| Lineup | John Jay | PG - George Stanford (fresh) SG - John Ray (fresh) SF - Richard Harvey (fresh) PF - Jeffrey Lahti (fresh) C - Harold Hall (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Mark Whetstone (fresh) SG - Shannon Ybarra (fresh) SF - Kelly McQuaid (fresh) PF - Mark Kimbrough (fresh) C - Michael Dunbar (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | John Jay | Richard Harvey wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (0) | |
| Game Plan | Otterbein | Otterbein is playing a fastbreak offense and a fullcourt press (0) | |
| 19:34 | John Jay | Jeffrey Lahti knocks in the shot from the left block set up by George Stanford and he's fouled by Mark Kimbrough - foul #1 on Mark Kimbrough, team foul #1 | 2-0 |
| 19:34 | John Jay | Jeffrey Lahti makes the free throw | 3-0 |
| 19:23 | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid drills a fadeaway from the baseline set up by Shannon Ybarra | 3-2 |
| 19:07 | John Jay | Harold Hall can't connect on a jumpshot from the free throw line | 3-2 |
| 19:06 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Mark Kimbrough | 3-2 |
| 19:02 | Otterbein | Shannon Ybarra can't connect on a fadeaway from just outside the lane | 3-2 |
| 19:00 | John Jay | The rebound goes to Jeffrey Lahti | 3-2 |
| 18:46 | John Jay | Harold Hall is hacked by Michael Dunbar - foul #1 on Michael Dunbar, team foul #2 | 3-2 |
| 18:31 | John Jay | Jeffrey Lahti hits the front of the rim on the shot from the left block | 3-2 |
| 18:29 | Otterbein | Mark Kimbrough pulls down the rebound | 3-2 |
| 18:09 | Otterbein | Shannon Ybarra's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 3-2 |
| 17:55 | John Jay | Jeffrey Lahti is fouled on the floor by Mark Kimbrough - foul #2 on Mark Kimbrough, team foul #3 | 3-2 |
| Subs | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong (PG), Robert Cates (SG), Brian Newsome (SF), James Bohm (PF), Jeff Spier (C) George Stanford, John Ray, Richard Harvey, Jeffrey Lahti, Harold Hall | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Mark Watson (PF) Mark Kimbrough | |
| 17:50 | John Jay | Robert Cates can't connect on an uncontested 3pt shot from the right corner | 3-2 |
| 17:49 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar grabs the defensive rebound | 3-2 |
| 17:41 | Otterbein | Mark Watson makes the 3 from the right corner on a nice dish by Shannon Ybarra | 3-5 |
| 17:39 | John Jay | Shannon Ybarra is called for the reach on Daniel Armstrong in the backcourt - foul #1 on Shannon Ybarra, team foul #4 | 3-5 |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Brock (PG), William Clement (SG), Robert Jacobson (C) Mark Whetstone, Shannon Ybarra, Michael Dunbar | |
| 17:17 | John Jay | Brian Newsome clanks a turnaround near the basket | 3-5 |
| 17:15 | Otterbein | Robert Jacobson pulls down the rebound | 3-5 |
| 17:11 | Otterbein | Mark Watson makes the jumpshot from the left side set up by William Clement | 3-7 |
| 17:08 | John Jay | Robert Jacobson steps in front of the Robert Cates pass in the backcourt | 3-7 |
| 16:56 | Otterbein | William Clement scores on a shot from the right side | 3-9 |
| 16:45 | John Jay | James Bohm misses the turnaround in the paint | 3-9 |
| 16:43 | John Jay | James Bohm snags the offensive board | 3-9 |
| 16:25 | John Jay | Robert Cates hits the front of the rim on the wide open jumper from the right wing | 3-9 |
| 16:23 | Otterbein | James Brock pulls down the rebound | 3-9 |
| 16:18 | Otterbein | James Brock misses short on a fadeaway from the right wing but he's fouled by Brian Newsome - foul #1 on Brian Newsome, team foul #1 | 3-9 |
| Subs | John Jay | George Stanford (PG), John Ray (SG), David Carlson (SF), Jeffrey Lahti (PF), Edward Batiste (C) Daniel Armstrong, Robert Cates, Brian Newsome, James Bohm, Jeff Spier | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Mark Whetstone (PG), Shannon Ybarra (SG), Robert Vernon (SF), Michael Dunbar (C) William Clement, Kelly McQuaid, Mark Watson, Robert Jacobson | |
| 16:18 | Otterbein | James Brock makes the 1st free throw | 3-10 |
| 16:18 | Otterbein | James Brock makes the 2nd free throw | 3-11 |
