| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Robert Houle (fresh) 6 pts. 2 ast. SG - Edwin Rebello (fresh) 3 pts. SF - David Barrientes (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. PF - Micah Cunningham (fresh) 4 reb. 2 blk. C - James Rutledge (fresh) 4 pts. 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Quincy Bowles (fresh) 3 pts. SG - Zachary Franks (fresh) 3 pts. 3 ast. SF - James Big (fresh) 4 pts. PF - Keith Ebron (fresh) 2 reb. C - Robert Smallwood (fresh) 6 pts. 3 reb. | |
| 20:00 | John Carroll | James Big inbounds the ball | 29-35 |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (0) | |
| 19:48 | John Carroll | James Big comes up short on the jumpshot from the free throw line | 29-35 |
| 19:47 | John Carroll | Quincy Bowles grabs the offensive board | 29-35 |
| 19:37 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron makes the pull-up jumper from just outside the lane and the foul's on Micah Cunningham - foul #2 on Micah Cunningham, team foul #1 | 29-37 |
| 19:37 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron misses the free throw | 29-37 |
| 19:37 | Muskingum | James Rutledge snags the defensive board | 29-37 |
| 19:26 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello misses the fadeaway jumper from the left side | 29-37 |
| 19:25 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood grabs the defensive rebound | 29-37 |
| 19:18 | John Carroll | Robert Houle is called for the reach on Keith Ebron - foul #1 on Robert Houle, team foul #2 | 29-37 |
| 19:00 | John Carroll | Edwin Rebello takes the ball from Robert Smallwood | 29-37 |
| 18:56 | Muskingum | Robert Houle lays it up and in set up by Edwin Rebello | 31-37 |
| 18:48 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood misses the 3 from the right wing | 31-37 |
| 18:46 | Muskingum | Robert Houle gets the rebound | 31-37 |
| 18:25 | Muskingum | James Rutledge misses long on a runner in the paint but the foul's on Quincy Bowles - foul #3 on Quincy Bowles, team foul #1 | 31-37 |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Paul Maddox (PG) Quincy Bowles | |
| 18:25 | Muskingum | James Rutledge makes the 1st free throw | 32-37 |
| 18:25 | Muskingum | James Rutledge makes the 2nd free throw | 33-37 |
| 18:13 | John Carroll | David Barrientes is called for the reach on James Big - foul #1 on David Barrientes, team foul #3 | 33-37 |
| 18:08 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks is hacked by Edwin Rebello - foul #2 on Edwin Rebello, team foul #4 | 33-37 |
| 17:58 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood comes up short on the shot from the left block | 33-37 |
| 17:56 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood misses the tip | 33-37 |
| 17:54 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to Robert Houle | 33-37 |
| 17:36 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello misses the 3pt jumper from the right corner | 33-37 |
| 17:34 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox gets the rebound | 33-37 |
| 17:18 | John Carroll | David Barrientes blocks the 3 pointer from the right wing by Zachary Franks | 33-37 |
| 17:17 | Muskingum | James Rutledge gets the rebound | 33-37 |
| 17:11 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello misses badly on a 3pt shot from the left corner | 33-37 |
| 17:09 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham tips it in | 35-37 |
| 17:04 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks comes up short on the fadeaway from the free throw line | 35-37 |
| 17:02 | Muskingum | James Rutledge grabs the defensive rebound | 35-37 |
| 16:40 | Muskingum | Keith Ebron steps in front of the Micah Cunningham pass | 35-37 |
| 16:22 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks is hacked by Edwin Rebello - foul #3 on Edwin Rebello, team foul #5 | 35-37 |
| Subs | Muskingum | John Perillo (PG), Horace Dunn (SG), John Poe (SF), Anthony Sigmon (PF), Michael Conley (C) Robert Houle, Edwin Rebello, David Barrientes, Micah Cunningham, James Rutledge | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Bale (PG), Franklin Bailey (SF), Michael Kulinski (PF), Paul Greenough (C) Zachary Franks, James Big, Keith Ebron, Robert Smallwood | |
| 16:10 | John Carroll | Michael Kulinski misses long on a fadeaway from the free throw line | 35-37 |
| 16:09 | Muskingum | John Perillo gets the rebound | 35-37 |
