Rule V Season 90 Topic

Removing best and worst seasons...Seasons 66-89
.
Rank Franchise Years _Wins_ Losses Wining%
1 Rockies 12 881 1063 3dayrotation
2 Rays 10 742 878 0.4580
3 Rangers 12 904 1041 Dougsdawgs13
4 White Sox 11 831 951 0.4663
5 Red Sox 22 1710 1854 tridentric
6 Tigers 13 1022 1085 nyyfannova05
7 Mariners 21 1657 1746 nordawg
8 D'backs 18 1426 1491 Darthdurron
9 Marlins 15 1193 1237 bigsteve12
10 Royals 14 1116 1154 ribbentrop
11 Orioles 12 963 981 schwarze
12 Pirates 10 803 817 0.4957
13 Twins 16 1288 1305 0.4967
14 Cubs 22 1775 1790 buddhagamer
15 Giants 18 1458 1458 specsman
16 Braves 22 1783 1781 alleyviper
17 Angels 10 811 809 ff09
18 Blue Jays 20 1626 1616 spikeboots
19 Brewers 17 1383 1371 0.5022
20 Dodgers 22 1797 1768 justinlee_24
21 Astros 22 1806 1759 deathdealer
22 A's 17 1410 1344
23 Cardinals 21 1744 1658 mussopini23
24 Expos 21 1758 1644 soxyanks12
25 Mets 19 1591 1487 atheistdeals
26 Reds 16 1344 1249 bullet6464
27 Phillies 20 1680 1560 captmurphy
28 Yankees 21 1771 1632 Petroff
29 Padres 22 1920 1644 newarkwilder
30 Indians 20 1754 1486 sinfonian11

Link to Rules: https://www.whatifsports.com/forums/Posts.aspx?topicID=543813
11/27/2025 11:20 AM (edited)
Season 89 Records/Season 90 Team Selection Draft Order (Timed draft begins: Monday November 24)

1. tridentric 48-114 9am Boston Red Sox #
2. Petroff 61-101 930am New York Yankees #
3. ribbentrop 67-95 10am Kansas City Royals #
4. soxyanks12 68-94 1030am Montreal/Washington Expos/Nats #
5. bullett6464* 70-92 11am Cincinnati Reds#
6. nordawg 74-88 1130am Seattle Mariners #
7. deathdealer 76-86 12pm Houston Astros #
8. nyyfannova05 76-86 1230pm Detroit Tigers #
9. schwarze* 77-85 1pm Baltimore Orioles #
10. spikeboots 78-84 130pm Toronto Blue Jays #
11. 3dayrotation 80-82 2pm Colorado Rockies #
12. captmurphy 84-78 230pm Philadelphia Phillies #
13. newarkwilder 84-78 3pm San Diego Padres #
14. buddhagamer 87-75 330pm Chicago Cubs #
15. DarthDurron 88-74 4pm Arizona Diamondbacks #
16. justinlee_24 88-74 430pm Los Angeles Dodgers #
17. mussopini23 85-77^ 500pm St. Louis Cardinals #
18. sinfonian11 86-76^ 530pm Cleveland Indians/Guardians #
19. specsman 88-74^ 600pm San Francisco Giants #
20. bigsteve12 89-73^ 630pm Florida/Miami Marlins #
21. atheistdeals 96-66^ 7pm New York Mets #
22. alleyviper 97-65^ 730pm Atlanta Braves #
23. Dougsdawgs 99-63% 800pm Texas Rangers #
24. ff09 98-64$ 830pm Cal/Ana/LA Angels #