| 15:53 | John Jay | David Carlson misses long on a pull-up jumper from the left wing but he's hacked by Robert Vernon - foul #1 on Robert Vernon, team foul #5 | 3-11 |
| Subs | John Jay | Harold Hall (C) Edward Batiste | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Mark Watson (PF) James Brock | |
| 15:53 | John Jay | David Carlson makes the 1st free throw | 4-11 |
| 15:53 | John Jay | David Carlson makes the 2nd free throw | 5-11 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - George Stanford (fresh) 1 ast. SG - John Ray (fresh) SF - David Carlson (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Jeffrey Lahti (fresh) 3 pts. C - Harold Hall (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Mark Whetstone (fresh) SG - Shannon Ybarra (fresh) 2 ast. SF - Robert Vernon (fresh) PF - Mark Watson (fresh) 5 pts. C - Michael Dunbar (fresh) | |
| 15:36 | Otterbein | Mark Watson misses long on a fadeaway from the left side | 5-11 |
| 15:35 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar tips it back up and in | 5-13 |
| 15:31 | John Jay | John Ray is hacked by Shannon Ybarra in the backcourt - foul #2 on Shannon Ybarra, team foul #6 | 5-13 |
| Subs | John Jay | Richard Harvey (SF) David Carlson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid (SF) Shannon Ybarra | |
| 15:16 | John Jay | Jeffrey Lahti clanks a 3 from straight away | 5-13 |
| 15:15 | John Jay | Richard Harvey hits the follow up shot | 7-13 |
| 14:51 | Otterbein | Mark Whetstone connects on the pull-up jumper from the left side set up by Kelly McQuaid | 7-15 |
| 14:36 | John Jay | Richard Harvey misses the easy layup | 7-15 |
| 14:34 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Robert Vernon | 7-15 |
| 14:29 | Otterbein | John Ray steps in front of the Mark Whetstone pass | 7-15 |
| 14:24 | John Jay | George Stanford lays it up and in on a nice dish by John Ray | 9-15 |
| 14:18 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar's fadeaway is rejected by Jeffrey Lahti | 9-15 |
| 14:16 | John Jay | Harold Hall pulls down the rebound | 9-15 |
| 14:00 | John Jay | Richard Harvey misses long on an open fadeaway jumper from the right side | 9-15 |
| 13:59 | John Jay | Richard Harvey gets the offensive rebound | 9-15 |
| 13:41 | John Jay | Jeffrey Lahti hits a shot from just outside the lane on a nice dish by Richard Harvey | 11-15 |
| 13:19 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Lahti is called for the reach on Mark Watson - foul #1 on Jeffrey Lahti, team foul #2 | 11-15 |
| Subs | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong (PG), Robert Cates (SG), Brian Newsome (SF), James Bohm (PF), Jeff Spier (C) George Stanford, John Ray, Richard Harvey, Jeffrey Lahti, Harold Hall | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook (PG), William Clement (SG), James Brock (SF), Robert Jacobson (PF) Mark Whetstone, Robert Vernon, Kelly McQuaid, Mark Watson | |
| 12:59 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar is called for a moving pick - foul #2 on Michael Dunbar, team foul #7 | 11-15 |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Mark Watson (C) Michael Dunbar | |
| 12:39 | John Jay | James Bohm misses badly on a shot from the left block | 11-15 |
| 12:38 | John Jay | Brian Newsome tips it back up and in | 13-15 |
| 12:21 | Otterbein | Mark Watson comes up short on the pull-up jumper from the right side but he's fouled by Jeff Spier - foul #1 on Jeff Spier, team foul #3 | 13-15 |
| 12:21 | Otterbein | Mark Watson makes the 1st free throw | 13-16 |
| 12:21 | Otterbein | Mark Watson makes the 2nd free throw | 13-17 |
| 12:05 | John Jay | Jeff Spier misses long on a runner from the left block but he's hacked by Robert Jacobson - foul #1 on Robert Jacobson, team foul #8 | 13-17 |
| Subs | John Jay | George Stanford (PG), David Carlson (SF) Daniel Armstrong, Brian Newsome | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid (SF) Mark Watson | |
| 12:05 | John Jay | Jeff Spier misses the 1st free throw | 13-17 |
| 12:05 | John Jay | Jeff Spier makes the 2nd free throw | 14-17 |