| 16:02 | Muskingum | Anthony Sigmon hits the front of the rim on the jump hook in the lane | 35-37 |
| 16:01 | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey grabs the defensive rebound | 35-37 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - John Perillo (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SG - Horace Dunn (fresh) SF - John Poe (fresh) 6 pts. PF - Anthony Sigmon (fresh) 5 pts. C - Michael Conley (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - John Bale (fresh) 9 pts. SG - Paul Maddox (fresh) 3 pts. SF - Franklin Bailey (fresh) 5 pts. 4 reb. PF - Michael Kulinski (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Paul Greenough (fresh) | |
| 15:47 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox hits the finger roll on a nice dish by Franklin Bailey | 35-39 |
| 15:27 | Muskingum | John Poe travels with the ball | 35-39 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Jason Choice (SF) Michael Conley | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Quincy Bowles (PG), Zachary Franks (SG) Paul Maddox, Paul Greenough | |
| 15:12 | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey banks in the layup on a great pass from John Bale and the foul's on John Poe - foul #1 on John Poe, team foul #6 | 35-41 |
| 15:12 | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey makes the free throw | 35-42 |
| 14:46 | Muskingum | John Perillo throws a bad pass out of bounds | 35-42 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Houle (PG), Micah Cunningham (PF) Horace Dunn, John Poe | |
| Subs | John Carroll | James Big (SF), Keith Ebron (PF) Zachary Franks, John Bale | |
| 14:25 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron connects on the jumper in the lane | 35-44 |
| 14:06 | Muskingum | Anthony Sigmon makes the 3pt shot from the right corner on a nice dish by Robert Houle | 38-44 |
| 13:53 | John Carroll | James Big connects on the 3pt jumper from straight away on a great pass from Quincy Bowles | 38-47 |
| 13:41 | Muskingum | Robert Houle scores on a shot in the lane and he's fouled by Franklin Bailey - foul #1 on Franklin Bailey, team foul #2 | 40-47 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello (SG), James Rutledge (C) John Perillo, Anthony Sigmon | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Paul Maddox (SG), Robert Smallwood (C) Franklin Bailey, Michael Kulinski | |
| 13:41 | Muskingum | Robert Houle makes the free throw | 41-47 |
| 13:25 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood's pass is intercepted by Micah Cunningham | 41-47 |
| 13:20 | Muskingum | Robert Houle misses short on a 3 pointer from the right wing | 41-47 |
| 13:18 | John Carroll | James Big pulls down the rebound | 41-47 |
| 13:13 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox can't connect on a 3 from the right wing | 41-47 |
| 13:11 | Muskingum | James Rutledge gets the rebound | 41-47 |
| 13:00 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham misses the lay-in but he's fouled by Keith Ebron - foul #3 on Keith Ebron, team foul #3 | 41-47 |
| Subs | Muskingum | David Barrientes (SF) Jason Choice | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Zachary Franks (SG), John Bale (SF), Franklin Bailey (PF) Paul Maddox, James Big, Keith Ebron | |
| 13:00 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham makes the 1st free throw | 42-47 |
| 13:00 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham misses the 2nd free throw | 42-47 |
| 13:00 | John Carroll | The rebound goes to Robert Smallwood | 42-47 |
| 12:50 | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey knocks in the fadeaway in the paint | 42-49 |
| 12:29 | Muskingum | James Rutledge hits the front of the rim on the jumper from close range | 42-49 |
| 12:27 | Muskingum | James Rutledge gets the offensive rebound | 42-49 |
| 12:16 | Muskingum | Robert Houle is hacked by Quincy Bowles - foul #4 on Quincy Bowles, team foul #4 | 42-49 |
| Subs | Muskingum | John Poe (SF), Anthony Sigmon (PF) Robert Houle, Micah Cunningham | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Paul Maddox (PG), Michael Kulinski (C) Quincy Bowles, Robert Smallwood | |
| 12:05 | Muskingum | David Barrientes is hacked by John Bale - foul #2 on John Bale, team foul #5 | 42-49 |
| 12:00 | Muskingum | John Poe misses long on a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 42-49 |
