0.733	-0.176
Where are the Spiders?	Jtpsops	Indians	96	0.926	0.756	-0.170
Indians take 5 Naps	barracuda3	Indians	88	0.898	0.739	-0.159
02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	ronthegenius	Indians	76	0.928	0.782	-0.146
Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	eman7400	Indians	126	0.900	0.761	-0.139
Puzzle Indians	calhoop	Indians	106	0.903	0.770	-0.132
Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	schwarze	Indians	91	0.897	0.773	-0.124
L4: Indians	3dayrotation	Indians	99	0.913	0.820	-0.093
CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	footballmm11	Indians	78	0.902	0.816	-0.087
Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	pedrocerrano	Indians	45	0.897	0.821	-0.076

League 4 - Team Pitching Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Leag	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Cardinals 1922, 1948, 1969, 1971, 2007	4	mllama54	Cardinals	5.78	2.46	3.32
Cardinals 1904-1914-1925-1937-1979	4	pedrocerrano	Cardinals	5.33	2.13	3.20
L4: Cards	4	3dayrotation	Cardinals	5.46	2.80	2.67
Cardinals 26, 52’, 66’,68’, 98	4	glowguy	Cardinals	4.90	2.27	2.63
Cardinals 1927, 34, 42, 89, 2001	4	DarthDurron	Cardinals	4.88	2.43	2.45
Cards' Pujols x 2	4	nocomm999	Cardinals	4.65	2.31	2.34
Musial/Pujols/Gibson	4	je3rd	Cardinals	5.04	2.72	2.32
Cardinals: 1928/1944/1981/2014/2022	4	thejuice6	Cardinals	4.75	2.47	2.28
Cardinals 01/24/67/09/21	4	toysboys	Cardinals	4.98	2.83	2.15
Cardinals 30-41-85-10-20	4	redcped	Cardinals	4.54	2.47	2.07
STL 2004-1953-1970-1917-2016	4	footballmm11	Cardinals	4.78	2.78	1.99
Cardinals 1943, 1950, 2006, 2002, 1920	4	schwarze	Cardinals	4.05	2.47	1.58
.
Team Name	Leag	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Naps/Indians: 1903/1925/1995/2001/2014	4	thejuice6	Indians	5.12	2.16	2.97
06,24,65,96,02 Indians	4	kstober	Indians	5.02	2.12	2.90
L4: Indians	4	3dayrotation	Indians	4.81	2.27	2.54
Indians 1910-1919-1920-1938-1944	4	pedrocerrano	Indians	5.01	2.51	2.50
5 Indians 1972 1998 2007 2018 2020	4	BeAllEndAll	Indians	4.57	2.11	2.45
Indians take 5 Naps	4	barracuda3	Indians	4.40	2.12	2.28
CLE 2017-2022-1922-1912-1949	4	footballmm11	Indians	4.86	2.62	2.24
Indians 1968, 1923, 1907, 1950, 2019	4	schwarze	Indians	4.30	2.23	2.07
Where are the Spiders?	4	Jtpsops	Indians	4.56	2.59	1.97
Cleveland 08,34,52,59 and 2005	4	eman7400	Indians	3.78	2.12	1.66
02-94-21-23-46 Blue GuardIndians	4	ronthegenius	Indians	4.23	2.70	1.54
Puzzle Indians	4	calhoop	Indians	4.04	2.57	1.46

LEAGUE 5 - HITTING
(Min 285 PA to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by OPS difference)
.