| 11:44 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook buries a pull-up jumper from the right side on a great pass from James Brock | 14-19 |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - George Stanford (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Robert Cates (fairly fresh) SF - David Carlson (fresh) 2 pts. PF - James Bohm (fresh) C - Jeff Spier (fairly fresh) 1 pts. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Jeffrey Cook (fairly fresh) 2 pts. SG - William Clement (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SF - Kelly McQuaid (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Robert Jacobson (fairly fresh) C - James Brock (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. | |
| 11:27 | John Jay | Kelly McQuaid picks off the pass by George Stanford | 14-19 |
| 11:22 | Otterbein | Robert Jacobson is fouled on the floor by David Carlson - foul #1 on David Carlson, team foul #4 | 14-19 |
| Subs | John Jay | John Ray (SG), Jeffrey Lahti (PF), Edward Batiste (C) Robert Cates, James Bohm, Jeff Spier | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Mark Whetstone (PG), Mark Watson (PF) Jeffrey Cook, William Clement | |
| 11:03 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Lahti is called for the reach on James Brock - foul #2 on Jeffrey Lahti, team foul #5 | 14-19 |
| Subs | John Jay | James Bohm (PF) Jeffrey Lahti | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Robert Vernon (SG) James Brock | |
| 10:58 | Otterbein | Robert Jacobson scores on a fadeaway jumper from the free throw line on a great pass from Kelly McQuaid | 14-21 |
| 10:44 | John Jay | James Bohm makes the turnaround near the basket and the foul's on Robert Jacobson - foul #2 on Robert Jacobson, team foul #9 | 16-21 |
| Subs | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong (PG) George Stanford | |
| Subs | Otterbein | James Brock (C) Robert Jacobson | |
| 10:44 | John Jay | James Bohm misses the free throw | 16-21 |
| 10:44 | Otterbein | James Brock gets the rebound | 16-21 |
| 10:41 | Otterbein | Mark Whetstone travels in the backcourt | 16-21 |
| 10:28 | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong misses long on a floater from the baseline but he's fouled by Mark Whetstone - foul #1 on Mark Whetstone, team foul #10 | 16-21 |
| Subs | John Jay | Brian Newsome (SG), Richard Harvey (SF) John Ray, David Carlson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 10:28 | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong misses the 1st free throw | 16-21 |
| 10:28 | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong makes the 2nd free throw | 17-21 |
| 10:03 | Otterbein | James Brock misses badly on a turnaround in the paint | 17-21 |
| 10:01 | John Jay | Richard Harvey grabs the board | 17-21 |
| 09:41 | John Jay | James Brock picks off the pass by Richard Harvey | 17-21 |
| 09:16 | Otterbein | James Brock clanks a pull-up jumper from the left wing | 17-21 |
| 09:14 | John Jay | James Bohm gets the rebound | 17-21 |
| 09:02 | John Jay | James Bohm is by himself and knocks in the fadeaway from the left block | 19-21 |
| 08:58 | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid scores on a jumper in the paint | 19-23 |
| 08:40 | John Jay | James Brock takes the ball from Daniel Armstrong | 19-23 |
| 08:17 | Otterbein | James Brock misses long on a fadeaway from the right side | 19-23 |
| 08:16 | John Jay | Richard Harvey grabs the board | 19-23 |
| 08:13 | John Jay | Brian Newsome is hacked by Robert Vernon in the backcourt - foul #2 on Robert Vernon, team foul #11 | 19-23 |
| Subs | John Jay | George Stanford (PG), Robert Cates (SF), Jeff Spier (PF), Harold Hall (C) Daniel Armstrong, Richard Harvey, James Bohm, Edward Batiste | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook (PG), William Clement (SG) Mark Whetstone, Robert Vernon | |
| 08:13 | John Jay | Brian Newsome makes the 1st free throw | 20-23 |
| 08:13 | John Jay | Brian Newsome makes the 2nd free throw | 21-23 |
| 07:50 | Otterbein | Harold Hall swats the short shot by James Brock | 21-23 |
| 07:49 | Otterbein | Mark Watson hits the follow up shot | 21-25 |
| 07:47 | John Jay | Brian Newsome's pass is intercepted by Jeffrey Cook in the backcourt | 21-25 |