| 11:59 | Muskingum | James Rutledge pulls down the offensive rebound | 42-49 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - David Barrientes (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Edwin Rebello (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. 3 pf. SF - John Poe (fresh) 6 pts. PF - Anthony Sigmon (fresh) 8 pts. C - James Rutledge (fresh) 6 pts. 10 reb. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Paul Maddox (fresh) 5 pts. SG - Zachary Franks (fresh) 3 pts. 3 ast. SF - John Bale (fresh) 9 pts. 1 ast. PF - Franklin Bailey (fresh) 10 pts. 4 reb. C - Michael Kulinski (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 11:42 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello is called for a pushoff foul - foul #4 on Edwin Rebello, team foul #7 | 42-49 |
| Subs | Muskingum | John Perillo (SG), Jason Choice (SF) Edwin Rebello, John Poe | |
| Subs | John Carroll | James Big (SF), Keith Ebron (PF) John Bale, Franklin Bailey | |
| 11:29 | John Carroll | James Big misses short on a fadeaway jumper from the left side but he's hacked by Jason Choice - foul #4 on Jason Choice, team foul #8 | 42-49 |
| Subs | Muskingum | John Poe (SF), Michael Conley (C) Jason Choice, James Rutledge | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 11:29 | John Carroll | James Big makes the 1st free throw | 42-50 |
| 11:29 | John Carroll | James Big misses the 2nd free throw | 42-50 |
| 11:29 | Muskingum | John Poe gets the rebound | 42-50 |
| 11:10 | Muskingum | James Big is called for the reach on John Perillo - foul #2 on James Big, team foul #6 | 42-50 |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Bale (PG) Zachary Franks | |
| 10:52 | Muskingum | David Barrientes hits the finger roll on a nice dish by John Perillo and he's hacked by John Bale - foul #3 on John Bale, team foul #7 | 44-50 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Houle (PG), Micah Cunningham (PF) Anthony Sigmon, Michael Conley | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey (SG), Robert Smallwood (C) John Bale, Michael Kulinski | |
| 10:52 | Muskingum | David Barrientes makes the free throw | 45-50 |
| 10:39 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood misses badly on a 3pt attempt from the right corner | 45-50 |
| 10:37 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron can't tip it in | 45-50 |
| 10:36 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood can't tip it in | 45-50 |
| 10:35 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron snags the offensive board | 45-50 |
| 10:26 | John Carroll | James Big can't connect on a fadeaway in the paint but the foul's on David Barrientes - foul #2 on David Barrientes, team foul #9 | 45-50 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Rutledge (C) David Barrientes | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 10:26 | John Carroll | James Big makes the 1st free throw | 45-51 |
| 10:26 | John Carroll | James Big misses the 2nd free throw | 45-51 |
| 10:26 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to James Rutledge | 45-51 |
| 10:07 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham hits a runner in the lane | 47-51 |
| 09:49 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron misses the fadeaway from the left side | 47-51 |
| 09:47 | Muskingum | John Perillo grabs the defensive rebound | 47-51 |
| 09:22 | Muskingum | Keith Ebron is called for the reach on John Perillo - foul #4 on Keith Ebron, team foul #8 | 47-51 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Anthony Sigmon (PF) Micah Cunningham | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Bale (PG), Zachary Franks (SG), Michael Kulinski (PF), Paul Greenough (C) Paul Maddox, James Big, Keith Ebron, Robert Smallwood | |
| 09:22 | Muskingum | John Perillo misses the 1st free throw | 47-51 |
| 09:22 | John Carroll | Michael Kulinski grabs the defensive rebound | 47-51 |
| 09:13 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks can't connect on a jumpshot from the right side | 47-51 |
| 09:12 | Muskingum | James Rutledge grabs the board | 47-51 |
| 09:07 | Muskingum | John Poe clanks a fadeaway from the right wing but he's hacked by Franklin Bailey - foul #2 on Franklin Bailey, team foul #9 | 47-51 |
| Subs | Muskingum | David Barrientes (PG), Horace Dunn (SG), Michael Conley (C) Robert Houle, John Perillo, James Rutledge | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 09:07 | Muskingum | John Poe makes the 1st free throw | 48-51 |