# = Keepers Sent
* new owner
^ playoff team
% WS runner-up
$ WS champion

Division Alignment (Historical Winning Percentage Season 66-Present)
NL EAST: Rockies, Rangers, Red Sox, Tigers
NL CENTRAL: Mariners, Diamondbacks, Marlins, Royals
NL WEST: Orioles, Cubs, Giants, Braves
AL EAST: Angels, Blue Jays, Dodgers, Astros
AL CENTRAL: Cardinals, Expos/Nats, Mets, Reds
AL WEST: Phillies, Yankees, Padres, Indians

nyyfannova05; buddhagamer; justinlee_24; newarkwilder; tridentric; sinfonian11; nordawg; darthdurron; deathdealer; specsman; 3dayrotation; alleyviper; spikeboots; ff09; mussopini23; dougsdawgs13; ribbentrop; bigsteve12; petroff; atheistdeals; captmurphy; soxyanks12; schwarze; bullet6464;


ColeWilhoit
MLB143493
11/27/2025 11:27 AM (edited)
Player Draft Round One (timed schedule begins: Monday Dec. 1st)
all times - EST
1) 3dayrotation - Colorado Rockies: 10am - Tim Lincecum - Giants
2) Dougsdawgs13 - Texas Rangers: 1030am - George Brett - Royals
3) tridentric - Boston Red Sox: 11am - Roberto Alomar- Blue Jays
4) nyyfannova05 - Detroit Tigers: 1130am - Jeff Bagwell - Astros
5) nordawg - Seattle Mariners: 12pm - Curt Schilling - Phillies
6) Darthdurron - AZ Diamondbacks: 1230pm - Kevin Brown - Dodgers
7) bigsteve12 - Florida/Miami Marlins: 1pm - Justin Verlander - Astros.........................ASTROS OFF BOARD
8) ribbentrop - Kansas City Royals: 130pm - Chris Sale - Red Sox
9) schwarze - Baltimore Orioles: 2pm - Felix Hernandez - Mariners
10) buddhagamer - Chicago Cubs: 230pm - Kevin Mitchell - Giants.............................GIANTS OFF BOARD
11) specman - San Francisco Giants: 3pm - John Smoltz - Braves
12) alleyviper - Atlanta Braves: 330pm - Nomar Garciaparra - Red Sox........................RED SOX OFF BOARD
13) ff09 - Cal/Ana/LA Angels: 4pm - Fernando Valenzuela - Dodgers...........................DODGERS OFF BOARD
14) spikeboots - Toronto Blue Jays: 430pm - Pedro Martinez - Mets
15) justinelee_24 - Los Angeles Dodgers: 5pm - Willie Wilson - Royals ........................ROYALS OFF BOARD
16) deathdealer - Houston Astros: 530pm - Yadier Molina - Cardinals
17) mussopini23 - St. Louis Cardinals: 6pm - Kevin Millwood - Braves............................BRAVES OFF BOARD
18) soxyanks12 - Mon/Wash Expos/Nats: 630pm - Vince Coleman - Cardinals.........CARDINALS OFF BOARD
19) atheistdeals - New York Mets: 7pm - Bryce Harper - Expos/Nats
20) bullet6464 - Cincinnati Red: 730pm - Jim Thome - Indians/Guardians
21) captmurphy - Philadelphia Phillies: 8pm - Alex Rodriguez - Mariners.................MARINERS OFF BOARD
22) Petroff - New York Yankees: 830pm - Manny Ramirez - Indians/Guardians.......CLEVELAND OFF BOARD
23) newarkwilder - San Diego Padres: 9pm - Paul Goldschmidt - Diamondbacks
24) sinfonian11 - Cleve Indians/Guardians: 930pm - Joey Votto - Reds