| 07:37 | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid is whistled for traveling | 21-25 |
| Subs | John Jay | David Carlson (SF) Brian Newsome | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - George Stanford (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Robert Cates (fresh) SF - David Carlson (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Jeff Spier (fresh) 1 pts. C - Harold Hall (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Jeffrey Cook (fresh) 2 pts. SG - William Clement (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SF - Kelly McQuaid (tired) 4 pts. PF - Mark Watson (tired) 9 pts. C - James Brock (tiring) 2 pts. 1 ast. 2 stl. | |
| 07:35 | John Jay | Robert Cates is fouled in the backcourt by William Clement - foul #1 on William Clement, team foul #12 | 21-25 |
| 07:35 | John Jay | Robert Cates misses the 1st free throw | 21-25 |
| 07:35 | John Jay | Robert Cates makes the 2nd free throw | 22-25 |
| 07:16 | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid misses long on a floater near the basket but the foul's on George Stanford - foul #1 on George Stanford, team foul #6 | 22-25 |
| Subs | John Jay | John Ray (SG) David Carlson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 07:16 | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid makes the 1st free throw | 22-26 |
| 07:16 | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid makes the 2nd free throw | 22-27 |
| 06:56 | John Jay | John Ray connects on the 3pt shot from the left corner | 25-27 |
| 06:31 | Otterbein | Robert Cates takes the ball from William Clement | 25-27 |
| 06:14 | John Jay | John Ray can't connect on a 3pt attempt from straight away | 25-27 |
| 06:12 | Otterbein | William Clement pulls down the rebound | 25-27 |
| 06:12 | Otterbein | Otterbein calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 25-27 |
| Subs | John Jay | James Bohm (PF) Jeff Spier | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 05:43 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook scores on a jumper from the right block set up by Kelly McQuaid | 25-29 |
| 05:24 | John Jay | George Stanford is whistled for a carry | 25-29 |
| Subs | John Jay | David Carlson (SF), Edward Batiste (C) Robert Cates, Harold Hall | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Mark Whetstone (PG) Jeffrey Cook | |
| 05:04 | Otterbein | James Brock clanks a 3pt shot from straight away | 25-29 |
| 05:02 | John Jay | John Ray snags the defensive board | 25-29 |
| 05:00 | John Jay | William Clement is called for the reach on James Bohm in the backcourt - foul #2 on William Clement, team foul #13 | 25-29 |
| Subs | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong (PG) George Stanford | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar (C) William Clement | |
| 05:00 | John Jay | James Bohm makes the 1st free throw | 26-29 |
| 05:00 | John Jay | James Bohm makes the 2nd free throw | 27-29 |
| 04:39 | Otterbein | Mark Watson's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 27-29 |
| Subs | John Jay | Jeff Spier (PF) James Bohm | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 04:23 | John Jay | John Ray connects on the open jumper from the left side | 29-29 |
| 04:02 | Otterbein | James Brock's pass is intercepted by Daniel Armstrong | 29-29 |
| 03:34 | John Jay | John Ray throws a bad pass out of bounds | 29-29 |
| Subs | John Jay | George Stanford (PG), Brian Newsome (SG), Richard Harvey (SF), Jeffrey Lahti (PF), Harold Hall (C) Daniel Armstrong, John Ray, David Carlson, Jeff Spier, Edward Batiste | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Shannon Ybarra (SG), Robert Vernon (SF), Mark Kimbrough (PF), Robert Jacobson (C) James Brock, Kelly McQuaid, Mark Watson, Michael Dunbar | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - George Stanford (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Brian Newsome (fresh) 4 pts. SF - Richard Harvey (fresh) 2 pts. 4 reb. PF - Jeffrey Lahti (fresh) 5 pts. C - Harold Hall (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Mark Whetstone (fairly fresh) 2 pts. SG - Shannon Ybarra (fresh) 2 ast. SF - Robert Vernon (fresh) PF - Mark Kimbrough (fresh) 2 reb. C - Robert Jacobson (fresh) 2 pts. | |