Name	Year__	Team Name	Sim OPS	Act OPS	DIFF
Ramirez, Manny	2002	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	0.788	1.097	-0.309
Vaughn, Mo	1997	Boston’s Best	0.676	0.980	-0.304
Williams, Ted	1957	Boston’s Best	0.983	1.257	-0.274
Howard, Ryan	2006	L5: Phills	0.811	1.084	-0.273
Vaughn, Mo	1998	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	0.741	0.993	-0.252
Schmidt, Mike	1977	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	0.716	0.967	-0.251
Allen, Dick	1967	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	0.721	0.970	-0.249
Hurst, Don	1929	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	0.667	0.915	-0.248
Boggs, Wade	1987	L5: Red Sox	0.808	1.049	-0.241
Allen, Dick	1964	Puzzle Phillies	0.699	0.939	-0.240
Cronin, Joe	1938	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	0.735	0.964	-0.229
Williams, Ted	1939	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	0.823	1.045	-0.222
Allen, Dick	1966	Phreakin' Phillies	0.807	1.028	-0.221
Petrocelli, Rico	1969	Boston Red Sox Huntington	0.778	0.992	-0.214
Garciaparra, Nomar	2000	Boston Red Sox Huntington	0.820	1.033	-0.213
Dimaggio, Dom	1950	Drago and Dropo	0.657	0.866	-0.209
Williams, Ted	1948	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	0.905	1.112	-0.207
Klein, Chuck	1930	Phreakin' Phillies	0.916	1.123	-0.207
Klein, Chuck	1929	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	0.858	1.064	-0.206
Magee, Sherry	1914	Puzzle Phillies	0.684	0.889	-0.205
Garciaparra, Nomar	1999	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	0.817	1.021	-0.204
Foxx, Jimmie	1939	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	0.955	1.158	-0.203
Rice, Jim	1977	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	0.771	0.969	-0.198
Lynn, Fred	1979	Drago and Dropo	0.868	1.060	-0.192
Utley, Chase	2006	L5: Phills	0.715	0.906	-0.191
O Doul, Lefty	1930	Phreakin' Phillies	0.870	1.057	-0.187
Whitney, Pinky	1929	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	0.686	0.872	-0.186
Williams, Ted	1949	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	0.960	1.140	-0.180
Abreu, Bobby	1999	Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	0.820	0.995	-0.175
Ortiz, David	2016	Drago and Dropo	0.847	1.021	-0.174
Williams, Ted	1941	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	1.113	1.286	-0.173
Williams, Ted	1947	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	0.962	1.133	-0.171
Burrell, Pat	2002	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	0.751	0.920	-0.169
Ramirez, Manny	2004	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	0.842	1.010	-0.168
Schmidt, Mike	1981	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	0.913	1.079	-0.166
Trillo, Manny	1981	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	0.569	0.733	-0.164
Martinez, Victor	2009	L5: Red Sox	0.698	0.861	-0.163
Pesky, Johnny	1950	Drago and Dropo	0.662	0.825	-0.163
Collins, Jimmy	1903	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	0.617	0.777	-0.160
Andrews, Mike	1969	Boston Red Sox Huntington	0.687	0.845	-0.158
Foxx, Jimmie	1940	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	0.837	0.993	-0.156
Abreu, Bobby	2005	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	0.726	0.879	-0.153
Abreu, Bobby	2006	L5: Phills	0.733	0.886	-0.153
Solters, Moose	1935	Boston Red Sox Huntington	0.702	0.854	-0.152
Betts, Mookie	2016	Drago and Dropo	0.745	0.897	-0.152
Harper, Bryce	2021	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	0.892	1.044	-0.152
Bogaerts, Xander	2018	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	0.734	0.882	-0.148
Utley, Chase	2007	Phreakin' Phillies	0.830	0.976	-0.146
Luzinski, Greg	1977	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	0.843	0.988	-0.145
Utley, Chase	2009	Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	0.760	0.905	-0.145
Boggs, Wade	1991	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	0.737	0.881	-0.144
Betts, Mookie	2018	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	0.934	1.078	-0.144
Harper, Bryce	2023	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	0.761	0.900	-0.139
Hurst, Don	1932	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	0.821	0.959	-0.138
Everett, Carl	2000	Boston Red Sox Huntington	0.822	0.960	-0.138
Damon, Johnny	2004	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	0.721	0.857	-0.136
O Doul, Lefty	1929	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	0.952	1.087	-0.135
Schmidt, Mike	1987	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	0.801	0.936	-0.135
Gonzalez, Adrian	2011	Red Sox 5 Pack	0.823	0.958	-0.135
Gedman, Rich	1985	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	0.711	0.846	-0.135
Daulton, Darren	1992	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	0.777	0.909	-0.132
Klein, Chuck	1932	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	0.919	1.050	-0.131
Devers, Rafael	2019	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	0.785	0.916	-0.131
Howard, Ryan	2009	Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	0.807	0.931	-0.124
Luderus, Fred	1915	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	0.709	0.833	-0.124
Utley, Chase	2008	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	0.794	0.915	-0.121
Ennis, Del	1950	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	0.802	0.923	-0.121
Polanco, Placido	2005	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	0.710	0.830	-0.120
Schmidt, Mike	1986	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	0.819	0.937	-0.118
Ashburn, Richie	1951	L5: Phills	0.701	0.819	-0.118
Martinez, J.D.	2018	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	0.913	1.031	-0.118
Utley, Chase	2005	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	0.799	0.916	-0.117
Doerr, Bobby	1949	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	0.773	0.890	-0.117
Abreu, Bobby	2002	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	0.822	0.934	-0.112
Thome, Jim	2004	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	0.866	0.977	-0.111
Ashburn, Richie	1952	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	0.608	0.719	-0.111
Greenwell, Mike	1988	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	0.837	0.947	-0.110
Stephens, Vern	1949	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	0.821	0.930	-0.109
Samuel, Juan	1987	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	0.728	0.837	-0.109
Klein, Chuck	1933	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	0.917	1.024	-0.107