Player Draft Round Two (timed schedule begins: Tuesday December 2nd)
all times - EST
1) 3dayrotation - Colorado Rockies: 10am - Tom Seaver - Mets
2) Dougsdawgs13 - Texas Rangers: 1030am - Yoshinobu Yamamoto - Dodgers
3) tridentric - Boston Red Sox: 11am - Hideo Nomo - Dodgers...........................DODGERS OFF BOARD
4) nyyfannova05 - Detroit Tigers: 1130am - Gerritt Cole - Yankees
5) nordawg - Seattle Mariners: 12pm - George Foster - Reds
6) Darthdurron - AZ Diamondbacks: 1230pm - Carlton Fisk - Red Sox
7) bigsteve12 - Florida/Miami Marlins: 1pm - Zack Greinke - Diamondbacks
8) ribbentrop - Kansas City Royals: 130pm - Bruce Sutter - Cubs
9) schwarze - Baltimore Orioles: 2pm - Andre Dawson - Expos/Nats
10) buddhagamer - Chicago Cubs: 230pm - Don Sutton - Astros
11) specman - San Francisco Giants: 3pm - Spencer Strider - Braves
12) alleyviper - Atlanta Braves: 330pm - Gerrit Cole - Astros................................ASTROS OFF BOARD
13) ff09 - Cal/Ana/LA Angels: 4pm - Rickey Henderson - Yankees......................YANKEES OFF BOARD
14) spikeboots - Toronto Blue Jays: 430pm - Ryne Sandberg - Cubs..................CUBS OFF BOARD
15) justinelee_24 - Los Angeles Dodgers: 5pm - Chris Carpenter - Cardinals
16) deathdealer - Houston Astros: 530pm - Tony Phillips - Tigers
17) mussopini23 - St. Louis Cardinals: 6pm - Pete Rose - Reds............................REDS OFF BOARD
18) soxyanks12 - Mon/Wash Expos/Nats: 630pm - Pete Rose - Phillies
19) atheistdeals - New York Mets: 7pm - Mookie Betts - Red Sox ........................RED SOX OFF BOARD
20) bullet6464 - Cincinnati Red: 730pm - Cliff Lee - Mariners
21) captmurphy - Philadelphia Phillies: 8pm - Willie Hernandez - Tigers................TIGERS OFF BOARD
22) Petroff - New York Yankees: 830pm - George Kirby - Mariners........................MARINERS OFF BOARD
23) newarkwilder - San Diego Padres: 9pm - Troy Tulowitzki - Rockies
24) sinfonian11 - Cleve Indians/Guardians: 930pm - Max Fried - Braves................BRAVES OFF BOARD


Player Draft Round Three (timed schedule begins: TBD)
all times - EST
1) 3dayrotation - Colorado Rockies: 10am - Madison Bumgarner - Giants
2) Dougsdawgs13 - Texas Rangers: 1030am - Jose Reyes - Mets
3) tridentric - Boston Red Sox: 11am - Ken Singleton - Orioles
4) nyyfannova05 - Detroit Tigers: 1130am - Brad Zeigler - Diamondbacks
5) nordawg - Seattle Mariners: 12pm - Mark Fidrych - Tigers
6) Darthdurron - AZ Diamondbacks: 1230pm - Reggie Smith - Dodgers
7) bigsteve12 - Florida/Miami Marlins: 1pm - Daniel Hudson - Diamondbacks .......DBACKS OFF BOARD
8) ribbentrop - Kansas City Royals: 130pm - Marco Scutaro - Giants......................GIANTS OFF BOARD
9) schwarze - Baltimore Orioles: 2pm - Brad Keller - Royals
10) buddhagamer - Chicago Cubs: 230pm - Ozzie Smith - Cardinals
11) specman - San Francisco Giants: 3pm - Andruw Jones - Braves
12) alleyviper - Atlanta Braves: 330pm - Dave Righetti - Yankees
13) ff09 - Cal/Ana/LA Angels: 4pm - Emmanuel Clase - Indians/Guardians
14) spikeboots - Toronto Blue Jays: 430pm - Walker Buehler - Dodgers................DODGERS OFF BOARD
15) justinelee_24 - Los Angeles Dodgers: 5pm - Andres Gallaraga - Rockies
16) deathdealer - Houston Astros: 530pm - Armando Benitez - Marlins
17) mussopini23 - St. Louis Cardinals: 6pm - Sean Doolittle - Expos/Nats
18) soxyanks12 - Mon/Wash Expos/Nats: 630pm - Trevor Story - Rockies................ROCKIES OFF BOARD
19) atheistdeals - New York Mets: 7pm - Hanley Ramirez - Marlins..........................MARLINS OFF BOARD
20) bullet6464 - Cincinnati Red: 730pm - Wade Boggs - Yankees............................YANKEES OFF BOARD
21) captmurphy - Philadelphia Phillies: 8pm - Pascual Perez - Expos/Nats..........EXPOS/NATS OFF BOARD
22) Petroff - New York Yankees: 830pm - Dan Quisenberry - Royals....................ROYALS OFF BOARD
23) newarkwilder - San Diego Padres: 9pm - Randy Johnson - Astros
24) sinfonian11 - Cleve Indians/Guardians: 930pm - Kevin Mitchell - Reds
12/5/2025 1:12 PM (edited)
List of Keepers/Draft Picks