| 09:07 | Muskingum | John Poe makes the 2nd free throw | 49-51 |
| 08:48 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks misses long on a turnaround from the baseline but the foul's on David Barrientes - foul #3 on David Barrientes, team foul #10 | 49-51 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Leo Dirksen (PG) John Poe | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Robert Nestor (PG) Franklin Bailey | |
| 08:48 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks misses the 1st free throw | 49-51 |
| 08:48 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks makes the 2nd free throw | 49-52 |
| 08:23 | Muskingum | Horace Dunn hits the front of the rim on the 3 from the right corner | 49-52 |
| 08:21 | John Carroll | The rebound goes to Michael Kulinski | 49-52 |
| 08:03 | John Carroll | John Bale scores on a shot from the left side on a great pass from Zachary Franks | 49-54 |
| 07:46 | Muskingum | Michael Conley misses the lay-in | 49-54 |
| 07:45 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks grabs the defensive rebound | 49-54 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Leo Dirksen (fresh) SG - Horace Dunn (fresh) SF - David Barrientes (fairly fresh) 5 pts. 1 ast. 3 pf. PF - Anthony Sigmon (fresh) 8 pts. C - Michael Conley (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Robert Nestor (fresh) 1 ast. SG - Zachary Franks (fresh) 4 pts. 4 ast. SF - John Bale (fresh) 11 pts. 1 ast. 3 pf. PF - Michael Kulinski (fresh) 2 pts. 4 reb. C - Paul Greenough (fresh) | |
| 07:29 | John Carroll | Horace Dunn is called for the reach on Zachary Franks - foul #1 on Horace Dunn, team foul #11 | 49-54 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Houle (PG), Edwin Rebello (SG), Jason Choice (SF), Micah Cunningham (PF), James Rutledge (C) Leo Dirksen, Horace Dunn, David Barrientes, Anthony Sigmon, Michael Conley | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Quincy Bowles (PG), James Big (SF), Keith Ebron (PF), Robert Smallwood (C) Robert Nestor, John Bale, Michael Kulinski, Paul Greenough | |
| 07:29 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks misses the 1st free throw | 49-54 |
| 07:29 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks makes the 2nd free throw | 49-55 |
| 07:10 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello comes up short on the jump hook from the left block but the foul's on Robert Smallwood - foul #1 on Robert Smallwood, team foul #10 | 49-55 |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Paul Maddox (SG) Zachary Franks | |
| 07:10 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello makes the 1st free throw | 50-55 |
| 07:10 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello makes the 2nd free throw | 51-55 |
| 06:54 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood banks in the layup on a great pass from Quincy Bowles | 51-57 |
| 06:45 | Muskingum | James Rutledge's fadeaway is rejected by Robert Smallwood | 51-57 |
| 06:44 | Muskingum | Jason Choice misses the tip | 51-57 |
| 06:43 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham tips it in | 53-57 |
| 06:29 | John Carroll | Quincy Bowles misses short on a 3 pointer from the left wing | 53-57 |
| 06:27 | Muskingum | James Rutledge gets the rebound | 53-57 |
| 06:08 | Muskingum | Jason Choice buries a 3 from the right wing on a nice dish by Robert Houle | 56-57 |
| 05:49 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood can't connect on a fadeaway from the free throw line | 56-57 |
| 05:48 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to Robert Houle | 56-57 |
| 05:28 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello hits the front of the rim on the runner from the right block but the foul's on Quincy Bowles - foul #5 on Quincy Bowles, team foul #11 | 56-57 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Anthony Sigmon (C) James Rutledge | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Zachary Franks (SG), Franklin Bailey (PF), Michael Kulinski (C) Quincy Bowles, Keith Ebron, Robert Smallwood | |
| 05:28 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello makes the 1st free throw | 57-57 |
| 05:28 | Muskingum | Edwin Rebello makes the 2nd free throw | 58-57 |
| 05:12 | John Carroll | James Big comes up short on the 3pt shot from the right wing | 58-57 |
| 05:11 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks tips it back up and in | 58-59 |