Magee, Sherry	1910	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	0.847	0.952	-0.105
Pedroia, Dustin	2009	L5: Red Sox	0.713	0.818	-0.105
Garciaparra, Nomar	1998	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	0.843	0.946	-0.103
Abreu, Bobby	2004	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	0.870	0.972	-0.102
Williams, Ted	1940	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	0.935	1.036	-0.101
Ashburn, Richie	1954	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	0.716	0.817	-0.101
Ellsbury, Jacoby	2011	Red Sox 5 Pack	0.828	0.928	-0.100
Ashburn, Richie	1955	Phreakin' Phillies	0.798	0.897	-0.099
Doerr, Bobby	1940	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	0.751	0.850	-0.099
Utley, Chase	2014	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	0.647	0.746	-0.099
Yastrzemski, Carl	1970	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	0.948	1.044	-0.096
Yastrzemski, Carl	1967	Boston’s Best	0.945	1.040	-0.095
Dimaggio, Dom	1946	L5: Red Sox	0.725	0.820	-0.095
Seminick, Andy	1950	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	0.830	0.924	-0.094
Dimaggio, Dom	1942	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	0.709	0.801	-0.092
Ferrell, Rick	1935	Boston Red Sox Huntington	0.709	0.801	-0.092
Valentin, John	1997	Boston’s Best	0.779	0.871	-0.092
Hamner, Granny	1954	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	0.725	0.817	-0.092
Werth, Jayson	2010	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	0.829	0.920	-0.091
Bogaerts, Xander	2022	Red Sox 5 Pack	0.742	0.833	-0.091
Delahanty, Ed	1901	Puzzle Phillies	0.866	0.955	-0.089
Rollins, Jimmy	2006	L5: Phills	0.724	0.812	-0.088
Ellsbury, Jacoby	2013	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	0.696	0.781	-0.085
Williams, Cy	1920	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	0.776	0.861	-0.085
Bellhorn, Mark	2004	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	0.732	0.817	-0.085
Freeman, Buck	1901	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	0.838	0.920	-0.082
Ashburn, Richie	1953	Puzzle Phillies	0.722	0.802	-0.080
Cronin, Joe	1939	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	0.819	0.899	-0.080
Foxx, Jimmie	1938	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	1.086	1.166	-0.080
Williams, Ted	1946	L5: Red Sox	1.084	1.164	-0.080
Rose, Pete	1981	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	0.702	0.781	-0.079
Gedman, Rich	1986	Boston’s Best	0.660	0.739	-0.079
Speaker, Tris	1914	Red Sox 5 Pack	0.848	0.926	-0.078
Pedroia, Dustin	2011	Red Sox 5 Pack	0.784	0.861	-0.077
Pesky, Johnny	1946	L5: Red Sox	0.751	0.828	-0.077
Hernandez, Cesar	2017	Puzzle Phillies	0.718	0.794	-0.076
Doerr, Bobby	1948	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	0.817	0.891	-0.074
Rollins, Jimmy	2011	Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	0.663	0.737	-0.074
Gardner, Larry	1911	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	0.680	0.749	-0.069
Varitek, Jason	1999	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	0.744	0.812	-0.068
Speaker, Tris	1912	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	0.964	1.031	-0.067
Dykstra, Lenny	1993	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	0.837	0.902	-0.065
Rollins, Jimmy	2008	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	0.721	0.786	-0.065
Rollins, Jimmy	2004	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	0.740	0.803	-0.063
Lynn, Fred	1975	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	0.904	0.967	-0.063
Rollins, Jimmy	2002	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	0.625	0.686	-0.061
Schmidt, Mike	1980	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	0.944	1.004	-0.060
Fisk, Carlton	1977	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	0.864	0.923	-0.059
Boggs, Wade	1986	Boston’s Best	0.883	0.939	-0.056
Collins, Jimmy	1901	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	0.824	0.870	-0.046
Davis, Spud	1933	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	0.823	0.868	-0.045
Gonzalez, Tony	1967	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	0.824	0.868	-0.044
Magee, Sherry	1907	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	0.807	0.851	-0.044
Cravath, Gavvy	1915	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	0.860	0.903	-0.043
Ennis, Del	1946	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	0.807	0.849	-0.042
Ellsbury, Jacoby	2009	L5: Red Sox	0.733	0.770	-0.037
Rollins, Jimmy	2003	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	0.670	0.707	-0.037
Boggs, Wade	1988	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	0.931	0.966	-0.035
Doerr, Bobby	1942	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	0.789	0.824	-0.035
Thomas, Roy	1901	Puzzle Phillies	0.739	0.771	-0.032
Garciaparra, Nomar	1997	Boston’s Best	0.846	0.876	-0.030
Rollins, Jimmy	2007	Phreakin' Phillies	0.846	0.875	-0.029
Segura, Jean	2021	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	0.755	0.784	-0.029
Kruk, John	1992	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	0.856	0.881	-0.025
Speaker, Tris	1911	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	0.896	0.920	-0.024
Ruth, Babe	1918	Boston Red Sox Huntington	0.944	0.965	-0.021
Williams, Ted	1942	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	1.131	1.147	-0.016
Rollins, Jimmy	2014	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	0.712	0.717	-0.005
Bancroft, Dave	1920	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	0.734	0.733	0.001
Speaker, Tris	1915	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	0.830	0.827	0.003
Devers, Rafael	2022	Red Sox 5 Pack	0.883	0.879	0.004
Lieberthal, Mike	2003	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	0.833	0.826	0.007
Flick, Elmer	1901	Puzzle Phillies	0.906	0.899	0.007
Pesky, Johnny	1947	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	0.793	0.785	0.008
Boggs, Wade	1985	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	0.939	0.928	0.011
Dykstra, Lenny	1990	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	0.874	0.859	0.015
Speaker, Tris	1913	Boston’s Best	0.994	0.974	0.020
Ruth, Babe	1919	L5: Red Sox	1.141	1.113	0.028
Luderus, Fred	1918	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	0.768	0.729	0.039
Kruk, John	1993	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	0.960	0.905	0.055
Speaker, Tris	1910	Red Sox 5 Pack	0.981	0.872	0.109