Colorado Rockies: Todd Helton, D.J. LaMahieu, Nolan Arenado, Larry Walker, Charlie Blackmon, Tim Lincecum, Ellis Burks, Tom Seaver, Ubaldo Jimenez, Madison Bumgarner

Texas Rangers: Nolan Ryan, Bert Blyleven, Josh Hamilton, Alex Rodriguez, Corey Seager, George Brett, Nathan Eovaldi, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Mike Napoli, Jose Reyes

Boston Red Sox: Pedro Martinez, Derek Lowe, Roger Clemens, Wade Boggs, Fred Lynn, Roberto Alomar, Garrett Crochet, Hideo Nomo, David Ortiz, Ken Singleton

Detroit Tigers: Miguel Cabrera, Maglio Ordonez, Max Scherzer, Justin Verlander, Tarik Skubal, Jeff Bagwell, Alan Trammell, Gerrit Cole, Tyler Holton, Brad Zeigler

Seattle Mariners: Ken Griffey Jr., Edgar Martinez, Ichiro Suzuki, Randy Johnson, Cal Raleigh, Curt Schilling, Bret Boone, George Foster, Norm Charlton, Mark Fidrych

Arizona Diamondbacks: Randy Johnson, Zac Gallen, Curt Schilling, Ketel Marte, Luis Gonzalez, Kevin Brown, Geraldo Perdomo, Carlton Fisk, A.J. Pollock, Reggie Smith

Florida/Miami Marlins: Kevin Brown, Sandy Alcantara, Jose Fernandez, Luis Arreaz, Gary Sheffield, Justin Verlander, Dee Gordon, Zack Greinke, Luis Castillo, Daniel Hudson

Kansas City Royals: Bobby Witt, Bret Saberhagen, Kevin Appier, Zack Greinke, David Cone, Chris Sale, Darrel Porter, Bruce Sutter, Larry Gura, Marco Scutaro

Baltimore Orioles: Jim Palmer, Chris Hoiles, Roberto Alomar, Cal Ripken Jr., Brady Anderson, Felix Hernandez, Manny Machado, Andre Dawson, Eddie Murray, Brad Keller

Chicago Cubs: Jake Arrieta , Greg Maddux, Yu Darvish, Sammy Sosa, Derek Lee, Kevin Mitchell, Rick Wilkins, Don Sutton, Kyle Hendricks, Ozzie Smith

San Francisco Giants: Buster Posey, Jeff Kent, Rich Aurelia, Barry Bonds, Jason Schmidt, John Smoltz, Will Clark, Spencer Strider, Matt Williams, Andruw Jones

Atlanta Braves: Chipper Jones, Freddy Freeman, Marcel Ozuna, Ronald Acuna Jr., Greg Maddux, Nomar Garciaparra, Chris Sale, Gerrit Cole, Kris Medlen, Dave Righetti

Cal/Ana/LA Angels: Garrett Richards, Frank Tanana, Mike Trout, Shohei Ohtani (H), Mark Teixiera, Fernando Valenzuela, Darin Erstad, Rickey Henderson, Doug DeCinces, Emmanuel Clase