| 05:03 | Muskingum | James Big is called for the reach on Anthony Sigmon - foul #3 on James Big, team foul #12 | 58-59 |
| Subs | Muskingum | David Barrientes (SG), John Poe (SF) Edwin Rebello, Jason Choice | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Bale (SF) James Big | |
| 05:03 | Muskingum | Anthony Sigmon makes the 1st free throw | 59-59 |
| 05:03 | Muskingum | Anthony Sigmon makes the 2nd free throw | 60-59 |
| 04:59 | John Carroll | Robert Houle picks off the pass by Paul Maddox in the backcourt | 60-59 |
| 04:36 | Muskingum | David Barrientes is fouled on the floor by Zachary Franks - foul #1 on Zachary Franks, team foul #13 | 60-59 |
| Subs | Muskingum | John Perillo (SG), Michael Conley (C) Robert Houle, Micah Cunningham | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Paul Greenough (C) Paul Maddox | |
| 04:36 | Muskingum | David Barrientes makes the 1st free throw | 61-59 |
| 04:36 | Muskingum | David Barrientes misses the 2nd free throw | 61-59 |
| 04:36 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks snags the defensive board | 61-59 |
| 04:18 | John Carroll | Paul Greenough can't connect on a jump hook in the paint but the foul's on David Barrientes - foul #4 on David Barrientes, team foul #12 | 61-59 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Rutledge (C) Michael Conley | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Keith Ebron (PF) Michael Kulinski | |
| 04:18 | John Carroll | Paul Greenough makes the 1st free throw | 61-60 |
| 04:18 | John Carroll | Paul Greenough makes the 2nd free throw | 61-61 |
| 04:01 | Muskingum | Anthony Sigmon misses short on a 3 from straight away | 61-61 |
| 04:00 | John Carroll | Paul Greenough grabs the defensive rebound | 61-61 |
| 03:56 | John Carroll | John Bale hits the front of the rim on the 3 pointer from the left corner | 61-61 |
| 03:54 | Muskingum | John Poe pulls down the rebound | 61-61 |
| 03:42 | Muskingum | Zachary Franks steps in front of the John Poe pass | 61-61 |
| 03:39 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks lays it in | 61-63 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - David Barrientes (fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. 4 pf. SG - John Perillo (fresh) 3 pts. 2 ast. SF - John Poe (fresh) 8 pts. 3 reb. PF - Anthony Sigmon (fresh) 10 pts. C - James Rutledge (fresh) 6 pts. 13 reb. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - John Bale (fresh) 11 pts. 1 ast. 3 pf. SG - Zachary Franks (fresh) 9 pts. 4 ast. 2 stl. SF - Franklin Bailey (fresh) 10 pts. 4 reb. PF - Keith Ebron (fresh) 4 pts. 4 reb. 4 pf. C - Paul Greenough (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 03:13 | Muskingum | John Perillo makes the shot from the right side set up by Anthony Sigmon | 63-63 |
| 03:01 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks's fadeaway is rejected by James Rutledge | 63-63 |
| 03:00 | Muskingum | James Rutledge grabs the defensive rebound | 63-63 |
| 03:00 | Muskingum | Muskingum calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 63-63 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Houle (PG), Edwin Rebello (SG), Jason Choice (SF), Micah Cunningham (PF) David Barrientes, John Perillo, John Poe, Anthony Sigmon | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Paul Maddox (PG), James Big (SF), Robert Smallwood (C) John Bale, Franklin Bailey, Paul Greenough | |
| 02:52 | Muskingum | Robert Houle is fouled on the floor by Paul Maddox - foul #1 on Paul Maddox, team foul #14 | 63-63 |
| 02:52 | Muskingum | Robert Houle makes the 1st free throw | 64-63 |
| 02:52 | Muskingum | Robert Houle makes the 2nd free throw | 65-63 |
| 02:41 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks scores on a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane on a great pass from James Big and he's fouled by Edwin Rebello - foul #5 on Edwin Rebello, team foul #13 | 65-65 |
| Subs | Muskingum | David Barrientes (SG) Edwin Rebello | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 02:41 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks misses the free throw | 65-65 |
| 02:41 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to James Rutledge | 65-65 |
| 02:25 | Muskingum | Jason Choice comes up short on the 3 pointer from the right corner | 65-65 |
| 02:23 | John Carroll | The rebound goes to Robert Smallwood | 65-65 |
| 02:10 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron misses the floater from the free throw line | 65-65 |