LEAGUE 5 - PITCHING
(Min 92 IP to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by ERA difference)
.

Player	SN	Team	Sim ERA	Act ERA	ERA Diff
Grove, Lefty	1939	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	8.72	2.70	6.02
Rixey, Eppa	1916	L5: Phills	6.46	1.85	4.61
Martinez, Pedro	1998	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	7.38	2.89	4.49
Hogg, Brad	1918	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	6.85	2.53	4.32
Hamels, Cole	2008	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	7.30	3.09	4.21
Moore, Earl	1910	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	6.67	2.58	4.09
Wood, Joe	1910	Red Sox 5 Pack	5.67	1.68	3.99
Schilling, Curt	1996	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	7.12	3.19	3.93
Roberts, Robin	1951	L5: Phills	6.94	3.03	3.91
Mays, Carl	1917	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	5.59	1.74	3.85
Leonard, Dutch	1917	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	5.98	2.17	3.81
Schilling, Curt	2004	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	7.03	3.26	3.77
Shore, Ernie	1915	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	5.36	1.64	3.72
Carlton, Steve	1977	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	6.33	2.64	3.69
Ruth, Babe	1915	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	5.69	2.01	3.68
Wood, Joe	1915	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	5.15	1.49	3.66
Lonborg, Jim	1967	Boston’s Best	6.78	3.16	3.62
Mayer, Erskine	1915	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	5.94	2.36	3.58
Morgan, Cy	1909	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	5.28	1.81	3.47
Simmons, Curt	1953	Puzzle Phillies	6.67	3.21	3.46
Gibson, Norwood	1904	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	5.64	2.21	3.43
Bell, Gary	1967	Boston’s Best	6.73	3.31	3.42
Young, Cy	1908	Boston Red Sox Huntington	4.63	1.26	3.37
Leonard, Dutch	1916	Drago and Dropo	5.68	2.36	3.32
Alexander, Pete	1916	L5: Phills	4.78	1.55	3.23
Martinez, Pedro	1999	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	5.23	2.07	3.16
Sparks, Tully	1907	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	5.07	2.00	3.07
Ruth, Babe	1916	Drago and Dropo	5.51	2.44	3.07
Sullivan, Frank	1957	Boston’s Best	5.76	2.73	3.03
Lee, Cliff	2012	Phreakin' Phillies	6.13	3.15	2.98
Mays, Carl	1916	Drago and Dropo	5.31	2.39	2.92
Bunning, Jim	1966	Phreakin' Phillies	5.31	2.41	2.90
Wheeler, Zack	2022	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	5.71	2.82	2.89
Tiant, Luis	1972	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	4.80	1.91	2.89
Leonard, Dutch	1915	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	5.22	2.36	2.86
Bunning, Jim	1967	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	5.14	2.29	2.85
Carlton, Steve	1980	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	5.13	2.34	2.79
Bunning, Jim	1964	Puzzle Phillies	5.40	2.63	2.77
Schilling, Curt	1998	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	5.99	3.25	2.74
Carlton, Steve	1972	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	4.63	1.97	2.66
Hamels, Cole	2011	Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	5.45	2.79	2.66
Bush, Joe	1918	Boston Red Sox Huntington	4.76	2.11	2.65
Halladay, Roy	2010	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	5.05	2.44	2.61
Ruth, Babe	1917	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	4.35	1.75	2.60
Alexander, Pete	1917	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	4.42	1.83	2.59
Leonard, Dutch	1914	Red Sox 5 Pack	3.53	0.96	2.57
Alexander, Pete	1914	Puzzle Phillies	4.93	2.38	2.55
Alexander, Pete	1915	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	3.73	1.22	2.51
Hughes, Tom	1903	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	5.07	2.57	2.50
Barrett, Dick	1943	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	4.86	2.39	2.47
Clemens, Roger	1991	RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	5.09	2.62	2.47
Carlton, Steve	1981	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	4.84	2.42	2.42
Mays, Carl	1919	L5: Red Sox	4.52	2.10	2.42
Mays, Carl	1918	Boston Red Sox Huntington	4.58	2.21	2.37
Young, Cy	1903	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	4.44	2.08	2.36
Dinneen, Bill	1903	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	4.59	2.26	2.33
Clemens, Roger	1990	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	4.24	1.93	2.31
Young, Cy	1901	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	3.93	1.62	2.31
Clemens, Roger	1988	15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	5.23	2.93	2.30
Clemens, Roger	1986	Boston’s Best	4.78	2.48	2.30
Young, Cy	1904	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	4.22	1.97	2.25
Jacobs, Elmer	1918	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	4.57	2.41	2.16
Beckett, Josh	2007	Drago and Dropo	5.38	3.27	2.11
Duggleby, Bill	1906	Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	4.35	2.25	2.10
Martinez, Pedro	2002	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	4.34	2.26	2.08
Sale, Chris	2017	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	4.87	2.90	1.97
McQuillan, George	1908	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	3.48	1.53	1.95
Rixey, Eppa	1917	Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	4.21	2.27	1.94
Rowe, Schoolboy	1943	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	4.83	2.94	1.89
Arellanes, Frank	1909	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	4.01	2.18	1.83
Sparks, Tully	1906	Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	3.97	2.16	1.81
Winter, George	1907	L5: Red Sox	3.86	2.07	1.79
Wood, Joe	1912	Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	3.66	1.91	1.75
Young, Cy	1907	L5: Red Sox	3.73	1.99	1.74
Martinez, Pedro	2000	Boston Red Sox Huntington	3.48	1.74	1.74
Oswalt, Roy	2010	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	4.48	2.76	1.72
Alexander, Pete	1911	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	4.28	2.57	1.71
Foster, Rube	1914	Red Sox 5 Pack	3.41	1.70	1.71
Nola, Aaron	2018	Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	4.08	2.37	1.71
Roberts, Robin	1953	Puzzle Phillies	4.41	2.75	1.66
Grove, Lefty	1935	Boston Red Sox Huntington	4.73	3.08	1.65
Short, Chris	1964	Puzzle Phillies	3.80	2.20	1.60
Roberts, Robin	1954	Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	4.55	2.97	1.58
Roberts, Robin	1955	Phreakin' Phillies	4.81	3.28	1.53
Hughson, Tex	1944	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	3.77	2.26	1.51
Sale, Chris	2018	BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	3.55	2.11	1.44
Roberts, Robin	1952	Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	3.86	2.59	1.27
Young, Cy	1905	Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	3.07	1.82	1.25
Lee, Cliff	2011	Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	3.42	2.40	1.02
Parnell, Mel	1949	Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	3.62	2.77	0.85
Corridon, Frank	1907	Phillies' McQuillan x 2	3.31	2.46	0.85
Martinez, Pedro	2003	Red Sox 5 Pack	3.07	2.22	0.85
Nola, Aaron	2022	5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	3.96	3.25	0.71
Lowe, Derek	2002	Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	3.19	2.59	0.60
Schilling, Curt	1992	19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	2.90	2.35	0.55
Wheeler, Zack	2021	PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	3.26	2.78	0.48
Gordon, Tom	1997	Boston’s Best	4.16	3.74	0.42

League 5 - Team Hitting Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Phreakin' Phillies	Jtpsops	125	0.957	0.809	-0.148
Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	DarthDurron	125	0.894	0.750	-0.144
L5: Phills	3dayrotation	121	0.864	0.730	-0.134
Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	toysboys	125	0.902	0.780	-0.122
Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	schwarze	94	0.870	0.752	-0.118
5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	BeAllEndAll	96	0.850	0.741	-0.109
Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	thejuice6	116	0.856	0.753	-0.102
19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	richiebrown6	101	0.869	0.770	-0.099
Puzzle Phillies	calhoop	54	0.856	0.758	-0.098
Phillies' McQuillan x 2	nocomm999	92	0.842	0.758	-0.084
Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	pedrocerrano	106	0.917	0.837	-0.079
PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	footballmm11	111	0.887	0.836	-0.051
.
Team Name	Owner	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Drago and Dropo	SAKABAKBRG	112	0.880	0.718	-0.162
Boston Red Sox Huntington	Ribbentrop	113	0.902	0.760	-0.142
RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	oldtimer59	141	0.933	0.802	-0.132
L5: Red Sox	3dayrotation	106	0.929	0.805	-0.124
BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	footballmm11	136	0.944	0.823	-0.121
Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	thejuice6	104	0.889	0.769	-0.121
Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	pedrocerrano	146	0.922	0.807	-0.115
Boston’s Best	je3rd	133	0.950	0.842	-0.108
Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	njbigwig	103	0.959	0.864	-0.095
15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	kstober	121	0.964	0.873	-0.091
Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	schwarze	90	0.893	0.803	-0.089
Red Sox 5 Pack	Bill_James47	112	0.894	0.851	-0.044