Toronto Blue Jays: Roger Clemens, Jose Bautista, John Olerud, Carlos Delgado, Tony Fernandez, Pedro Martinez, Roy Halladay, Ryne Sandberg, B.J. Ryan, Walker Buehler

Los Angeles Dodgers: Shohei Ohtani (H), Zack Greinke, Orel Hershiser, Clayton Kershaw, Tony Gonsolin, Willie Wilson, Cody Bellinger, Chris Carpenter, Max Scherzer, Andres Galarraga

Houston Astros: Mike Scott, Lance Berkman, Nolan Ryan, Roger Clemens, J.R. Richard, Yadir Molina, Craig Biggio, Tony Phillips, Alex Bregman, Armando Benitez

St. Louis Cardinals: John Tudor, Adam Wainright, Albert Pujols, Mark McGwire, Willie McGee, Kevin Millwood, Ted Simmons, Pete Rose, Jose DeLeon, Sean Doolittle

Mon/Wash Expos/Nats: Pedro Martinez, Max Scherzer, Tim Burke, Tim Raines, Juan Soto, Vince Coleman, Bryn Smith, Pete Rose, Vlad Guerrero, Trevor Story

New York Mets: Jacob deGrom, Dwight Gooden, Matt Harvey, Carlos Beltran, Mike Piazza, Bryce Harper, David Wright, Mookie Betts, Bob Ojeda, Hanley Ramirez

Cincinnati Reds: Tom Seaver, Johnny Cueto, Trevor Bauer, Joe Morgan, Eric Davs, Jim Thome, Barry Larkin, Cliff Lee, Shin Soo Choo, Wade Boggs

Philadelphia Phillies: Chase Utley, Mike Schmidt, Bryce Harper, Roy Halladay, Zack Wheeler, Alex Rodriguez, Aaron Nola, Willie Hernandez, Ryan Howard, Pascal Perez

New York Yankees: Bernie Williams, Alex Rodriguez, Aaron Judge, Paul O'Neill, Ron Guidry, Manny Ramirez, Catfish Hunter, George Kirby, Derek Jeter, Dan Quisenberry

San Diego Padres: Dinelson Lamet, Jake Peavy, Kevin Brown, Tony Gwynn, Ken Caminiti, Paul Goldschmidt, Randy Jones, Troy Tulowitzki, Adrian Morejon, Randy Johnson

Cleveland Indians/Guardians: Kenny Lofton, Roberto Alomar, Albert Belle, Corey Kluber, Shane Bieber, Joey Votto, Jose Ramirez, Max Fried, Victor Martinez, Kevin Mitchell
12/5/2025 1:16 PM (edited)
Round 3 Keepers Received 24
Dodgers
Orioles
Astros
Angels
Reds
Red Sox

Cubs
Yankees

Royals
Mets
Rockies
Mariners
Rangers
Indians/Guardians
Tigers
Marlins
Expos/Nats
Braves
Phillies
Giants
Padres
Cards
Blue Jays
DBacks



Round 3 Keepers Not Received 0
12/3/2025 11:57 AM (edited)
looking forward to try to repeat my success last season!!
11/18/2025 12:58 PM
Posted by schwarze on 11/21/2025 9:14:00 PM (view original):
I didn't get in?
Looks like you’re team picking 9th...
11/23/2025 9:46 AM
Boston Red Sox
11/23/2025 10:25 AM
NY YANKEES
11/24/2025 7:56 AM
Kansas City Royals
11/24/2025 8:19 AM
Les Expos please
11/24/2025 9:49 AM
Mariners
11/24/2025 11:31 AM
Astros
11/24/2025 12:02 PM
A's
11/24/2025 12:35 PM
Baltimore Orioles
11/24/2025 1:29 PM
1|2|3...10 Next ▸
Rule V Season 90 Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.