| 02:08 | John Carroll | The offensive rebound goes to Robert Smallwood | 65-65 |
| 01:57 | John Carroll | A charge is called on Paul Maddox - foul #2 on Paul Maddox, team foul #15 | 65-65 |
| 01:34 | Muskingum | Robert Smallwood swats the short shot by David Barrientes | 65-65 |
| 01:33 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks gets the rebound | 65-65 |
| 01:24 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron misses short on a jumpshot from the free throw line | 65-65 |
| 01:23 | Muskingum | David Barrientes grabs the board | 65-65 |
| 01:09 | Muskingum | David Barrientes scores on a shot from the left side | 67-65 |
| 00:54 | John Carroll | James Big's layup is rejected by James Rutledge | 67-65 |
| 00:52 | John Carroll | James Big gets the offensive rebound | 67-65 |
| 00:37 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox drills a jumper from the free throw line set up by Zachary Franks | 67-67 |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (0) | |
| 00:16 | Muskingum | Jason Choice can't finish the layup | 67-67 |
| 00:14 | Muskingum | Jason Choice grabs the offensive rebound | 67-67 |
| 00:03 | Muskingum | David Barrientes misses long on a jumpshot from the left side | 67-67 |
| 00:02 | Muskingum | The offensive rebound goes to Micah Cunningham | 67-67 |
| 00:00 | Muskingum | The clock runs out | 67-67 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Robert Houle (fresh) 13 pts. 4 ast. 2 stl. SG - David Barrientes (fresh) 8 pts. 1 ast. 4 pf. SF - Jason Choice (fresh) 3 pts. 3 reb. 4 pf. PF - Micah Cunningham (fresh) 7 pts. 7 reb. 2 blk. 2 stl. C - James Rutledge (fresh) 6 pts. 15 reb. 3 blk. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Paul Maddox (fresh) 7 pts. SG - Zachary Franks (fresh) 11 pts. 5 ast. 2 stl. SF - James Big (fresh) 9 pts. 3 reb. 3 pf. PF - Keith Ebron (fresh) 4 pts. 4 reb. 4 pf. C - Robert Smallwood (fresh) 8 pts. 9 reb. 2 blk. | |
| 05:00 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood wins the tip | 67-67 |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (0) | |
| 04:51 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox throws a bad pass out of bounds | 67-67 |
| 04:26 | Muskingum | Robert Houle misses the 3pt shot from the left wing | 67-67 |
| 04:24 | Muskingum | James Rutledge tips it home | 69-67 |
| 04:16 | John Carroll | James Big misses the 3pt jumper from the right wing | 69-67 |
| 04:15 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to James Rutledge | 69-67 |
| 04:09 | Muskingum | Jason Choice travels with the ball | 69-67 |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey (SG) Zachary Franks | |
| 03:44 | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey makes the driving attempt from the baseline on a great pass from James Big | 69-69 |
| 03:28 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham hits a driving attempt from close range | 71-69 |
| 03:17 | John Carroll | David Barrientes is called for the reach on Franklin Bailey - foul #5 on David Barrientes, team foul #14 | 71-69 |
| Subs | Muskingum | John Perillo (SG), John Poe (SF), Anthony Sigmon (C) David Barrientes, Jason Choice, James Rutledge | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Michael Kulinski (C) Robert Smallwood | |
| 03:17 | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey makes the 1st free throw | 71-70 |
| 03:17 | John Carroll | Franklin Bailey makes the 2nd free throw | 71-71 |
| 03:00 | Muskingum | John Poe can't connect on a fadeaway jumper from the left side | 71-71 |
| 02:59 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox grabs the board | 71-71 |
| 02:59 | John Carroll | John Carroll calls a full timeout (2 :30 4 full remaining) | 71-71 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Jason Choice (SF) John Poe | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Zachary Franks (SG) Franklin Bailey | |
| 02:38 | John Carroll | James Big misses the 3pt jumper from the right wing | 71-71 |
| 02:37 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham pulls down the rebound | 71-71 |
| 02:37 | Muskingum | Muskingum calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 71-71 |
| Subs | Muskingum | James Rutledge (C) Anthony Sigmon | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood (C) Michael Kulinski | |
| 02:19 | Muskingum | Robert Houle buries a runner near the basket on a great pass from Micah Cunningham | 73-71 |