League 5 - Team Pitching Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
L5: Phills	3dayrotation	5.96	2.17	3.79
Phillies 54/77/96/98/04	toysboys	5.92	2.91	3.01
19967 1976 1992 2008 2023 Phillies	richiebrown6	5.44	2.67	2.78
Phreakin' Phillies	Jtpsops	5.54	3.00	2.54
Phillies 1910-1917-1932-1986-1993	pedrocerrano	4.72	2.21	2.51
Puzzle Phillies	calhoop	4.94	2.53	2.41
Phillies' McQuillan x 2	nocomm999	4.31	1.92	2.39
Phillies 1906, 10, 25, 99, 2009	DarthDurron	4.71	2.48	2.23
Phillies: 1918/1950/2005/2010/2018	thejuice6	4.69	2.49	2.20
Phillies 1908, 1929, 1952, 2014, 1911	schwarze	4.10	2.17	1.94
PHI 1980-2021-1933-1920-1943	footballmm11	4.41	2.55	1.86
5 Phillies 1972 1981 1990 2002 2022	BeAllEndAll	4.40	2.66	1.74
.
Team Name	Owner	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Boston’s Best	je3rd	6.27	2.96	3.31
RED SOX 1941/72/91/98/2004	oldtimer59	6.07	2.76	3.31
Drago and Dropo	SAKABAKBRG	5.73	2.69	3.05
Bigwig's Red Sox (04/12/39/47/85)	njbigwig	5.22	2.21	3.01
15,38,40,88,01 Red Sox	kstober	5.33	2.38	2.95
Red Sox 1917-1949-1970-2013-2019	pedrocerrano	4.86	2.14	2.71
L5: Red Sox	3dayrotation	4.61	2.15	2.46
Red Sox 5 Pack	Bill_James47	4.39	1.95	2.44
BOS 2018-1903-1948-1975-2017	footballmm11	4.57	2.29	2.28
Boston Red Sox Huntington	Ribbentrop	4.40	2.13	2.27
Red Sox 1999, 1942, 1901, 1990, 1905	schwarze	4.07	1.94	2.12
Red Sox: 1909/1911/1944/1977/2002	thejuice6	4.11	2.11	2.00

Thanks for this. FYI, the team pitching totals for League 4 are mixed up with League 5

LEAGUE 6 - HITTING
(Min 297 PA to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by OPS difference)
.