| 03:12 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Lahti denies the turnaround by Mark Whetstone | 29-29 |
| 03:11 | Otterbein | Mark Kimbrough pulls down the offensive rebound | 29-29 |
| 02:58 | Otterbein | Shannon Ybarra banks in the layup set up by Mark Kimbrough | 29-31 |
| 02:34 | John Jay | Richard Harvey misses short on a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 29-31 |
| 02:32 | Otterbein | Robert Vernon grabs the defensive rebound | 29-31 |
| 02:27 | Otterbein | Richard Harvey swats the short shot by Robert Vernon | 29-31 |
| 02:25 | Otterbein | Robert Jacobson gets the offensive rebound | 29-31 |
| 02:18 | Otterbein | Shannon Ybarra lays it in set up by Robert Vernon | 29-33 |
| 01:59 | John Jay | Harold Hall is fouled on the floor by Robert Jacobson - foul #3 on Robert Jacobson, team foul #14 | 29-33 |
| Subs | John Jay | Robert Cates (SG), David Carlson (SF), James Bohm (PF) Brian Newsome, Richard Harvey, Jeffrey Lahti | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook (PG), William Clement (SG), Michael Dunbar (C) Mark Whetstone, Shannon Ybarra, Robert Jacobson | |
| 01:59 | John Jay | Harold Hall makes the 1st free throw | 30-33 |
| 01:59 | John Jay | Harold Hall makes the 2nd free throw | 31-33 |
| 01:47 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook can't connect on a jump hook from the baseline | 31-33 |
| 01:45 | John Jay | Harold Hall snags the defensive board | 31-33 |
| 01:40 | John Jay | Robert Cates's pass is intercepted by Michael Dunbar in the backcourt | 31-33 |
| 01:30 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar misses short on a fadeaway near the basket but he's fouled by Harold Hall - foul #1 on Harold Hall, team foul #7 | 31-33 |
| Subs | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong (PG), Jeff Spier (C) George Stanford, Harold Hall | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 01:30 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar makes the 1st free throw | 31-34 |
| 01:30 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar misses the 2nd free throw | 31-34 |
| 01:30 | John Jay | James Bohm gets the rebound | 31-34 |
| 01:11 | John Jay | Mark Kimbrough blocks the short jumper by Robert Cates | 31-34 |
| 01:10 | Otterbein | Mark Kimbrough grabs the board | 31-34 |
| 01:06 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook is hacked by Daniel Armstrong - foul #1 on Daniel Armstrong, team foul #8 | 31-34 |
| 01:06 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook makes the 1st free throw | 31-35 |
| 01:06 | Otterbein | Jeffrey Cook makes the 2nd free throw | 31-36 |
| 00:47 | John Jay | Daniel Armstrong travels with the ball | 31-36 |
| Subs | John Jay | Richard Harvey (SF), Jeffrey Lahti (PF) David Carlson, James Bohm | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Kelly McQuaid (SF) Robert Vernon | |
| 00:34 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar hits the front of the rim on the jumpshot from just outside the lane but he's hacked by Daniel Armstrong - foul #2 on Daniel Armstrong, team foul #9 | 31-36 |
| Subs | John Jay | George Stanford (PG), John Ray (SG), Edward Batiste (C) Daniel Armstrong, Robert Cates, Jeff Spier | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Mark Whetstone (PG), Shannon Ybarra (SG) Jeffrey Cook, William Clement | |
| 00:34 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar makes the 1st free throw | 31-37 |
| 00:34 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar misses the 2nd free throw | 31-37 |
| 00:34 | John Jay | Edward Batiste gets the rebound | 31-37 |
| 00:13 | John Jay | Edward Batiste is hacked by Mark Whetstone - foul #2 on Mark Whetstone, team foul #15 | 31-37 |
| 00:13 | John Jay | Edward Batiste makes the 1st free throw | 32-37 |
| 00:13 | John Jay | Edward Batiste misses the 2nd free throw | 32-37 |
| 00:13 | Otterbein | Michael Dunbar grabs the defensive rebound | 32-37 |
| 00:00 | Otterbein | Mark Kimbrough misses the 3 pointer from the right corner | 32-37 |