| 02:02 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron hits the front of the rim on the jumper in the lane but the foul's on Micah Cunningham - foul #3 on Micah Cunningham, team foul #15 | 73-71 |
| 02:02 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron misses the 1st free throw | 73-71 |
| 02:02 | John Carroll | Keith Ebron makes the 2nd free throw | 73-72 |
| 01:43 | Muskingum | Robert Houle hits a floater near the basket on a nice dish by Micah Cunningham | 75-72 |
| 01:34 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood clanks a jump hook near the basket but he's hacked by James Rutledge - foul #2 on James Rutledge, team foul #16 | 75-72 |
| 01:34 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood makes the 1st free throw | 75-73 |
| 01:34 | John Carroll | Robert Smallwood makes the 2nd free throw | 75-74 |
| 01:20 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham can't connect on a jump hook from the right block | 75-74 |
| 01:19 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox gets the rebound | 75-74 |
| 01:01 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox is fouled on the floor by Robert Houle - foul #2 on Robert Houle, team foul #17 | 75-74 |
| 01:01 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox makes the 1st free throw | 75-75 |
| 01:01 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox misses the 2nd free throw | 75-75 |
| 01:01 | Muskingum | John Perillo grabs the board | 75-75 |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Robert Houle (fresh) 17 pts. 4 ast. 2 stl. SG - John Perillo (fresh) 5 pts. 2 ast. SF - Jason Choice (fresh) 3 pts. 3 reb. 4 pf. PF - Micah Cunningham (fresh) 9 pts. 8 reb. 2 blk. 2 stl. 3 pf. C - James Rutledge (fresh) 8 pts. 17 reb. 3 blk. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Paul Maddox (fresh) 8 pts. SG - Zachary Franks (fresh) 11 pts. 5 ast. 2 stl. SF - James Big (fresh) 9 pts. 3 reb. 3 pf. PF - Keith Ebron (fresh) 5 pts. 4 reb. 4 pf. C - Robert Smallwood (fresh) 10 pts. 9 reb. 2 blk. | |
| 00:44 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham banks in the layup on a nice dish by Robert Houle | 77-75 |
| 00:31 | John Carroll | The jump hook by Zachary Franks is blocked by James Rutledge | 77-75 |
| 00:30 | Muskingum | Jason Choice grabs the board | 77-75 |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and intentionally fouling (0) | |
| 00:27 | Muskingum | Jason Choice is fouled in the backcourt by Paul Maddox - foul #3 on Paul Maddox, team foul #16 | 77-75 |
| 00:27 | Muskingum | Jason Choice makes the 1st free throw | 78-75 |
| 00:27 | Muskingum | Jason Choice makes the 2nd free throw | 79-75 |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and intentionally fouling (0) | |
| 00:23 | John Carroll | Robert Houle takes the ball from James Big | 79-75 |
| 00:20 | Muskingum | Robert Houle lays it in | 81-75 |
| 00:14 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox is hacked by Jason Choice - foul #5 on Jason Choice, team foul #18 | 81-75 |
| Subs | Muskingum | John Poe (SF) Jason Choice | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 00:14 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox makes the 1st free throw | 81-76 |
| 00:14 | John Carroll | Paul Maddox misses the 2nd free throw | 81-76 |
| 00:14 | Muskingum | Micah Cunningham grabs the board | 81-76 |
| 00:14 | Muskingum | Muskingum calls a full timeout (2 :30 2 full remaining) | 81-76 |
| 00:11 | Muskingum | Paul Maddox is called for the reach on John Poe in the backcourt - foul #4 on Paul Maddox, team foul #17 | 81-76 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Horace Dunn (SG) James Rutledge | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 00:11 | Muskingum | John Poe makes the 1st free throw | 82-76 |
| 00:11 | Muskingum | John Poe makes the 2nd free throw | 83-76 |
| 00:06 | John Carroll | Zachary Franks hits the front of the rim on the 3pt attempt from the left corner | 83-76 |
| 00:04 | Muskingum | John Poe pulls down the rebound | 83-76 |
| 00:04 | Muskingum | Muskingum calls a full timeout (2 :30 1 full remaining) | 83-76 |
| Subs | Muskingum | Michael Conley (C) Horace Dunn | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+2) | |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a halfcourt press/man to man (0) | |
| 00:00 | Muskingum | Robert Houle runs out the clock | 83-76 |