Name	Year__	Team Name	Sim OPS	Act OPS	DIFF
Stargell, Willie	1971	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	0.670	1.026	-0.356
Grantham, George	1929	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	0.680	0.987	-0.307
Sisler, George	1922	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	0.764	1.061	-0.297
Grantham, George	1930	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	0.652	0.947	-0.295
Ripken Jr., Cal	1983	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	0.594	0.888	-0.294
Kiner, Ralph	1949	Deacon Blues	0.796	1.090	-0.294
Hoiles, Chris	1993	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	0.717	1.001	-0.284
Kiner, Ralph	1951	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	0.797	1.079	-0.282
DeCinces, Doug	1978	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	0.592	0.872	-0.280
Gentile, Jim	1961	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	0.800	1.069	-0.269
Williams, Ken	1922	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	0.773	1.040	-0.267
Bonds, Barry	1992	L6: Pirates	0.815	1.080	-0.265
Kiner, Ralph	1947	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	0.794	1.056	-0.262
Traynor, Pie	1929	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	0.609	0.865	-0.256
Tejada, Miguel	2004	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	0.639	0.894	-0.255
Robinson, Frank	1969	Summer of 69 Orioles	0.701	0.955	-0.254
Giles, Brian	2000	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	0.774	1.026	-0.252
Jacobson, Baby Doll	1921	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	0.633	0.885	-0.252
Davis, Chris	2015	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	0.672	0.923	-0.251
McManus, Marty	1922	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	0.568	0.817	-0.249
Traynor, Pie	1930	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	0.689	0.932	-0.243
Waner, Paul	1928	Deacon Blues	0.751	0.993	-0.242
Robinson, Frank	1970	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	0.676	0.918	-0.242
Dillinger, Bob	1948	L6: O's	0.561	0.800	-0.239
Williams, Ken	1925	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	0.764	1.003	-0.239
Davis, Chris	2013	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	0.768	1.004	-0.236
Stargell, Willie	1973	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	0.802	1.038	-0.236
Markakis, Nick	2006	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	0.565	0.799	-0.234
Waner, Paul	1934	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	0.738	0.968	-0.230
Jacobson, Baby Doll	1920	L6: O's	0.680	0.903	-0.223
Wagner, Honus	1912	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	0.670	0.891	-0.221
Traynor, Pie	1923	Puzzle Pirates	0.646	0.866	-0.220
Bonds, Barry	1990	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	0.752	0.971	-0.219
Kress, Red	1930	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	0.634	0.853	-0.219
Manush, Heinie	1929	Summer of 69 Orioles	0.684	0.901	-0.217
Giles, Brian	1999	L6: Pirates	0.817	1.032	-0.215
Robinson, Frank	1966	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	0.832	1.047	-0.215
Machado, Manny	2016	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	0.662	0.876	-0.214
Vaughan, Arky	1934	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	0.733	0.942	-0.209
Lopez, Javy	2004	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	0.664	0.873	-0.209
Vaughan, Arky	1935	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	0.892	1.098	-0.206
Severeid, Hank	1922	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	0.583	0.783	-0.200
Waner, Paul	1936	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	0.766	0.966	-0.200
Singleton, Ken	1977	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	0.745	0.945	-0.200
Goslin, Goose	1930	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	0.783	0.983	-0.200
Grich, Bobby	1976	Summer of 69 Orioles	0.592	0.790	-0.198
Murray, Eddie	1978	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	0.638	0.836	-0.198
Robinson, Brooks	1964	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	0.692	0.889	-0.197
Madlock, Bill	1981	L6: Pirates	0.713	0.908	-0.195
Powell, Boog	1964	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	0.810	1.005	-0.195
Waner, Paul	1930	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	0.760	0.953	-0.193
Suhr, Gus	1936	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	0.689	0.877	-0.188
Traynor, Pie	1925	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	0.653	0.841	-0.188
Williams, Ken	1923	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	0.875	1.062	-0.187
Waner, Lloyd	1929	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	0.688	0.874	-0.186
Grich, Bobby	1975	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	0.602	0.788	-0.186
Ripken Jr., Cal	1991	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	0.758	0.940	-0.182
Waner, Paul	1927	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	0.806	0.986	-0.180
Sisler, George	1920	L6: O's	0.901	1.081	-0.180
Williams, Ken	1921	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	0.810	0.990	-0.180
Anderson, Brady	1996	L6: O's	0.853	1.033	-0.180
McCutchen, Andrew	2012	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	0.776	0.953	-0.177
Tobin, Jack	1921	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	0.706	0.882	-0.176
Palmeiro, Rafael	1994	Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	0.768	0.942	-0.174
Machado, Manny	2015	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	0.687	0.861	-0.174
Williams, Ken	1924	Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	0.784	0.958	-0.174
Wright, Glenn	1925	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	0.648	0.821	-0.173
Hebner, Richie	1972	Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	0.714	0.886	-0.172
Murray, Eddie	1984	Summer of 69 Orioles	0.749	0.919	-0.170
Stennett, Rennie	1977	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	0.638	0.806	-0.168
McManus, Marty	1923	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	0.680	0.848	-0.168
Manush, Heinie	1928	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	0.822	0.989	-0.167
Parker, Dave	1977	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	0.761	0.928	-0.167
Carey, Max	1925	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	0.744	0.909	-0.165
Tejada, Miguel	2005	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	0.699	0.864	-0.165
Zarilla, Al	1948	L6: O's	0.708	0.871	-0.163
Severeid, Hank	1923	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	0.612	0.775	-0.163
Tierney, Cotton	1923	Puzzle Pirates	0.630	0.790	-0.160
Kendall, Jason	2003	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	0.657	0.815	-0.158
Hernandez, Ramon	2006	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	0.667	0.822	-0.155
Suhr, Gus	1930	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	0.707	0.860	-0.153
Tejada, Miguel	2006	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	0.725	0.877	-0.152
Waner, Paul	1935	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	0.718	0.869	-0.151
Anderson, Brady	1992	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	0.671	0.822	-0.151
Stone, George	1905	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	0.609	0.757	-0.148
Cuyler, Kiki	1925	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	0.876	1.021	-0.145
Jones, Adam	2013	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	0.668	0.811	-0.143
Robinson, Frank	1967	Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	0.839	0.979	-0.140
Kendall, Jason	2000	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	0.744	0.882	-0.138
Sanguillen, Manny	1975	Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	0.704	0.842	-0.138
Sanchez, Freddy	2006	L6: Pirates	0.714	0.851	-0.137
Ripken Jr., Cal	1996	L6: O's	0.670	0.807	-0.137
Clarke, Fred	1901	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	0.720	0.856	-0.136
Alomar, Roberto	1996	L6: O's	0.802	0.938	-0.136
Waner, Paul	1929	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	0.824	0.958	-0.134
Giles, Brian	2003	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	0.807	0.941	-0.134
Blefary, Curt	1965	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	0.718	0.851	-0.133
Murray, Eddie	1983	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	0.798	0.931	-0.133
Jacobson, Baby Doll	1925	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	0.775	0.905	-0.130
Bonilla, Bobby	1995	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	0.836	0.964	-0.128
Carey, Max	1922	Deacon Blues	0.740	0.867	-0.127
Vaughan, Arky	1936	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	0.801	0.927	-0.126
Wagner, Honus	1903	Deacon Blues	0.808	0.932	-0.124
Robinson, Frank	1971	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	0.774	0.894	-0.120
Patterson, Corey	2006	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	0.639	0.757	-0.118
Robinson, Brooks	1962	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	0.711	0.828	-0.117
Hayes, Ke Bryan	2023	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	0.648	0.762	-0.114
Clemente, Roberto	1969	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	0.843	0.955	-0.112
Oliver, Al	1974	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	0.722	0.833	-0.111
Traynor, Pie	1927	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	0.715	0.825	-0.110
Clemente, Roberto	1968	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	0.729	0.837	-0.108
Bartell, Dick	1930	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	0.739	0.845	-0.106
Kendall, Jason	2004	Puzzle Pirates	0.684	0.789	-0.105
Wagner, Honus	1909	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	0.805	0.909	-0.104
Sanguillen, Manny	1974	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	0.581	0.684	-0.103
Bonilla, Bobby	1989	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	0.747	0.848	-0.101
Bumbry, Al	1977	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	0.682	0.782	-0.100
Morris, Warren	1999	L6: Pirates	0.688	0.785	-0.097
Wagner, Honus	1901	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	0.814	0.910	-0.096
Wagner, Honus	1902	Puzzle Pirates	0.762	0.857	-0.095
Stone, George	1906	Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	0.831	0.918	-0.087
Van Slyke, Andy	1992	L6: Pirates	0.800	0.886	-0.086
Walker, Neil	2013	Deacon Blues	0.673	0.757	-0.084
Herman, Babe	1935	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	0.775	0.859	-0.084
Robinson, Brooks	1965	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	0.714	0.796	-0.082
Stephens, Vern	1945	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	0.743	0.825	-0.082
Roberts, Brian	2004	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	0.638	0.720	-0.082
Roberts, Brian	2005	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	0.822	0.902	-0.080
Beaumont, Ginger	1902	Puzzle Pirates	0.744	0.822	-0.078
Grimm, Charlie	1923	Puzzle Pirates	0.794	0.869	-0.075
Grantham, George	1926	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	0.817	0.890	-0.073
Sanguillen, Manny	1973	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	0.642	0.712	-0.070
Wagner, Honus	1905	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	0.865	0.932	-0.067
Sanguillen, Manny	1971	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	0.707	0.771	-0.064
Grich, Bobby	1973	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	0.697	0.760	-0.063
Stennett, Rennie	1974	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	0.634	0.696	-0.062
McCutchen, Andrew	2014	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	0.892	0.952	-0.060
Johnson, Davey	1970	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	0.693	0.752	-0.059
Wagner, Honus	1908	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	0.899	0.957	-0.058
Waner, Paul	1926	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	0.884	0.941	-0.057
Clarke, Fred	1909	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	0.702	0.757	-0.055
Aparicio, Luis	1966	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	0.625	0.677	-0.052
Sisler, George	1918	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	0.789	0.840	-0.051
Ripken Jr., Cal	1984	Summer of 69 Orioles	0.835	0.884	-0.049
Manush, Heinie	1930	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	0.868	0.916	-0.048
Robinson, Brooks	1960	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	0.724	0.769	-0.045
Traynor, Pie	1926	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	0.753	0.797	-0.044
Clift, Harlond	1937	Summer of 69 Orioles	0.915	0.959	-0.044
Carey, Max	1921	Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	0.784	0.825	-0.041
Wagner, Honus	1906	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	0.835	0.875	-0.040
Vaughan, Arky	1940	Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	0.808	0.846	-0.038
Powell, Boog	1966	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	0.870	0.904	-0.034
Severeid, Hank	1917	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	0.616	0.639	-0.023
Rice, Harry	1925	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	0.995	1.018	-0.023
Carey, Max	1923	Puzzle Pirates	0.820	0.840	-0.020
Clarke, Fred	1903	Deacon Blues	0.927	0.946	-0.019
Vaughan, Arky	1938	Puzzle Pirates	0.878	0.877	0.001
Walker, Neil	2014	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	0.812	0.809	0.003
Stephens, Vern	1944	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	0.835	0.827	0.008
Wagner, Honus	1904	L6: Pirates	0.980	0.943	0.037
Buford, Don	1971	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	0.938	0.890	0.048
Wagner, Honus	1907	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	0.978	0.921	0.057

LEAGUE 6 - PITCHING
(Min 96 IP to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by ERA difference)
.

Player	SN	Team	Sim ERA	Act ERA	ERA Diff
Sothoron, Allen	1918	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	6.14	1.94	4.20
Shocker, Urban	1920	L6: O's	6.84	2.71	4.13
Leifield, Lefty	1906	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	5.70	1.87	3.83
Leever, Sam	1903	Deacon Blues	5.47	2.06	3.41
Leever, Sam	1907	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	4.81	1.66	3.15
Hardin, Jim	1968	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	5.54	2.51	3.03
Drabek, Doug	1992	L6: Pirates	5.61	2.77	2.84
Palmer, Jim	1969	Summer of 69 Orioles	5.16	2.34	2.82
Barber, Steve	1965	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	5.50	2.69	2.81
Lowdermilk, Grover	1915	L6: O's	6.01	3.24	2.77
Cooper, Wilbur	1919	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	5.38	2.67	2.71
Camnitz, Howie	1908	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	4.19	1.56	2.63
Glade, Fred	1904	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	4.89	2.27	2.62
Weilman, Carl	1915	L6: O's	4.94	2.34	2.60
Flaherty, Patsy	1904	L6: Pirates	4.64	2.05	2.59
Leever, Sam	1904	L6: Pirates	4.70	2.17	2.53
Phillippe, Deacon	1902	Puzzle Pirates	4.49	2.05	2.44
Phillippe, Deacon	1905	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	4.60	2.19	2.41
Willis, Vic	1908	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	4.45	2.07	2.38
Walker, Jerry	1959	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	5.24	2.92	2.32
Moose, Bob	1972	Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	5.23	2.91	2.32
Tannehill, Jesse	1901	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	4.44	2.18	2.26
Veale, Bob	1968	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	4.29	2.05	2.24
McGregor, Scott	1978	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	5.53	3.32	2.21
Chesbro, Jack	1902	Puzzle Pirates	4.32	2.17	2.15
Ponder, Elmer	1920	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	4.76	2.62	2.14
Veale, Bob	1964	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	4.86	2.74	2.12
Boddicker, Mike	1984	Summer of 69 Orioles	4.90	2.79	2.11
Chesbro, Jack	1901	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	4.48	2.38	2.10
Pappas, Milt	1959	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	5.37	3.27	2.10
Camnitz, Howie	1907	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	4.25	2.15	2.10
McNally, Dave	1968	1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	4.03	1.95	2.08
Bauers, Russ	1938	Puzzle Pirates	5.12	3.07	2.05
Tannehill, Jesse	1902	Puzzle Pirates	3.98	1.95	2.03
Leever, Sam	1905	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	4.72	2.70	2.02
Blanton, Cy	1935	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	4.56	2.58	1.98
Cooper, Wilbur	1918	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	4.07	2.11	1.96
Phillippe, Deacon	1903	Deacon Blues	4.38	2.43	1.95
Adams, Babe	1921	Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	4.59	2.64	1.95
Wilhelm, Hoyt	1959	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	4.12	2.19	1.93
Powell, Jack	1906	Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	3.58	1.77	1.81
Pelty, Barney	1906	Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	3.39	1.59	1.80
Adams, Babe	1920	Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	3.91	2.16	1.75
Howell, Harry	1905	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	3.72	1.98	1.74
Palmer, Jim	1976	Summer of 69 Orioles	4.24	2.51	1.73
Palmer, Jim	1973	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	4.12	2.40	1.72
Camnitz, Howie	1909	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	3.31	1.62	1.69
Howell, Harry	1904	Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	3.87	2.19	1.68
Leever, Sam	1906	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	4.00	2.32	1.68
Adams, Babe	1913	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	3.81	2.15	1.66
Phillippe, Deacon	1901	Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	3.84	2.22	1.62
Bradish, Kyle	2023	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	4.36	2.83	1.53
Camnitz, Howie	1910	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	4.75	3.22	1.53
Shocker, Urban	1923	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	4.89	3.41	1.48
Mussina, Mike	1997	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	4.68	3.20	1.48
Harshman, Jack	1958	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	4.35	2.89	1.46
O Dell, Billy	1958	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	4.43	2.97	1.46
Davis, Storm	1983	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	5.04	3.59	1.45
Maddox, Nick	1909	Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	3.62	2.21	1.41
Powell, Jack	1908	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	3.50	2.11	1.39
Willis, Vic	1907	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	3.72	2.34	1.38
Howell, Harry	1906	Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	3.47	2.11	1.36
Law, Vern	1965	07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	3.39	2.15	1.24
Drabek, Doug	1990	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	3.98	2.76	1.22
Dobson, Pat	1972	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	3.86	2.65	1.21
Kramer, Jack	1944	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	3.68	2.49	1.19
Roberts, Robin	1962	St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	3.94	2.78	1.16
Swift, Bill	1935	35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	3.81	2.70	1.11
Palmer, Jim	1977	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	4.02	2.91	1.11
Adams, Babe	1911	Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	3.36	2.33	1.03
Portocarrero, Arnie	1958	Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	4.27	3.25	1.02
Kremer, Ray	1927	Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	3.46	2.47	0.99
Palmer, Jim	1975	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	3.01	2.09	0.92
Adams, Babe	1919	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	2.78	1.98	0.80
Potter, Nels	1945	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	3.27	2.47	0.80
Glazner, Whitey	1921	Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	3.51	2.77	0.74
Miller, Frank	1919	Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	3.72	3.03	0.69
Grimes, Burleigh	1928	Deacon Blues	3.68	2.99	0.69
Pappas, Milt	1964	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	3.65	2.97	0.68
Cuellar, Mike	1969	Summer of 69 Orioles	3.05	2.38	0.67
Mussina, Mike	1992	Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	3.10	2.54	0.56
Waddell, Rube	1908	5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	2.42	1.89	0.53
Bedard, Erik	2007	Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	3.60	3.15	0.45
McDonald, Ben	1993	BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	3.83	3.39	0.44
Barber, Steve	1961	BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	3.72	3.33	0.39
Cole, Gerrit	2015	Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	2.87	2.60	0.27
Boddicker, Mike	1983	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	3.04	2.77	0.27
Brown, Kevin	1995	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	3.65	3.60	0.05
Mussina, Mike	1995	Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	3.10	3.29	-0.19

League - Team Hitting Total Comparison6
.

Team Name	Leag	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	6	pedrocerrano	Pirates	68	0.918	0.747	-0.172
Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	6	thejuice6	Pirates	80	0.877	0.706	-0.171
35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	6	ronthegenius	Pirates	115	0.925	0.761	-0.164
Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	6	redcped	Pirates	77	0.888	0.731	-0.156
Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	6	njbigwig	Pirates	88	0.919	0.764	-0.155
07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	6	kstober	Pirates	66	0.890	0.738	-0.152
Deacon Blues	6	ybjsports	Pirates	73	0.903	0.767	-0.136
L6: Pirates	6	3dayrotation	Pirates	105	0.896	0.766	-0.130
Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	6	DarthDurron	Pirates	72	0.859	0.736	-0.123
Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	6	emanes10	Pirates	59	0.798	0.696	-0.102
Puzzle Pirates	6	calhoop	Pirates	36	0.845	0.751	-0.094
Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	6	schwarze	Pirates	80	0.890	0.829	-0.061
.
Team Name	Leag	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	6	pmars2001	Orioles	94	0.896	0.704	-0.193
Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	6	mllama54	Orioles	95	0.877	0.687	-0.190
L6: O's	6	3dayrotation	Orioles	102	0.894	0.717	-0.177
Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	6	toysboys	Orioles	123	0.892	0.725	-0.166
5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	6	BeAllEndAll	Orioles	137	0.836	0.672	-0.164
BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	6	footballmm11	Orioles	131	0.901	0.738	-0.163
BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	6	Dufferman	Orioles	133	0.892	0.739	-0.153
Summer of 69 Orioles	6	crazyamos	Orioles	101	0.876	0.727	-0.149
Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	6	glowguy	Orioles	99	0.819	0.681	-0.138
1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	6	jrig21	Orioles	134	0.832	0.707	-0.125
Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	6	thejuice6	Orioles	107	0.875	0.752	-0.123
Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	6	schwarze	Orioles	92	0.827	0.723	-0.104

League 6 - Team Pitching Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Bigwig's Pirates (01/36/51/71/85)	njbigwig	Pirates	4.80	2.37	2.43
L6: Pirates	3dayrotation	Pirates	4.82	2.41	2.41
Pirates 1920, 1908, 2014, 1969, 1926	schwarze	Pirates	4.41	2.12	2.29
Pirates 1906-1927-1934-1964-2000	pedrocerrano	Pirates	4.61	2.42	2.19
Pittsburgh Pirates 09-18-74-12-23	emanes10	Pirates	4.10	1.99	2.11
Puzzle Pirates	calhoop	Pirates	4.48	2.39	2.09
Deacon Blues	ybjsports	Pirates	4.51	2.58	1.94
Pirates 1911, 21, 40, 72, 75	DarthDurron	Pirates	4.32	2.55	1.76
35-05-12-47-73 Three River Pirates	ronthegenius	Pirates	4.27	2.57	1.70
Pirates: 1910/1913/1930/1990/2015	thejuice6	Pirates	4.10	2.49	1.62
07,29,65,68,03 Pirates	kstober	Pirates	3.66	2.22	1.44
Pirates 19-25-77-89-98	redcped	Pirates	3.55	2.39	1.16
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
L6: O's	3dayrotation	Orioles	5.31	2.59	2.72
1917, 1965, 2015, 1966, 1968 Browns/Orio	jrig21	Orioles	4.99	2.37	2.62
Browns 1905, 1918, 1971, 2005, 1904	schwarze	Orioles	4.27	2.15	2.12
St Louis/Baltimore Orioles	pmars2001	Orioles	4.70	2.77	1.93
Browns/Orioles: 1906/1924/1967/1994/2007	thejuice6	Orioles	3.86	2.14	1.72
BrownieOs 23/44/61/64/82	Dufferman	Orioles	4.46	2.88	1.58
BAL 1991-1973-1925-1993-1978	footballmm11	Orioles	4.17	2.69	1.48
Summer of 69 Orioles	crazyamos	Orioles	3.93	2.50	1.43
Brown Oriole 1921,1958,1997,2004,2014	mllama54	Orioles	4.13	2.77	1.36
Orioles 28/70/83/95/23	toysboys	Orioles	4.18	3.05	1.13
Browns/Orioles 45, 60, 75, 77, 92	glowguy	Orioles	3.60	2.49	1.11
5 Orioles 1908 1972 2006 2013 2016	BeAllEndAll	Orioles	3.35	2.27	1.08